AdventAI

The Destiny of the Impenitent.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 1., June 28, 1881

There seems to be a growing disbelief in the eternal conscious misery of the lost. Very many ministers are abandoning that hoary error. Some take a bold stand, and for preaching their honest sentiments, backed by the word of God, are brought before councils. In some cases they are even disfellowshipped for their “heterodox and dangerous” doctrines. Others, while admitting that they hold such views, hesitate to commit themselves. One of the former class, not long since, awakened considerable excitement in one of our large cities by a series of sermons disproving the doctrine of eternal conscious torment. In an interview with a Tribune reporter, he gave the following cogent reasons for his faith:—

I hold the view commonly called “conditional immortality,” i. e., that eternal life exists only in union with Jesus Christ. The argument will be from reason and Scripture.

I. Reason.—1. There is a difference between right and wrong, believers and sinners. They ought to be viewed differently by God, and treated accordingly.

2. It is evident that in the present state of things, vice is not always punished, nor virtue always rewarded. Hence a rectification is to be looked for,—a time of retribution.

3. In what will that retribution consist? I answer: In such punishment as shall be just and right, ending with extinction. Eternal torment is not just. It is excessive, and a just God cannot inflict it. Moreover, eternal torment implies eternal sinning, and eternal sinning involves a defeat of God. It would make the devil as powerful as God, and virtually says there are two Gods, one of evil and one of good.

4. All existing life in plants and animals shows that all such life has possibilities, but the attainment of those possibilities does not always follow. All blossoms are possible fruits, but only some come to fruition. All eggs are possible animals, but only some attain their destiny. So all men are possible immortals, but some fail to reach immortality.

5. We cannot by reason prove man immortal; the best we can do is to prove that he is capable of immortality.

II. Revelation.—But reason cannot prove much one way or the other. God knows what is before us, and has told us all we need to know. Hence we are to look to the Bible for satisfactory information.

1. The Bible uniformly promises life only to the righteous. “This is life eternal to know the only true God and Jesus.” “He that hath the Son hath life.” “He that believeth on the Son hath life.” “The wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life,” etc., etc.

2. The doom of the wicked is “destruction,” “perdition,” “everlasting death,” the “second death,” “to be burned up,” to “be as though they had not been,” “to vanish,” etc.

No deviation from these distinctions can be found anywhere in the Bible. Some texts, however, need attention.

Matt. 25:46: “These shall go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into life eternal.” Here “punishment” is shown to be just as long as “life,” i. e., eternal, but the punishment is destruction, which is complete, entire, final, and without remedy.

If it be objected that destruction is not punishment, I answer that the Bible says it is. “They shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord.”

If it be objected again that destruction cannot be properly called everlasting, I answer, The Bible calls it so. “They shall be punished with everlasting destruction.”

Mark 9:42: “Unquenchable fire.” This means fire which cannot be put out till it does its work. (See Isa. 34:10; Jer. 17:27; Eze. 20:47; Rev. 14:10.) “Smoke going up forever.” This refers to some punishment upon the beast before the Judgment day, and means total destruction.

Rev. 20:12, and the following verses, portray judgment. All who are not admitted to life are burned up, ended, destroyed. No sin is left anywhere in God’s universe. God becomes all in all.

If it be objected that the soul cannot be destroyed, I answer: “Fear Him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.”

This is a brief and very bold statement, but a diligent student of the Bible who compares text with text, will readily see that from the day death was threatened to the sinning Adam, the Bible is uniform in presenting the truth. “He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life, and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life.” John 3:36.

I think that the notion of the necessary immortality of souls came into the church from paganism, through Neo-Platonism, in the third century.