Granbury, Hood Co.—Since my last report, I have had a debate of twelve sessions with Eld. Price, the Methodist champion in this part of the State. The results are very satisfactory to ourselves. We anticipated a hard battle with so renowned a foe, but in this we were disappointed. It was a rest to me. When the discussion began, I was quite worn, and hoarse from a cold which had been affecting me seriously for some time. When it closed, my health was better than it had been for two months.
On the Sabbath question, Eld. P. abandoned Methodist ground, and sought refuge in the antinomian field. The ten commandments were abolished at the cross; but the principles upon which they were based are immutable. The Jewish Sabbath ceased at the cross, while the principle remained. The principle only required the observance of a seventh part of time; but since the resurrection it enforces the observance of the first day of the week, which comes on the eighth day. The fourth commandment does not contain the seventh day. All there is of it is, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.” The other portion is only “specifications” of the commandment, just as the second is only a specification of the first. We are thus left with the principles of only nine of the commandments. The copy on the chart was not correct. He had never seen it on any card in the same form before. In all this he arrayed himself against Adam Clarke, John Wesley, and the Methodist discipline.
In the negative arguments, in his last speech before his final one, he introduced a few props in support of the first day. The main one was the testimony of Ignatius, Irenaeus, Theophilus, etc. We met this by declaring them unqualified frauds, and challenging him to show that the quotations he gave were genuine, and the uncorrupted statements of these Fathers. We also challenged him to affirm the following: “Do the Scriptures teach that the first day of the week is the Christian Sabbath, and should be observed by Christians at the present time?” He claimed that it was “illogical” to have two affirmatives on the Sabbath question. As we had affirmed the seventh day, we asked him to affirm that the first day was binding; and although we called upon him time and again to defend what he believes and teaches, giving him liberty to appeal to the Fathers, and although a petition was drawn up and a public vote of many citizens taken, asking him to meet the issue, yet he backed out of it, knowing that he had no theological ground to stand upon.
On the subject of the immortality of the soul and the punishment of the wicked, the usual arguments were presented. The silence of the Bible on the immortality of the soul was the best argument in its favor, and the expressions in the Bible concerning the “destruction” of the wicked, their being “consumed,” coming to “an end,” being “burned up,” “cut off,” “blotted out,” and becoming “as though they had not been,” all referred to this present life. His friends claim a victory; yet at Eld. P.’s suggestion they were ready to vote against having any more discussion.
We went to Granbury three months ago. One man and his wife were keeping the Sabbath. Evil reports had preceded us, and prejudiced many; opposition meetings operated against us; we gave way to nearly all regular appointments; ministers used their influence against us; sermons were preached condemning us and our views; we encountered challenges in public and propositions in private, and held a long debate with a recognized champion,—all these combined to make our labor arduous. But to the glory of God we are able to report a gain of many warm friends; and if we should number convictions for conversions, as is usually done on revival occasions, about two hundred could safely be estimated. But convictions are not conversions. About thirty have taken up the cross, and are trying to obey. A Sabbath-school of fifty members has been organized; and thirty subscribers to our periodicals have been obtained. We sold about $70 worth of books, and received about $45 toward expenses; and the day I left, I obtained in an hour or two pledges for over a hundred dollars toward erecting a house of worship. Not one has abandoned the truth on account of the debate, while a few have taken their stand in its favor since hearing both sides, and all have been confirmed. The people of Granbury shall ever be remembered for their kindness to us while we were among them. May God bless and reward them.
I am now forty miles south of Granbury, at Meridian, Bosque Co., with Bro. Jensen in his tent. The prospect is not so favorable as we could wish. We have postponed our meeting on account of a Methodist camp-meeting close by. Shall endeavor to create an interest, and if we fail, shall labor in other fields till camp-meeting. Brethren in Texas, let nothing but sickness prevent you from attending the camp-meeting at Dallas, Oct. 27 to Nov. 1. Get ready. Be in season. Pray for us. R. M. KILGORE.
Sept. 4.