LETTER TO A METHODIST MINISTER.
By E. Lamphear
PLAINFIELD, N. J. AUG. 28, 1881. DEAR SIR: I listened with deep interest to your sermon at the Seventh-day Baptist church yesterday, from the text: “Jesus saith unto him, Thomas, because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed; blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed.” John 20:29. The subject was well handled. I agree with you that notwithstanding his apparent obstinacy, Thomas was an honest seeker after truth. With his understanding of the events that had transpired three days previous, he could not believe it possible that his Saviour was alive, though the fact was declared to him by his brethren. On so important a subject, he desired something positive and tangible from his own observation. He must see the Saviour himself, see the prints of the nails, and place his finger thereon, and thrust his hand into the wounded side, before he could be convinced. This was right; for how could he, with his knowledge of the death and burial of his Lord, go before a doubting world to promulgate the doctrine of a risen Saviour, without all doubts being removed? So it should be with every one before attempting to promulgate any doctrine. Let every doubt be removed by reliable facts, that you can put your finger on, that you may be able to give a reason of the hope that is within you, and of the doctrine taught. And now I come to the point of my criticism, trusting you will believe, as in the case of Thomas, that I am an honest seeker after truth. You clearly set forth, in the first part of your discourse, that at evening of the same day, the first day of the week, the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, when Christ appeared unto them, etc., referring to the language of verse 19, which is decisive on this subject. This was their first positive knowledge of his resurrection. Thomas was not with them at this time, and when the disciples told him what they had seen, Thomas made the statement recorded in verse 25: “Except I shall see in his hands the prints of the nails, . . . I will not believe.” You then repeated verse 26: “And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them; then came Jesus, the door being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.” This was the second meeting. Here all doubt was removed from the mind of Thomas, and he acknowledged his risen Lord. Your sermon is as clear as the noon-day sun up to this point. But when you went on to assert that the first meeting of the disciples was on the Sabbath, and their second meeting was on the next Sabbath, doubts rushed in upon my mind as to whether these things were really so, and whether they could be proved by reliable evidence. Thus I was led to inquire, Can you not give us more tangible proof than your mere statement? Except I shall see in the Bible the chapter and verse wherein the word Sabbath is applied to the first day of the week, and place my finger thereon, and a distinct text that I can lay my hand upon, representing that Christ or his disciples enjoined its observance as a Sabbath, I cannot believe. And further: unless it is shown from reliable facts in mathematics that “after eight days” would bring their next meeting on the Sunday-Sabbath, as you represent, I cannot believe. I desire the removal of every doubt before I accept and promulgate the doctrine. Will you refer me to chapter and verse giving precept or example on the part of the Saviour or his apostles to prove the sanctity of the first day of the week? Will you tell me where the title Sabbath or Lord’s day is applied to the Sunday? Will you give me the rule of mathematics whereby you can make the second meeting of the disciples, after eight days, come on the next first day, that I may believe? The facts, furnished through the post-office or otherwise, will be gratefully received. Most respectfully, E. LAMPHEAR. P. S. To this letter no answer has as yet been received.