AdventAI

Reasons for Keeping Sunday.

By Eld. R. S. Owen

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 12., September 13, 1881

BY ELD. R. S. OWEN.

As the claims of the fourth commandment have been presented to the people of Waterbury, Vt., and the seventh day shown to be the only true Sabbath of the Bible, many, being very reluctant to yield up the long-cherished Sunday-Sabbath, have eagerly sought for evidence to establish first-day observance. The Bible has been searched in vain for the proof texts. Just at this trying hour, their hopes were brightened by the announcement that Eld. Wilkins, the Baptist minister, would preach a sermon giving the “reasons for keeping the first day of the week.” This was done in two discourses, to each of which we replied on the evenings following. That others may have the benefit of these “reasons,” we give his main positions and our replies.

1. “God’s seventh day was man’s first day; hence it was the first day of the week that was sanctified, the identical Sunday we now keep. Man must have been created just before sundown on the sixth day.”

This position rests upon two absurdities,—(1.) The supposition that God not being capable of reckoning the days of the week, the week could not commence till man’s creation! If God could tell us when the first, second, third, etc., days of the week came, why not accept his reckoning as given in Gen. 1? It was the act of God alone that divided time into weeks. (2.) That man was created “just before sundown on the sixth day,” so that as he opened his eyes, the first day he saw was the seventh day! From Gen. 2 we learn that after man was created, all the cattle, fowls, and beasts were brought before him, and he gave names to them. He then slept, a rib was taken from him, the woman was made, and they were married. All this took place on the sixth day. This was Adam’s first day.

2. “The Jews had another day given to them. Their Sabbath had no reference to the Edenic rest.”

The fourth commandment squarely contradicts this. “For in six days God made heaven and earth, . . . and rested the seventh day.” That is the reason God gave for commanding them to keep the seventh day. Yet Eld. Wilkins says their Sabbath had no reference to the Edenic rest! In Neh. 9:14 we learn that God made known to them his holy Sabbath. Sabbath means rest; God’s Sabbath must be God’s rest-day, and not “another day.”

3. “Gentiles were never required to keep the Sabbath.”

“The Sabbath was made for man.” Mark 2:27. “Blessed is the man that doeth this, and the son of man that layeth hold on it; that keepeth the Sabbath from polluting it.” Isa. 56:2. “Also the sons of the stranger, that join themselves to the Lord, to serve him, and to love the name of the Lord, to be his servants, every one that keepeth the Sabbath from polluting it, and taketh hold of my covenant; even them will I bring to my holy mountain, and make them joyful in my house of prayer.” Verses 6, 7.

He said that the fourth commandment was binding only on the Jews, but afterward claimed that it was not confined to the Jews, but was binding on all.

4. “Shall we keep the Sabbath, when we are not under the law, but under grace? Nonsensical!”

To be “under the law” in the sense of Paul’s argument (Rom. 6:14) is to be under its condemnation as sinners. Condemned to die. “For the wages of sin is death.” Verse 23. “Freed from sin,” “not under the law,” signifies pardon. Eld. W.’s position, then, is this: It is nonsensical to keep the Sabbath after we have been pardoned for breaking it. The same would be true of all the commandments. It is nonsensical to keep them after receiving pardon for sin! Christ said, “Go and sin no more.” Had Eld. W. read the very next words of Paul’s argument, they would have condemned his fallacious reasoning. “What then?” Paul continues, “shall we sin, because we are not under the law, but under grace? God forbid.” Rom. 6:15.p. 179

5. “In keeping the first day, we conform to all the requirements of the fourth commandment.”

The fourth command requires us to keep the seventh day to commemorate the work of creation. Eld. W. claims to keep the first day to commemorate the resurrection of Christ. Keeping another day for another object no more “conforms to the fourth commandment” than Christmas day commemorates the Declaration of Independence.

6. “Time was lost.” “A hundred thousand Sabbaths were lost from creation to the Exodus.” “Keep a regular succession! Oh, humbug!”

If man did lose the Sabbath after creation, God did not. He surely knew his sanctified rest-day, and he made it known unto his people. Neh. 9:14. For forty years the manna fell on six days, and was withheld on the seventh. Surely this was enough to point out the true Sabbath, if they had lost it. In the time of Christ they “rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment;” hence they must have had the true Sabbath then. There has since been no chance for the Sabbath to be lost. Jews, seventh-day Christians, first-day Christians, Catholics, and Mohammedans all agree that Sunday is the first day of the week, and Saturday the seventh.

7. “Sunday is the day of Edenic rest.” “It is identical with the primal Sabbath.” “It has been handed down to us through the pagans, who worshiped the sun on that day, and through the traditions of the American Indians.”

The absurdity of this position is too apparent to need any reply. A man who will scoff at the idea of keeping the knowledge of the true Sabbath through God’s own chosen people, among whom all the prophets, apostles, and Christ himself, have lived, and then in the same discourse undertake to establish a regular succession of Sundays from creation down through the pagans and American Indians, simply illustrates what men will do when trying to prove a false doctrine without arguments.

8. “A definite day cannot be observed, because time differs east and west.” “There is a difference of twelve hours between us and those on the opposite side of the globe.” “We cannot all keep the same day.”

God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it, not a seventh definite portion of absolute time. The sun was made to rule the day. When the seventh day comes, we are to keep it. If we cannot keep the seventh day, how about the first? Does the world become flat on Sunday, so that all can keep that day at once?

9. “The day of the Sabbath is fixed to the first day of the week by the resurrection of Christ. John 20:19, 26; Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2; Rev. 1:10.”

Neither Christ nor the apostles ever hint at the change of the Sabbath. John 20:19 says nothing of a meeting to celebrate the resurrection of Christ. The disciples were at home (John 20:19; Acts 1:13), eating supper (Mark 16:14), and did not believe that Christ was raised. (Mark 16:14.) John 20:26 does not mention the first day. After eight days from Sunday night would naturally carry us forward to Monday night, or some time after. Acts 20:7 contains the only account in the New Testament of a religious meeting held on the first day of the week. This was an evening meeting. From this Eld. Wilkins argued that the early Christians all kept Sunday. Suppose I pass through Waterbury Thursday evening, and find the Methodists holding their evening prayer-meeting. I then go back to Michigan, and report that the people of Waterbury and all over the State of Vermont keep Thursday as the Sabbath. They have changed their rest-day from Sunday to Thursday. When asked for proof of such a revolution in Vermont, I tell them I saw the Methodists holding a meeting in Waterbury Thursday evening. Would you believe that in Vermont the Sabbath was changed upon hearing such evidence as that? The evidence from Acts 20:7 is no stronger.

“Very much like our Sunday collections,” said the Elder, speaking of 1 Cor. 16:2. This was not a public collection, but each one was to lay by him in store, that is, at home, as many translations read. That was to be their first business transaction of the week. Rev. 1:10 refers to the Sabbath, as shown from Mark 2:28; Isa. 58:13. There is no record that Christ ever even mentioned the first day of the week. The Bible does not afford the slightest evidence for a first-day Sabbath.

10. “The testimony of the early Fathers of the church shows that they kept ‘Sunday as a rest-day.’”

The “Fathers” are a favorite resort for those who have a doctrine to prove, with no Bible proof. Dr. Adam Clarke says of the Fathers: “There is not a heresy that has disgraced the Romish Church that may not challenge them as its abettors.” Another advantage is, if the exact testimony desired is not to be found in the writings of the Fathers, one can be written out and a Father’s name signed to it, and but few would know the difference. This policy has been adopted to sustain Sunday. Eld. Wilkins quotes Irenaeus as saying, “On the Lord’s day every one of us keeps the Sabbath.” Upon this I need only state the fact that no such statement is to be found in the writings of Irenaeus.

Eld. W. quotes Ignatius as saying, “No more Sabbatize, but keep the Lord’s day.” The epistle from which this quotation is made is a spurious production, condemned by the best scholars. Calvin condemns it. And further, it is a spurious quotation, for in the original the term “Lord’s day” does not occur. A fraudulent translation from a spurious epistle!

Cyprian also was quoted. He lived down in the middle of the third century, when they had begun to pay some regard to Sunday, but not as a Sabbath or rest-day. For Cyprian speaks of it as the day after the Sabbath. Chrysostom was represented as testifying in A. D. 195 to Sunday as a rest-day. In the first place he did not write until about A. D. 360; secondly, although Chrysostom held meetings Sunday morning, he did not regard it as a Sabbath, but dismissed his congregation to their ordinary occupations, and held that it was right to do worldly business on the first day.

I have now hastily passed over Eld. W.’s principal arguments. His positions briefly summed up are these: Sunday is the true, original Sabbath. The Jews kept another day. Time is lost, so that we cannot tell when the seventh day comes. We must keep the first day of the week in honor of Christ. We cannot keep a particular day on a round world. The Sabbath was given to the Jews only. The fourth commandment is binding on all. Finally he said, “There is nothing holy about a day, because we cannot take hold of it.” Thus much for his “reasons for keeping Sunday.”