AdventAI

DISCUSSION IN COMPTON, P. Q.

By A. C. Bourdeau

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 1., June 28, 1881

A discussion on the Sabbath question between Eld. D. T. Bourdeau and Eld. Miles Grant was held in the Free Baptist church at Moe’s river, in the township of Compton, P. Q., on the evenings of June 13, 14, 15, and 16. The attendance was large, and the interest extraordinary. The second evening there was a thunder-shower, and the rain fell in torrents; yet the people came en masse. Said a Methodist clergyman, “I have never witnessed such an interest.” We could not ask for a more complete victory in favor of the Bible Sabbath than was gained at this discussion.

The question was, “Do the Scriptures teach that the Sabbath of the fourth commandment is still binding?” Eld. Bourdeau affirmed, and Eld. Grant denied. According to the ninth rule of the regulations, it was the duty of the chairman, in harmony with the moderators, who had chosen him, to preserve order, hold the speakers to the question, and see that the regulations of the discussion were carried out. The affirmative led out, and gave the closing speech.

At the outset, Eld. Grant intimated that he would say whatever he pleased, without regard to what he had signed. Accordingly, he essayed to bring the “visions” on the stand, and to give a prejudicial history of the Seventh-day Adventists. But he was immediately called to the question. The chairman afterward read the rules, stated that they had been violated, and said positively that he would hold the speakers to the question. The said chairman was a first-day man, and a phrenological lecturer.

The debate went on pleasantly, without any further break of this kind, till the third evening. The affirmative clearly substantiated his position, presenting ample Scriptural proof. He also showed, according to Eld. Grant’s own admission, that there is “only one weekly Sabbath mentioned in the Bible;” that there is no Scriptural authority for the observance of Sunday as the Sabbath; and that Eld. G. was trying to demolish that “only” Bible Sabbath, and to build up Sunday-keeping, alleging that we needed no command for its observance, but that we should keep the first day as a voluntary offering to the Lord. At this point of the discussion, Eld. G. felt the need of history to make his statements clear. Hence, in the third session, he again departed from the rules in attempting to quote the Fathers. He was again called to order by one of the moderators for introducing matter foreign to the question. But he paid no attention, whereupon the president left the chair. On noticing this, Eld. G. ceased speaking, and took a vote of the congregation to ascertain if they wanted to hear the proof from history. About one-eighth of the congregation, we should judge, voted in favor of hearing from history; and one or two hands were raised against. Evidently the candid and larger portion of the congregation would not vote on a question that was intended to lead the speakers to break their rules. The president did not indorse Eld. G.’s proceedings as lawful or in place.

Eld. Bourdeau had said that he stood ready to hold another discussion with Eld. Grant on the Sabbath question from the standpoint of history; but rather than to have the present discussion break up here, he proposed to let the Elder go to history. What was quoted from the Fathers and history was easily met.

In his next to the last speech Eld. G. seemed like one who had not much more to say; for he carelessly and slowly presented a redundancy of testimony, and, apparently to wear away the time, read about a score of passages containing the word “forever,” to show that it signified a limited duration, etc. He introduced no new matter in his last speech, as he had been very careful to reserve the privilege of doing.

In his last speech, Eld. Bourdeau pointed out more than a score of inconsistencies in the positions that the negative had taken, which it would seem all could readily see. We have reason to believe that many honest souls have become favorably inclined to the truth as the result of this discussion.

A. C. BOURDEAU.