REASONS FOR NON-CHURCH-GOING

2%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 13, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 12.

Read the full edition

REASONS FOR NON-CHURCH-GOING.

The Boston Sunday Herald has been examining into this matter of non-church-going; and from the following facts, gleaned from many sources, leaves the reader to draw his own inferences as to the popular idea of the true use of Sunday, and to what extent the ministers are losing their hold on the people:—
Why are the churches so poorly filled? How shall the masses be reached by the gospel? These are questions that have excited a deep interest in religious circles for the past few years, especially in our large cities. Ministers have preached about it. The religious press has theorized in regard to it. Ecclesiastical councils and conferences have listened to essays and joined in discussions concerning it. But, in spite of all that has been said and the little that has been done, the pews remain empty, and no two authorities seem to agree as to the reason or the remedy. It occurred to the Herald to go to the absentees themselves for the reason. Certainly it is a common-sense supposition that the man who doesn’t go to church knows better than anybody else the reason why. Why speculate about what may be known? The first step toward remedying any difficulty is to ascertain its cause. It has been ascertained by repeated counts, and is, indeed, a matter of common observation to those whose duty or pleasure takes them among the churches, that, taken altogether, and on a fair average, not more than one-half the sittings are regularly occupied on Sunday, and that in many of them, built and maintained at a large expense, the proportion is much less than this. It was ascertained, not long ago, upon the basis of an actual count made, and published in the Congregationalist, that in ten Orthodox churches in Boston city proper, representing an invested capital of fully $2,000,000, and an annual outlay, aside from interest, of nearly $100,000, with a seating capacity of some 8000, but a little over 3000 persons were in attendance on a pleasant Sunday morning. Add another thousand to the aggregate for any possible mistakes, or for more favorable conditions, and the showing is still sufficiently suggestive, not to say startling.

WHAT IS THE REASON

for this state of things? To get at a basis of fact, representatives of the Herald were directed to interview a large number of fairly typical persons of the so-called middle and working classes, who do not habitually attend church, with a view to ascertain, (1.) The reason why; (2.) If church-going has ever been their habit, and in what denomination; (3.) Any experiences, either mental or in the nature of the preaching or church management, that operate to prevent their going; (4.) Their idea of the best use of Sunday. The reports of these interviews are before us, and we have prepared a digest of them for our readers, giving, in most instances, the exact language, and, in all cases, the fair substance of the replies. The reasons are obvious why the very poor and the vicious classes do not attend church; and the inquiries were, therefore, mainly prosecuted among the intelligent, industrious, well-to-do great middle classes,—those whom we suppose the church authorities to mean when speaking of “the masses.” The first case given is that of a young man of twenty-eight, with a wife and two children, an accountant, with a salary of $1200 a year—a clean-cut, bright fellow, with fine tastes and irreproachable character, a model husband and good citizen.
“And so you want to know why I don’t go to church?” he responded to the inquiry. “Well, I appreciate your desire for exact information, but I don’t know as we have ever drawn up and declared our reasons, have we, wife?” appealing to the little lady, who was an interested listener. “The fact is,” he continued, “we

CAN’T AFFORD IT;

that is, we can’t afford to hire seats where we want to go, and we have natural antipathies to dead-beating it. If it were absolutely indispensable to our souls’ welfare for us to go to church somewhere, of course we could find a place. But we do not so regard it, and the places that are open to us under conditions where we would feel comfortable are the ones where we haven’t the slightest desire to go.”
“There are seat rentals within your means, of course?” “Yes; and if one church, and one preacher, and one service, were as good as another, it would be all right. But they are not. And nobody can make me believe that it is my duty to go and hear a man who murders the King’s English, or preaches through his nose, or reads a dull essay, or flaunts in my face doctrines that are abhorrent to me. I won’t do it, that’s all. I was brought up in an orthodox way, and don’t dissent from the main facts of religion, as I understand them. I would like to go to church, for the habit of the thing, and for the good it does me, under proper conditions. There are the free seats and the free churches, of course. But how does a fellow feel in them, who is in the habit of paying his way? It’s a Potters’ field for the living. Now, when we want to go to the play or a concert, my money is as good as anybody’s. For $1, I can have a seat as good as Croesus, and feel like a man in my right to it, as I sit beside him. There are no broad aisles, nor pew ownership, nor caste divisions, in other places of public resort. A fellow would feel about as much at home to stumble into a swell club-house as to go into a swell church. As for Sunday, I devote the day religiously to getting acquainted with my family. I have, of course, several other good reasons for not going to church, but these are enough, I take it.” As the reporter wasn’t instructed to argue the case, he conceded that they were.
The next type selected was a lady, a widow in moderate circumstances, cultivated, clever, and mentally “emancipated.” “You know that, officially, I can’t be impertinent,” said the reporter, “especially to an acquaintance. So please proceed, and tell me why you never go to church.” “Well, then, I don’t go to church because I

HAD TOO MUCH OF IT IN MY YOUTH.

It was church morning, afternoon, and evening, and prayer-meeting besides, forever and ever! I came to dread and then to hate it, and the first use I made of my freedom—my marriage, you understand, or you will understand if you get the right kind of a wife—was to stop going to church, except now and then to hear the music. Besides, I like new things, and it is the same old story from the pulpit.”
A music teacher, a single lady of education and refinement, offered herself as a witness. “I don’t go to church regularly,” she said, “because I can’t dress well enough to feel comfortable where I want to go, if I go at all. If it were in the line of duty, or something that I felt to be essential, I would go in calico, if need were. But church-going is now largely either a fashion or a habit. Nobody seriously thinks of it as a means of grace. They simply regard it as the proper thing to do, or feel it to be their duty to help keep up the establishment. I can’t afford to be fashionable, though I don’t deny that I should like to be. If I were able, and had been bred to it, I have no doubt I should don my camel’s hair, my laces, my love of a hat, and my most modest diamonds, and sail into my reserved seat quite as a matter of course, without thinking at all of making the plain little thing in the back pew, in her poor best dress, feel as though she were sitting on pins and needles. I don’t blame the fine dames at all. It is all natural to them. Only I will do my penance in a less conspicuous manner.” *
An architect and builder, well “fixed” as to worldly affairs, and bred an orthodox of the down East type, said,—
“No, I stopped some years ago. Didn’t like the sort of people our churches bred. Too low between joints, too narrow for comfort. Our closest skin-flints were always deacons. Their creed seemed to be that whatever is good is bad. I couldn’t believe in their hell, and couldn’t relish their Heaven, and so I thought I might as well quit.”
“And what do you do with your Sundays?”
“Well, I make it easy for the good wife,—look out for the youngsters; take a horse-car outing, if the weather is fair; read a little, smoke a good deal, sleep, visit, and make a restful home day of it.”
A tired-looking shop girl, a fair representative of the ten thousand of her class in the city, was asked the question, and replied, with bitter significance,—
“My employer goes. He is one of the pillars of the church.”
“Well?”
“That’s reason enough why I shouldn’t go. I know how he treats his help. We girls are barely able to keep soul and body together—and neither of them in good condition!—under the pitiful wages we can earn. Would you think Christianity did much for you, sir, if you were

A POOR GIRL,

compelled to work for $4.00 a week, and expected to dress and appear respectably, while your employer lived in a palace, and paid liberally to support a church, in which his operatives, who are popularly supposed to have souls, would be and feel as much out of place as in his fine house?”
“But many employers do treat their help generously.”
“Yes, but they are quite as often world’s people as so-called Christians; and then we girls are so shut in that we must look only at what is nearest us.”
An active business man of literary tastes said, among other things,—
“To be frank, I don’t believe in the Bible, or rather in the system built up on it. . . . I believe in Christianity, and would hold to it, whether such a person as Jesus ever actually lived and died according to the record or not; but I don’t think he would recognize the popular religion as his if he should come to our land to-day. I keep away from the temples for fear I should feel the sting of his scourge if he should happen to come among the money-changers.”
A large number of the reports show a

LOSS OF FAITH IN RELIGION

to have resulted from bad treatment, in business or other matters, by prominent church-members. The man who has been swindled or wronged often holds the system responsible for the deeds of the individual, especially when such conduct does not seem to impair the standing of the wrong-doer. This feeling was condensed into a bitter hyperbole by one man who had been outrageously duped and swindled by his partner, who was an active Sunday-school superintendent. “If I had a boy,” said the victim, grimly, “and he showed the least inclination to go to Sunday-school, I would drown him.”
A remark dropped by an English servant girl, to a lady who was seeking to engage her, is also quite apropos: “Do you attend church?” inquired the lady. “Not in this country, ma’am.” “And why not?” “I am a church woman, ma’am, but I have found no provision made for the serving class in our churches in this country.” “But you could go somewhere else?” “I beg your pardon, ma’am, but I only enjoy my own service.”
A good many of the absentees contented themselves with the brief but honest answer: “Because we don’t want to.” “People, as a rule, find a way to go where they want to,” said one outspoken lady. “I simply don’t want to go. When the churches, in their preaching, their music, their hospitality, their freedom from cold forms and Sunday millinery, make me want to go, I shall go, and not before. For the rest, I am quite willing to settle the matter with my God.”
An engineer who has charge of engines which furnish power to quite a number of industrial occupations in a central place in the city, and is quite an intelligent man, was asked,—
“You do not attend church at all, you say. Why?”
“Because there is

NOTHING THERE TO ATTRACT ME,

There is a desire, a want of knowledge on my part in relation to the things the preachers talk about, which they have not as yet satisfied, and I doubt if they ever can.”
“Have you been much of a church-goer in your life?”
“For the past twenty years I have not. My parents were of the Baptist persuasion, and compelled me, when young, to attend Sunday-school and church; but, even when a youngster, I thought the whole affair hollow and unsatisfying. The result is that I have been, since a boy, and am now, a free-thinker, that is, I believe only in what I conceive to be reasonable, according to my small comprehension.”
“What is your idea of the best use of Sunday?”
“Rational enjoyment. If I can go down the harbor without being uncomfortably squeezed by too large a crowd, I go. Or I take the horse-cars and go out to West Roxbury. But the fact is, the boats and horse-cars are generally so crowded on Sunday that one might wonder if there is any one left to go to church. It looks as if the priests were losing their hold on the people. I have enough to do with church-members on week days to let them alone on Sundays.”
The next is a blacksmith, who employs men. He is thirty-five years of age, and has a first-class reputation as an honest, fair-dealing man. He is of an intelligent and inquiring turn of mind.
“You do not habitually attend church, sir. May I ask you why?”
“Certainly. The church to me is a sapless trunk of a still standing tree. For me it has no fruit. And yet, I go to church occasionally. I go when any man of note is to be heard. I go to hear if he has any new ideas,—if he has any convincing proofs to give me of an immortality which I hope for, and a hereafter which must accompany it. I tell you, I have hungered and thirsted for information on those things, but have never found any one to satisfy me—ministers least of all.”
“How long did you regularly attend church and what denomination?”
“I attended Sunday-school and the Lutheran church until I was about fifteen years of age. Up to the time I left the church, I had no religious convictions. There was nothing in the preaching that was attractive to me. It seemed wrong and cruel according to my conceptions of justice and mercy and truth.

IT REPELLED ME

from the time I began to think, and, the more I have thought of the doctrines preached, the more repellent they are to me.”
“Are you an infidel now?”
“I do not particularly like that term. I am not an atheist. I believe in God, but not in all the Bible doctrines. They are too repulsive to me. My God is not the God the ministers tell us of. I suppose I might properly be called a free-thinker. I feel myself responsible to no man, to no minister, to no church, for what I think or believe. It affects me more than them, and I think I should have the most to say about it.”
“What is your idea of the best use of Sunday?”
“I generally pass my Sundays visiting friends or going to the seashore. If I feel like it, I go into the country or take a ride in the cars. If the day is not pleasant, I stay at home and read; I have plenty of good books to read, and the Sunday papers are full of information. I think rational men should spend Sunday as they see fit, and I do not see why they should be prevented from doing so.”
The interviews and statements could be prolonged, but the above give a sufficiently full and clear idea of the reasons, as they actually exist in the minds of the great mass of non-church-goers, for their course of life in this respect.