THE doctrine that “God from all eternity foreordained whatsoever comes to pass,” and that he elected certain individuals of our race to eternal salvation, and doomed the rest of mankind to eternal damnation, and this independent of their agency, is a doctrine that dishonors God, and must therefore be well-pleasing to his great enemy, Satan.
In discussing this subject, one said, “If it is as you say, that God fixed and established, or decreed, all the actions and conduct of all men from the beginning to the end of their life, and then makes them eternally miserable for doing nothing but what he eternally intended they should do, I cannot see for my life but that would make him out to be the wickedest being in the universe. . . . The devil may wish all mankind in hell, but he cannot send them there; he can tempt men to be wicked, but he cannot make them so. But, according to your doctrine, God makes men wicked, and then puts them to death and sends them to hell for being so.”
Infidels and skeptics use foreordination as a weapon with which to assail the Bible, as if it taught the doctrine, and to furnish an excuse for their unbelief and disobedience. But there is a class of believers who hesitate and delay obedience, because of this doctrine, claiming that they can do nothing for themselves; for if they are of the elect, God will bring them into the fold in due time, and if they are not of that chosen number, it is of no use for them to try.
Lorenzo Dow speaks of the effect of the doctrine upon two classes of minds as follows, if my memory has it right:—
“It is a bold serpentine scheme, It suits the serpent well, If he can make the sinner dream That he is doomed to hell. Or if he can persuade a man Decrees are on his side, Then he will say without delay, ‘This cannot be untied.’ The one he bindeth fast in pride; The other, in despair; If he can only keep them tied, Which way he does not care.”
God sets before us life and death, and asks us to choose life, that we may live. “The wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” Eternal life is promised to those who seek for it by patient continuance in well doing. God does not taunt us with the idea of choosing for ourselves, when he knows that our choosing can have no effect on the result, because all is decreed from the beginning. Particular election and reprobation is nowhere taught in the Bible; that is, as pertains to eternal salvation. All have the offer of this salvation, and they are the elect who accept the offer upon the given terms. Jesus Christ has become the author of eternal salvation to all them who obey him. Heb. 5:8. They are elected to eternal salvation who comply with the terms upon which it is freely offered.
But the doctrine of special election or predestination is taught in the Scriptures, though not in respect to salvation. God makes choice of certain individuals for certain particular purposes, in working out the great plan of salvation. And who has a better right? There must of necessity be a choice made of certain ones from among men, even from among the approved children of God, for certain purposes; since all cannot be taken for the same purposes. From among the children of Adam, Seth, Enos, Cainan, and so on down to Noah, were chosen to be the ancestors of the promised Christ. All could not have that honor, and it was for God to elect who should; and in making that election, others were of necessity passed by, though they might be equally worthy, and heirs of eternal salvation. Among the sons of Noah, Shem, who was not the oldest, was predestinated to the same honor, and of Shem’s descendants Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were chosen. Esau was born before Jacob; but before they were born, and consequently they had done no “good or evil, that the purpose of God according to election might stand,” it was said to their mother, “The elder shall serve the younger.” One of the two must be chosen as one of the line of the forefathers of Jesus Christ. Both could not be. Jacob was honored with the election. Esau was slighted, or passed by in this; but no injustice was done him. He was not predestinated to eternal damnation. Christ was given for him, though not through him, and he might accept of God’s arrangement, and be saved. The term “hated,” as it is now used, is too strong a term. When Jacob was chosen, Esau was slighted, or merely passed by.
Again, from among the righteous dead God saw fit to choose certain ones, foreknown to him, to be changed to the likeness of his Son by a resurrection from the dead and glorification in Heaven, before the time of the general resurrection, when all the sleeping saints will be changed to that image, being fashioned like unto his glorified body. See 1 John 3:2; Phil. 3:21; Col. 3:4.
A person is glorified in the full sense, I conclude, when admitted to the joys of Heaven and the presence of the Father. It is said, “The Holy Ghost was not yet given, because that Jesus was not yet glorified.” John 7:39. But when Jesus went to the Father, he sent the Holy Spirit to his disciples, according to his promise. John 16:7.
As I said, God determined to raise from the dead and glorify certain ones before the general resurrection and glorification of his people. He knew how to choose the ones for that especial purpose. Those that were passed by will have no cause of complaint. They came out of their graves after the resurrection of Christ. Matt. 27:52, 53. And though David was a man highly honored of God, I conclude that he was not one of the number, because after the Holy Spirit was given, Peter, speaking by that Spirit, said, “David is not ascended into the Heavens.” Acts 2:34. Let us hear the testimony:—
“For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren. [Christ was the firstborn from the dead (Rev. 1:5); after his resurrection, the elect company came forth from the dead.] Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called; and whom he called, them he also justified; and whom he justified, them he also glorified.” Rom. 8:29, 30. This company is spoken of again in Eph. 4:8. It is said of Christ, “When he ascended up on high, he led a multitude of captives.” Marginal reading.
Such is the election and predestination of the Scriptures. It is an election to some special purpose, not to eternal salvation and damnation. Even the wicked are sometimes placed in authority to fulfill certain purposes. “For the Scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might show my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth.” Rom. 9:17. Now this testimony is not that God made Pharaoh that he might damn him; but that he raised that wicked man to the throne of Egypt at a time when he would send his plagues upon Egypt and deliver Israel; so that the name and power of God might be published to the world.
It is objected: “God hardened Pharaoh’s heart.” Yes; but how did he do it? By showing him signs and wonders which attested God’s power, which he resisted; and by sending judgments or plagues, and then mercifully withdrawing them at his solicitation. Was it not right to leave such a blind and hardened sinner to his own ways, and make him an example to all the wicked rulers of the earth? Pharaoh hardened his own heart. “But when Pharaoh saw that there was respite, he hardened his heart, and hearkened not unto them, as the Lord had said.” Ex. 8:15. “And Pharaoh hardened his heart this time also, neither would he let the people go.” Verse 32. Pharaoh chose to rebel against God’s judgments, slight his mercies, and have his own way; and the Lord let him take his own course.
In conclusion: If God shall elect from among his people, from the living and from the dead, a company of 144,000, to whom he will give to witness the final conflict of the saints on earth with the powers of darkness, and their final deliverance, marking them for that purpose with his seal, while the winds of war are held, just before the time of trouble (Rev. 7:1–4), and translating them from among men on earth to Mt. Zion in the city of God, the heavenly Jerusalem (Rev. 14:1–5), giving them a place near the person of the Lamb of God, and a song to sing which is the song of their experience, a song that no other of the redeemed can sing, not one of the innumerable multitude of the redeemed will complain, nor envy the 144,000 that distinguishing honor. All will be satisfied with their portion, and with the Lord’s election and predestination.
But a personal part in this election is an exceedingly desirable thing. And if we would be of the number, we must, of our own free will, accept of the seal of God by keeping “the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus,” thus refusing the mark and worship of the beast. This you know you can do, if you choose.
R. F. COTTRELL.