The following is the concluding portion of a home-missionary sermon delivered by Dr. Goodwin:—
There is one more peril which confronts us, and puts an emphasis not possible to be exaggerated into the appeal for home evangelization. I mean the peril of
ROMAN CATHOLICISM.
The time was when, in common with many, I looked upon all that was said about the antagonism of the papacy to our free institutions as the outcry of bigotry or of foolish alarm. I cherished even the strong hope that the Romish church, modified somewhat by American ideas, might become an ally in propagating the gospel. But I parted company, long since, with all such impressions and expectations. And the more I have studied the nature of Romanism and the history of its workings, and have taken note of its attitude and spirit in our own country, the more positive and deep has become my conviction that, taken as a system, it is alike the deadly foe of our Christianity, our civilization, and our free government.
I may not tax you at this hour with any analysis of Romanism as a faith, or any extended argument concerning its spirit and record in the past. I simply plant myself on the facts that cannot be denied, and insist that no alternative is left us, that as lovers of the gospel and of our country we must take the attitude of avowed hostility to Rome. Mr. Mackenzie, summing up in his “History of the Nineteenth Century” the marvels that have been wrought and the failures experienced, comes, nearly at the close of the volume, to a discussion of the papacy, and he uses this language:—
“When, after one’s mind has been occupied with the splendid activities of the age, with its mechanical greatness, its humane disposition, its vindication of individual rights, its eagerness to educate and elevate, he turns to the investigation of the papacy, he breathes the air of buried centuries. The progress of man is reprobated and forbidden as a thing offensive to Heaven. Eternal hostility to the civilization which is deemed the glory of the century, is announced with copious and energetic malediction by the spiritual chief of two hundred million Christians.”—History of the Nineteenth Century, p. 433.
WHAT THE POPE SAYS.
And he has ample reason for such charge. He has the authority of the pope himself. In his letter to the ill-fated Maximilian, written in 1864, when that prince was expected to become Emperor of Mexico, he says: “Your Majesty is well aware that the Catholic religion must, above all things, continue to be the glory and the mainstay of the Mexican nation, to the exclusion of every dissenting worship; that no person may obtain the faculty of teaching and publishing false and subversive tenets; that instruction, whether public or private, should be watched over by ecclesiastical authority.”—Cook’s Orthodoxy, pp. 4, 5. Such language is unequivocal. It means all public schools suppressed, and none allowed except the schools of the church. It means more: that if the pope can have his way, Torquemada’s Inquisition shall be again set about its missionary work, and the watchword of the Propaganda now, as then, be, the papacy or death. But the pope has put himself on record still more emphatically. In his Encyclical of thep. 148 same year with the letter (1864), designed for the guidance and encouragement of the faithful, Pius IX specifies eighty distinct heresies, and thunders at them the pontifical anathema. Among these heresies is the opinion that “the pope ought to be reconciled to progress, liberalism, and modern civilization.” As the vicegerent of God, he anathematizes these. Also the opinion that “civil liberty of worship and freedom of the press do not conduce to the corruption of morals.” And he curses with special emphasis “all societies for circulating the Scriptures, and all persons not members of the true church who presume to entertain any hope of salvation for themselves or other misbelievers.” This language abundantly justifies Mr. Mackenzie’s conclusion, that by such utterances Rome “condemns Heaven’s law of progress, and seeks to lay enduring arrest upon its operation. Thus she broke finally with the nineteenth century, and declared her antagonism to all its maxims, its aims, and its achievements.”—History of the Nineteenth Century, p. 439.
“And this hostility to progress is peculiarly and of necessity hostility to free institutions. To lodge sovereignty in men is, of course, to recognize authority that is above the church. Hence Cardinal Manning does not hesitate to say that the principle that all men are created free and equal, and are by nature endowed with the right of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, is the first lie of the age.”—North American Review, February, 1880. In his view—and this is the radical theory of the papacy—men can have no rights except such as the church bestows; and to her, always and alone, supreme allegiance is due. Mr. Gladstone is right, therefore, when he affirms that the doctrine of the papacy is at war with all true loyalty in every government. And Bismarck and the French Ministry are right, as the authorities in so many other countries have been, in excluding the Jesuits, who are the zealous apostles everywhere of this doctrine of the supreme sovereignty of the Vatican. And still more to our purpose, Mr. Froude is right in insisting that “Romanism is as inconsistent with a republican form of government as slavery was.”
FACTS IN NEW MEXICO.
But we have more convincing proof than the logic of Romish principles supplies. We have an array of facts at our own doors which illustrates alike its spirit and its fruit. We need not go to Italy, where only one-fifth of the people are able to read, and brigandage abounds; nor to Spain, where only one-fourth can read, and the progress of civilization is practically unknown; nor to Portugal, where only one in thirty-six of the children are in school; we need only to go to New Mexico to show what the character of this new West will be if Roman Catholicism secures the shaping of it, as with all its prodigious energies and resources it is seeking to do.
For three hundred years, ever since the Spanish occupation, the papacy has had absolutely undisputed sway. There has been ample time, therefore, for its fruits to appear, and for it to show what it can and will do, when unhindered, for the civilization and ennoblement of a people. What, then, is the condition of New Mexico, with its population of 130,000 to 140,000 after three centuries of papal domination? Prof. Strieby writes me from Santa Fé, that “among the Mexican part of the population”—one hundred thousand strong—“there is no such thing as morality.” Then, thinking this statement too sweeping, he adds: “Chastity is rare among the common people. The unmarried women with their children at their heels gossip and visit on equal footing with their friends and relatives. No barrier opposes such immorality; no social odium attaches to it. More than all, these very women who lead such lives are most strict in their observance of religious duties, and pride themselves on their devoutness. Moreover, I cannot learn that any denunciations of such practices come from the Romish Church in New Mexico. And this is not a matter of wonder, for the priesthood is involved in like crime.” As a fact that falls in with this, the statement of President Tenney may be added, that a few years ago the immoralities of the Spanish priests throughout the Territory became so gross and outrageous, that the archbishop displaced them all, and filled the vacancies with priests imported, for the purpose, from France. It would seem from Prof. Strieby’s account, that the time has come for another importation!
But I may not dwell further on this theme. When the Jesuits were driven out of Berlin, they boasted that they would plant themselves in the Western Territories of America. They are there to-day, and there with a plan of empire. They have more colleges, more theological seminaries, the land over, than any of our Protestant denominations, and their chief increase is in the West. President Tenney says they have multiplied schools and churches in California faster than the Protestants. Superintendent Warren writes me from that State that “the Roman Catholic power is fast becoming an overwhelming evil. Their schools are everywhere, and number probably two thousand in the State. Their new college of St. Ignatius is, we are told, the largest, finest, best equipped of its kind in the United States. Thirty years ago, when Protestants entered the Golden Gate, there were twenty-one old ‘missions’ fast falling into decay. It is not so now. Three years ago the property of the Roman Catholic Church in San Francisco outvalued the sum total of the Protestant churches, parsonages, asylums, schools, and Young Men’s Christian Associations, by $47,000. To-day the excess is probably more than three times as much. They blow no trumpets, are sparing with statistics, but are at work night and day to break down the institutions of the country, beginning with the public schools. As surely as we live, so surely will the conflict come, and it will be a hard one.” Dr. Atkinson writes in words of like emphasis from Oregon.
Such, friends, is the outlook. I do not believe I am a bigot, but when I pass in review the facts as to papal influences furnished by our own country, especially from these States and Territories of the new West; when I consider the attitude of the Roman Church as to our common schools; her scheming for public patronage; her avowed contempt for all institutions not under her control; her hostility to all unchurchly influences of enlightenment and progress; her willing compacts with superstition and ignorance, and even immorality, in order to secure her ends; her recognition of no supreme loyalty except to the pope—I say to you frankly that I fear the man wearing the tiara, and who, sitting by the Tiber with two hundred millions of people to obey his nod, says, “America is the hope of Rome.”
Fellow-citizens of America, fellow-disciples of the Lord Jesus Christ, I venture this prophecy: Unless our faces are set as a flint to go up at once and possess that fair land of promise that stretches from the mountains to the sea, this hoary, gospel-hating, freedom-hating tyrant of the centuries, will, in the next generation, have his throne planted there. May God help us to prevent it!
Pausing here—though so much remains unsaid—and considering the ground that has been passed over; the vastness of this imperial field; its fast developing and amazing resources; its multiplying population, and its hence prodigious and increasing needs; its perils of irreligion, apostasy, infidelity, skepticism, paganism; its perils of socialism and political demagogism; its perils of Mormonism and Roman Catholicism—what immense responsibilities roll down upon us as patriots and as Christians! I do not wonder that Gen. Eaton, our United States Commissioner of Education, facing continually these facts, writes me that in his opinion “this is the crucial hour of the republic;” and he might have added, of our American Christianity, with equal truth.
As I take in these mighty interests which this question of home evangelization covers, and look into the coming years, a solemnity as of the great things of God oppresses my heart. I am profoundly sure that there is no possibility of over-estimating the necessities of the hour. The character of these fast-multiplying millions will be settled, and settled past essential change, within the next decade. In the quick soil of American free thought, beliefs mature fast; and with the shaping of these beliefs will go the shaping of the States that one after another will assume the functions of self-government. Utah and New Mexico with 140,000 people each, Montana with 50,000, Idaho with 30,000, Arizona with 50,000, Washington Territory with 60,000, will not long be content to stay without the sisterhood of the States. I should not be surprised if we had ten new States added to the Union in as many years. And as such developments take place, more and more will the destinies of the nation hang upon the ballots cast beyond the Rocky Mountains.
HOW SHALL WE MEET THESE ISSUES?
Folding our hands and talking serenely about the sure progress of the age, the sure triumph of our free institutions, the sure spread of Christianity, will avail nothing. The progress of the age. By the witness of all history, the civilizations of all time, whatever their science or art, or culture or wealth, or refinement, except as the supernatural, omnipotent might of God has interposed, have tended inevitably downward to the thick night of lust, and tyranny, and godlessness, and ruin. Witness the civilizations of Egypt, and Phœnicia, and Assyria, and Greece, and Rome, once illumining the world with their splendors, and then wrecked by their own self-engendered vices and crimes.
The sure triumph of our free institutions! We could not bear the strain of one more presidential election to be settled as was that of President Hayes; and a half century of advance along the line of the last fifty years would have such mill-stones of knavery, and corruption, and demagogism, and infidelity, and Sabbath-breaking, and immorality about our necks as would sink us out of sight in the depths of our own self-created shame.
The sure progress of Christianity? But even the pillar of fire turned back when the people refused to obey God! The effulgence of the first five centuries of gospel triumph was swallowed up and lost in the ten centuries of the thick and almost hopeless mediæval night of formalism and unbelief. There is no guaranty of the outward progress of Christianity except as the disciples of the Lord keep repeating its Pentecost upon their knees, keep repeating the aggressions of its first adherents by like consecration of their substance, like devotion to the word and the work of Jesus Christ.