The New Departure

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 1, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 18.

Read the full edition

The New Departure.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
The most casual observer of our denominational affairs cannot have failed to discern the radical change which is taking place in the views of our people respecting the relative importance of doctrinal and practical preaching. In years past, the theoretical preachers among us have borne away the palm on almost every occasion. As an increase of our denominational numbers has seemed to all to be in the highest degree important, and as theoretical preaching has contributed most directly to that end, those who have been masters of that art, and thus enabled to raise up churches, have been applauded and rewarded as those have not been whose office work has seemed to be that of laboring through practical preaching to more fully convert, and render more devotional, those who have been brought into the faith in courses of lectures, where the prophecies and the doctrinal features of our work have been almost exclusively presented. As a natural consequence, reaction is now taking place.
It has been discovered that theory alone will not furnish a foundation broad enough and deep enough for the erection thereupon of a church enduring in its character, and exemplifying in the lives of its members all the Christian graces.
That such a change has been inaugurated, affords us great satisfaction; but we apprehend that the time has now come to speak a word of caution in regard to the danger of allowing the reaction to push us too far in the opposite direction. He who has carefully studied the laws of the human mind, and the history of the church at large, cannot be ignorant of the fact that it is the next thing to impossibility to prevent those who have erred in one direction from going to extremes in the other direction. In fact, we think that we can already discover this tendency among ourselves.
Those who have had an overdose of theory seem now disposed to discard it altogether. Should such a change really take place quite generally among us, it seems as if the calamity thus induced would be almost irreparable. The difficulty of bringing back the denomination to the proper mean between the two extremes would be almost insuperable; nevertheless such a bringing back would be indispensable, if we are really engaged in the special work in which we claim to be employed. In other words, if we are giving the third angel’s message, our mission is a special one, and of such a nature, that in the providence of God we must inevitably devote our energies largely to the elucidation and propagation of those points of doctrine which it is the special work of the men who give the third angel’s message to present to, and impress upon, the world at large. Among those doctrines are found the Sabbath, the Advent, the sleep of the dead, the sanctuary question, spiritual gifts, etc., etc. These are all unpopular in their character, and novel to the majority of minds. Had we before us many years in which to propagate our faith, much of our time would necessarily be employed in producing that revolution in public sentiment necessary to induce men to embrace our views; but as time is confessedly very short, and as God has seen fit to so order that these doctrines are to become more and more fully testing in their character, the situation demands that they shall assume a prominence in our teachings such as will bring into requisition a large amount of our time and energy. Should we fail to give them that prominence, we should prove recreant to our mission in one important particular. Such neglect also, on our part, if persisted in, would insure the disapprobation of Heaven. Not only so, but it would be necessary that others should be substituted in our places, who would have the burden of the work which belongs to this time.
When Christ entered Jerusalem, and the multitudes shouted, “Hosanna to the Son of David,” he was requested to rebuke them; but his reply was, “If these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.” (Luke 19: 40.) The same is true of the third angel’s message. The people who give it have a place in the prophetic scheme, and a solemn announcement for the world, which is indispensable in order to prepare it for the coming judgments of God. They are to warn men that if they persist in trampling the commandments of God under foot, they must, in process of time, drink of the unmixed wine of the wrath of God. (Rev. 14: 9–12.) Should they fail to do their duty, they would subject themselves to the penalty of those who refuse to give the warning when they see the sword coming upon the land (Eze. 33: 6); i. e., they will be held responsible for the blood of those whom they have refused to apprise of their coming doom, while, at the same time, they will be subjected to the mortification of seeing others fill up the ranks of the faithful ones in order to secure unto themselves the palms and crowns forfeited by those who failed to appreciate the opportunity, which God had given them, of winning immortal honor.
Again: we think that some are making a very serious mistake in regard to the effect of a reasonable amount of doctrinal preaching upon the devotion of those who are engaged therein. To us it seems clear that soundness in theory is by no means incompatible with devotion in spirit. “Sanctify them,” said our Saviour, “through thy truth; thy word is truth.” (John 17: 17.) Here it appears that sanctification—which certainly represents the highest Christian experience possible—is to be secured through the truth of God. But what is the truth of God, unless it be a correct theory of God’s will concerning us, and our duty to him? But if this be the right understanding of the matter, then soundness in doctrine is indispensable to perfection in Christian character; else Christ did not understand the proper method to secure that end. But if that be true, then surely the man who preaches sound doctrine in all particulars will edify the flock of Christ as well as himself.
To prove that the absence, in a very large degree, of theoretical preaching is not necessarily proof of a high Christian experience on the part of those who are ministered to upon that plan, it is only necessary to call attention to the present condition of the nominal churches. At this time doctrinal preaching is very unpopular among them, and the standard of piety is exceptionally low. Fifty years ago doctrinal preaching was indulged in, perhaps, in excess of what it should be; but we think it will be conceded that the standard of piety was much higher then than it is in our day.
It is also worthy of remark right here, that in every great and permanent reform in the past, theoretical and practical preaching have had an almost equal prominence. Several illustrations will suffice. Take, if you please, the case of John the Baptist; the account of what he said and did is very meager; but enough is written concerning the nature of his mission to render it certain that he must have dealt largely in the prophecies in his preaching, as well as in those searching practical truths which led men to an examination of their own hearts. He emphatically claimed to be the forerunner of Christ, who he declared was at hand. (John 1: 19–23.) Now, in order to demonstrate these two propositions, it was indispensable that he should bring to his aid the prophetic word, as he was not gifted with the ability to perform miracles in order to demonstrate the truthfulness of his assertion. Human nature was the same then that it is now. Before John could sufficiently move men in the direction of preparation for the advent of Christ to induce them to change the whole current of their lives, and perhaps surrender their most cherished ambitions in order to get ready for that event, it was necessary that he should bring an array of Scripture proof in favor of his views which would be overwhelming in its character. That he did so, the results of his preaching clearly show. A more complete history of what he said and did, no doubt, would reveal to us the fact, that in his hands the law and the prophets were proved to be an almost exhaustless treasury of facts and predictions, all bearing upon his mission and the coming of Christ. In some way, no doubt, he was in the habit of demonstrating from the Old Testament, to the satisfaction of all the candid, that he was the forerunner predicted by Isaiah, and that the time had been reached, according to the periods of Daniel and others, for the manifestation of the Messiah. (John 1: 19–23.) But if this were so, then his work, like our own, rendered theoretical preaching, on a large scale, indispensable.
What has been said of John, would be equally true of the disciples of Christ as well as of Christ himself. The issue between them and the fierce partisans of Judaism turned upon the question whether Jesus was indeed the Christ. The disciples claimed that he was; the Pharisees, Sadducees, and the doctors of law, denied that proposition, arguing that he did not meet the requirements of the word. As a necessary result, both parties endeavored to maintain their respective theories from the prophetic word. One undertook to show that he appeared at the right time and under the right circumstances, in order to fulfill the predictions concerning the Messiah, and the other stoutly denied the correctness of these propositions. As a necessary consequence, a running fire of debate was kept up between these opposing parties, until the public mind was sufficiently enlightened in regard to the facts to give an intelligent verdict in the premises.
First and foremost after the days of Christ, in the fiery contest, were the noble and courageous Paul and the polished Apollos. The former, disputed daily, as we read, in the school of Tyrannus (Acts 19: 9), and on the Sabbaths in the synagogues (Acts 18: 4), while the latter “mightily convinced the Jews, and that publicly, showing by the Scriptures that Jesus was the Christ.” (Acts 18: 28.) But this disputing “in the synagogues” and “the school,” and this “convincing the Jews by the Scriptures,” all related to the doctrine that Jesus was the Christ, and was purely theoretical in its character. Passing over nearly sixteen hundred years, we discover the world again in commotion over the preaching of Luther the Monk. But what was the grand central point of his teaching? Was it not justification by faith instead of by works? How, we ask then, was that contest carried on? was it not largely disputational in its character, and did not the whole issue turn upon the teachings of the Bible respecting the doctrine of justification? If so, then we find again that theory occupied a most conspicuous place in the Reformation of the sixteenth century.
We might multiply illustrations; but the above are sufficient.
In conclusion we ask, therefore, whether it is possible to point to any great movements in the religious world which have been marked by deeper devotion and more earnest piety than were those which we have cited.
If the answer shall be in the affirmative, then we reply that we have not only proved that the preaching of theory is compatible with the highest spiritual attainments; but, also, that, judging from the history of the church, God has seen fit to associate the two in the most intimate manner in time past, and consequently that it is not improbable that he will continue to unite them for the future, whenever he wishes to move men on a large scale in the direction of perfect consecration to him and his cause. Let us therefore accept the history of the ages in this matter, and instead of finding fault with the Almighty for the great number of unpopular truths which he has made it our duty to prove and defend, rather be thankful that he has in them furnished the very instrumentalities which, if properly employed, are his chosen instruments to enlighten and sanctify most fully all who accept them.
If we shall do this, and combine theoretical and practical preaching, so-called, in proper proportions, we shall be able to stir the people as merely practical preaching never can stir them, and present to the world Christian characters more perfectly rounded out and symmetrical, than can be found wherever the gospel is preached either from the standpoint of doctrine altogether, or from that of its more practical phases.
We hope that we may never see the day when our people will love the great fundamental doctrines of our message any less than they do now. We trust, also, that the time may never come when they will not listen with the most profound pleasure to the proper presentation of practical truth.
While it is, no doubt, true that in the past some of our preachers may have dwelt too much upon the theoretical where their congregations were already thoroughly indoctrinated, and where there were none outside of the faith to be enlightened, yet we feel that we should commit an error but little less fatal, should we now pass over to the other extreme, and allow the deep and solemn conviction that we have a special message from God for the world to leak out of the minds of our brethren. Should we do so, it will be impossible for them to reconcile their past experience with present teachings, and, sooner or later, they will come to the inevitable conclusion that the movement by which they have been called out was a sad mistake. On the other hand, create a deep and permanent conviction in their minds that important truths have been committed to their charge, and you will inspire in them an enthusiasm for the work of God which will make their onset upon the hosts of his enemies irresistible.
Allegan, Mich., Oct. 10.