We propose in the present article, and perhaps in one or two to follow, an examination into the methods pursued by Roman Catholic missions in China, and the results attained by them. We will look first at the early history of those missions, taking, as the main witness in the case, Abbé Huc, who ought to be considered good Catholic authority. We find a good starting-point in a letter from Jean de Monte Corvino to the Vicars-General of the Dominicans and Franciscans, dated 8th January, 1305. . . .
This letter brings clearly into view three of the methods energetically employed by the missions in those days: 1. To ingratiate themselves into the favor of the emperor, and acquire all possible influence with the royal family. 2. To use this influence to gather about them large numbers of converts, and to get young lads under their training. No reference appears to be made to any conversion of heart and life; but they are baptized, and then set to studying Greek and Latin literature. 3. To take advantage of the pomp of external ceremonies to impress the people. The “Prince” is very readily admitted to minor orders, and special mention is made of his appearing in his royal robes to assist in the services. One would suppose that when he became a priest at the altars of the church, his robes of earthly rank might be laid aside. If Prince Leopold should take orders in the Church of England, he would hardly be expected to appear within the chancel clothed with the insignia of royalty; but when Romanism captured a member of the imperial family, it utilized all the grandeur of his rank to impress the minds of the common people and win them to the faith.
The course of Corvino in all these matters, doubtless, had the approval of the Pope, for in 1307 Clement V. made him Archbishop of Peking, and placed him at the head of all the missions in the extreme East.
In 1326 André de Pérouse wrote from Kai-tong (supposed by Huc to be Hang-chow): “The idolaters come in great numbers to be baptized; but many of them do not in reality live according to Christianity.” This frank statement of the good father might have been made in all candor by the most of his brethren in those days. It could not reasonably be expected of converts gathered as they were that they would exemplify the power of Christianity in their lives.
At Macao, Father Ricci, one of the most eminent leaders of the more modern Jesuit missions, sought to influence the Chinese to favorable views of Christianity by making a map to gratify their national conceit, in which China was represented as the “Middle Kingdom.” Trigault says: “In truth, by this decoy many Chinese were drawn to the bosom of the church. . . . I will not either omit to mention a contrivance of his to gain the good graces of the Chinese. They believe that the sky is round, but the earth square, and that their empire is situated in the midst of it; and they are, for this reason, very angry when they find our geographers, in their maps, putting it in a corner in the extreme east. Now, they are not capable of understanding any mathematical demonstration by which it might be proved to them that the earth and sea together form a globe, and that, by the nature of the spherical figure, there can be neither beginning nor end to it. He, therefore, altered a little our plan for maps of the world, and, by placing the first meridian of the Fortunate Isles at the margin, right and left, he brought the empire of China into the center, to their great satisfaction.” Father Trigault adds, as Huc well says, “with great naïveté”: “Truly one could not at that time have found an invention more calculated to dispose this people to receive the mysteries of our religion.” This reveals another method, and one that Rome has always been ready to employ, viz., pandering to the prejudices of the people in order to make headway among them.
For a while Father Ricci adopted the dress of the bonzes, supposing that it would best serve his purposes to appear in the garb of the priests of heathenism; but, finding that the literati had far more influence with the people than the bonzes, he readily adopted the garb of that class, and the missionaries, who had shaved their heads as bare as those of the bonzes, allowed their hair and beard to grow again.
At Nanking, Fathers Ricci and Cataneo decided to pave the way for the gospel by natural science and mathematics. Trigault says: “God has not through all ages made use of the same methods to draw men to his law; and we need not be surprised if our brethren [the Jesuits] made use of this bait to attract fish to their net.” The experiment of leading men through science to the gospel would have been freed from some objections if the science taught had been true; but, unfortunately, Ricci was not always able to give the truth in place of Chinese errors, and his teachings have made it somewhat awkward for some of his successors, as Huc testifies:—
“The missionaries of our day have sometimes been considerably embarrassed, when the Chinese talked to them of Father Ricci’s four elements and other physical theories, which were found interwoven with his moral and doctrinal works.”
Father Cataneo made a visit to Macao and returned, not only with money, but with “pictures, glass vases, linen cloths, clocks, maps, hour-glasses, mirrors,” etc., of which Trigault remarks: “All which things are necessary in the beginning, and serve as oil wherewith to grease the wheels of affairs, that they may roll more softly.” Here is another method, very like that of the teacher who gives a child candy for learning his lesson. This sort of oil would make the gospel wheels roll very softly in many places.
Father Lombard’s methods in the country regions are described by Huc as follows:—
“When he was about to preach in a village, he used to send off, some days before, a zealous neophyte, to announce the arrival of a missionary, and prepare the ground for the evangelical seed. The Father then presented himself, and, after exhorting the assembled people, gave them a summary explanation of the Decalogue and the principal articles of the Christian faith. Those who were seriously struck by what they heard were then asked to write down their names, and an altar was prepared, above which was placed an image of our Saviour, wax lights were kindled, and some prayers chanted, after which the new catechumens received a catechism from the missionary and promised to renounce their idols and superstitions. . . . A day was then appointed for their baptism, and as much pomp and solemnity as possible given to the ceremony. The neophytes were invited from all the country round, and, at the conclusion of the festival, the newly-baptized were escorted home, to the accompaniment of music, and with a procession like that which attends a mandarin.”
On this, Huc remarks that Catholicism “is not of a narrow, exclusive spirit, but willingly accommodates itself to whatever is harmless and allowable in the peculiar customs of various nations. Religion does not destroy national any more than individual character. It only improves and sanctifies it.”
No one who has observed the fondness of the Chinese for display, and the great attraction that processions have for them, will wonder that baptism to the accompaniment of music and procession with a procession were found to act like a charm in making converts; nor will he be surprised that the accommodating spirit of Romanism to that which is “harmless and allowable” proved a great success. It is not difficult to believe that “the list of catechumens and neophytes at the Mission of Tchao-tcheou rapidly increased,” especially when it is added that “the ceremonies of the Catholic worship were everywhere performed with splendor, more particularly that of the baptism of adults.”
Neither will any such observer be surprised to learn that, under the violent opposition of the literati, “the fearful and pusillanimous catechumens would withdraw, through fear of compromising themselves, and neophytes would often recant their recent profession of faith.”
We come now to a more important matter. The great question of ancestral worship is to be met. Ricci has shown such an intense spirit of accommodation that we are not much surprised to find him adopting the view that the Chinese worship of ancestors is of a purely civil nature, manifesting their veneration and filial love, and not incompatible with Christianity. Under the same broad shield of questionable charity it was easy to take in, as he did, the worship of Confucius; and so the spectacle was presented of Chinese Christians worshiping their ancestors and Confucius, along with the Virgin Mary and the Saviour! This was truly letting the bars down pretty low; Christianity made exceedingly easy! His successor, Lombard, took the opposite view, and a great controversy arose among the adherents of the two sides.
* * *
In 1699 the Jesuits of Peking besought a decision from the Emperor as to the character of the rites, desiring to get his influential testimony as to the facts involved. He decided according to their wishes. Notwithstanding this, in 1704 Pope Clement XI. decided against the rites, as being superstitious and idolatrous. His legate found himself in difficulties, on his arrival at Peking, as to promulgating a decision of a foreign potentate contrary to the decision of the Emperor. This led to adverse proclamations, and eventually to the banishment of the Roman Catholic missionaries.
We have thus presented a view of the methods pursued by early Roman Catholic missions in China, showing them to be very much of the same versatile, shifting, accommodating character as those for which Rome has been noted in all ages and among various nations.
As to results, it is very difficult to get accurate and reliable information. Marshall says that, in 1761, when the missionaries were restored, through the influence of Father Verbiest, “in that single year more than 20,000 Chinese were converted.” It is reported that in fourteen years 100,000 were baptized. The Dominican Lopez is reported to have baptized twice that number with his own hand. Under Yung-Ching, the successor of Kang-hi, we are told that “more than 300,000 Christians were abandoned to the fury of the heathen.” In 1805 Sir George Staunton estimated the number of Roman Catholics in China at 200,000. In 1840 Huc gives the number as 800,000, while Commodore Read estimates it at 583,000.—S. L. Baldwin, D. D., Missionary in Fuchan, in Independent.