AdventAI

The Human If.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 11., September 6, 1881

How pathetic those words of Martha, “Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died.” How certainly human is that if. Let us think about it a little.

It is the language of finiteness. Finiteness must dwell in the mood subjunctive. It cannot dwell in the mood indicative, the mood of certainty and decision. Man is very great and strong, but he is not so great or strong that he is not sure, sooner or later, to come to the limit of his strength and be obliged to say this human if.

“Moscow! Moscow!” the French soldiers shouted. They shouted it almost as shipwrecked sailors shout, The harbor. They had traversed the dreary plains of Lithuania. They had been fighting with fearful losses and against fearful odds. This was the limit of their long and terrible battling. They had reached the long, low line of the Sparrow Hills, and gazing down on the flat landscape, they saw far off the glittering domes and minarets of Moscow. No wonder they of the legions shouted. So again the star of their great leader had shone undimmed. So once more he had led them through victory unto rest. Moscow was their rest.

But how mistaken they were! Great as their leader was, he had not thought of fire. He had not thought the Russian purpose possible to give their sacred and ancestral city to the flames. But the flames changed their victory to ashes, and then that retreat amid the snows of a Russian winter followed, which for terror and destruction has been unparalleled in history. “Sire,” a woman had dared to say to the great Napoleon as he went haughtily forth on this great expedition, “man proposes, but Providence disposes.” “I propose and dispose too,” answered the victor of a hundred fights. And then even for him the if; if he had not undertaken the conquest; if he had not dared such a season; if he had foreseen the possibility of such a desperate conflagration.

The truth is, this human if belongs to finiteness. It is God only who need never say it. How strong soever a man may think himself; what confidence soever he may put in his well-laid plans; how puissant soever he may imagine his brain and arm—some decision which must take into account that future into whose thick mists his eye cannot pierce, some complication or danger concerning which his sagacity cannot make estimate, shall force him into the utterance of this helpless and torturing if. Like Mary and Martha, he shall find himself where his sorest need is the presence of another and a higher power, which, coming not, shall leave him but disaster and defeat.

This human if is the language of regret. How often we hear it,—If I had only given that other remedy, if I had only changed physicians, or if I had not changed them. If I had only trusted those promises, or if I had not trusted them. If, if, if—but you have done as you did. You cannot change the facts, sad as they may be. But regret cannot help looking sadly back and muttering this comfortless if, if.

Also this human if is the language of reproach. In many cases it should be the language of reproach. Where the if points toward results that might have been foreseen and ought to have been provided against, it should mean terrible and lashing reproach. Here is a young man standing on the threshold of life. He is solicited by temptation. He will yield, he says. He does yield. He is warned. He goes on yielding. He flatters himself that though such things as he is doing do hurt other men, they will not hurt him. He knows that he has laid to his soul the flattering unction of a lie. But he goes on yielding. Time goes on too, and he begins to reap the harvest of the seed he has been sowing. His reputation shrivels because he has honey-combed his character. He ought to be in the fullness of a manly prime, in the noon of his strength and faculty, but he is really aged before his time, and trembling and unable. He looks back, and his reproach must be this if. He is obliged to say, “If I had not yielded. If I had not burned my youthhood out so that my manhood has no substance it can draw upon.” The saddest thing in the wide world is this rightfully and terribly reproachful word if.

But the question comes, Is this all there is for us in our poor lives—Martha’s sad, wondering, finite, regretful if? If it be, there is small comfort in it; there is small courage in it; there is slight foundation for our poor lives to stand on.

It is to this helpless, comfortless if, much of the modern thinking would shut us up. Professor Huxley says, “Life is a chessboard, and men are players; and if, even with the best intentions in the world, you make a false move, there is nothing for you but the consequences. No hope, no meaning, no goal. Nothing for you but sorrow if you have mistaken or sinned.”

But thank God, we are not left to modern thinking. “Therefore his sister sent unto him saying, Lord, behold, he whom thou lovest is sick.” When Jesus heard this he said, “This sickness is not unto death, but for the glory of God, that the Son of God might be glorified thereby.” Here is God’s answer to the if of Martha. O soul, concerning many things, you, with your short sight, must say if. But in it all and through it all, God has meaning—his glory, your highest good. It was better that Lazarus die and then by the word of Christ be raised, than that he get well, and those sisters and all of us miss the vision of that resurrection. This is God’s answer to our ifs: Through what you are questioning so sadly, I am weaving glorious culmination.

There is only one if concerning which this cannot be said, namely, the rightfully reproachful. And yet for that there is forgiveness, and if into the results of that we introduce the new force Jesus Christ, he will somehow change even that darkness into day.

When we are cast into the saying of these ifs, let us lighten our gloom by thinking more of God and less of them.

Let us get the mastery over our human if by submission to the will of God.

“I have no cares, O blessed Will, For all my cares are thine. I live in triumph, Lord, for thou Hast made thy triumph mine.”

Let us by rational choice make God the center of our lives, and not our self-strength or skill the best word for which is this poor if. This is God’s message: Choose me, and all things shall work together for good—there shall really be no if about them.—Illustrated Christian Weekly.