AMONG the internal evidences for the divine origin of the Old Testament Scriptures may be reckoned, we fully think, the aspect in which those Scriptures stand toward the question of polygamy. The rise within our time of the great Mormon delusion, which has sought to establish a system of marriage which Christianity has plainly forbidden, makes the subject of peculiar interest to us.
Monogamy was the original institution of God. When the Creator looked upon Adam's state at the first, and pronounced that he was yet without a “help meet for him,” God's reply to his own thought was the creation of Eve. One wife for one man was, in the judgment of God, that which was required. There was here no occasion or place for any ordinance of monogamy or any prohibition for polygamy. Polygamy was out of Adam's power. Monogamy was pronounced by his Maker sufficient for him. Gen. 2:24.
That such was the original institution of God may also be seen from the primitive practice of mankind. Moses very plainly relates the departure from previous habit in the case of Lamech. Gen. 4:19. His having “two wives” is as plainly noted as a new thing, as the tent life, the invention of musical instruments, and the workmanship in brass and iron, are noted as new things in the history of human life and progress. Gen. 4:20–22.
In such a wonderfully brief sketch as is given of mankind in the opening of the book of Genesis, where six brief chapters are all that is devoted to the history of our race for a period of some fifteen hundred years, the sacred writer would not have noticed the taking to himself of two wives by Lamech unless that had been a departure from the practice of mankind hitherto. Lamech married two wives, and only two, and this was reckoned by all an extraordinary event, and by most, probably, condemned as wrong. Such was the commencement of a social system which led in Jewish history to Solomon and his seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines; which led to the Seraglio of Abdalrahman, Caliph of Bagdad, of six thousand three hundred wives, concubines, and eunuchs; which displayed to the astonished minds of the Spanish invaders of South America in the sixteenth century the court of the Inca of Peru, whose concubines were numbered not by hundreds but by thousands.
With the gospel of Jesus Christ came back the old institution of monogamy in even more than its primitive force. Matt. 19:4–9. As first instituted by God, there was no direct prohibition of polygamy. There was the simple institution of a state of monogamy pronounced by God suitable and adequate for the welfare of the human race. That was enough for the time. Departure from this established rule of God was plainly wrong. But when practice had established a different state of things; when polygamy had long been in use in different nations of the world; when, in particular, polygamy had been practiced without rebuke among God's chosen nation by men who stood high in God's favor and the estimation of the people,—it was then no longer sufficient, if a change in this system were intended by Christ, to lay before men the simple and original institution of God. This must be accompanied by a comment which would put it out of the power of any one either to argue that the original institution of marriage was not incompatible with polygamy, or that, at least, Christianity permitted polygamy as Judaism had done.
Our Lord has done all this plainly and beyond any doubt. He took occasion to do so from a question put to him by his subtle enemies. Matt. 19:3. Polygamy was at this time all but extinct among the Jews, but divorce was extremely common, and rendered polygamy a matter undesirable by almost every one. About to prohibit divorce from the marriage tie in every case whatsoever save only one, our Lord knew that this prohibition of divorce would send men back upon that practice of polygamy which had to a very considerable extent been laid aside, and that accordingly when he had uttered his mind fully and plainly upon the matter of divorce, he must do so as plainly and unequivocally upon the kindred subject of polygamy. He has accordingly done so in his reply to the Pharisee's question: “Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause?”
He first lays before them the original law of marriage, and from its nature pronounces divorce to be unlawful. When to this it is objected that Moses commanded a writing of divorcement to be given to the woman who was put away, our Lord explains that this was permitted by reason of the hardness of heart of the people, but that it was a departure from the original institution. And then he lays down his decision that in every case whatever, save one only, where a man put away his wife and married another, he was guilty of adultery. Now if it was lawful to have two wives, i. e., if polygamy was permitted, the fact of one wife being divorced before a second was married could not possibly make it adultery to take the second. It could only be because polygamy was absolutely wrong that marriage after divorce was unlawful, because divorce was not judged by Christ to break the marital bond. If a man might take two or more wives under any circumstances, his having divorced the first, whether divorce was valid or invalid, could not possibly make it sin in him to take another. The whole force of our Lord's argument in Matt. 19:9 arises from the strict prohibition under his dispensation of that polygamy which was tolerated, not approved of, under the Mosaic dispensation and that of previous times. While one wife is living, Christ pronounces it adultery to marry another. Such is the Christian law of marriage.
That from the earliest period such was the view taken of our Lord's utterances upon this question, there can be no doubt. How those who were polygamists before their conversion to Christianity were to be treated, has come up from time to time before the judgment of the church; but it was never, that we know of, made a serious matter of inquiry in the churches of Christ whether polygamy was lawful or not. There have been individual cases, as that of the Elector of Saxony in the sixteenth century, where an effort has been made to vindicate the practice in those instances, but the extreme rarity of the cases in which such attempts were made does but establish the general view of Christian men that polygamy is condemned by the religion of Christ.
But between the first institution of marriage as we find it in Gen. 2:24, and the promulgation by Christ of its original meaning, there came a great, and long-continued, and wide-spread divergence of practice. Lamech, the sixth in descent from Cain, introduces the practice of polygamy, not going, however, beyond taking a second wife. Gen. 4:19. There can be little doubt that the practice rapidly grew in the wicked generations before the flood. No doubt it was continued in the early generations after the deluge. We find it established in the court of Pharaoh, king of Egypt. Gen. 12:15. We find Abraham conforming to it. Use, doubtless, made it appear to be good, though monogamy might still be reckoned the better way. But, at all events, it grew into use wherever it was judged advisable. It is needless to say that in this interval all the books of the Old Testament were written. Moses begins a series of writings which end with Malachi. To the period from Abraham to Malachi I would particularly refer. The history of this period is the fullest, and specially refers to the Israelites, from whom every one of the sacred writers, with the possible exception of the writer of the book of Job, was taken. During this period polygamy was permitted, so far as never having been forbidden. During this period some of the most honored names of Scripture practiced it without rebuke. Abraham, the father of the faithful, was a polygamist. Jacob, who gave the name of Israel to the chosen people, was one also. So was David, the hero of the Jewish people, the root from whence their Christ was to spring. So was Solomon, the wisest of mankind, whose peaceful kingdom from the river of Egypt to the Euphrates was a type of the reign of their Messiah.
And it is also to be remembered that not only were the writers of the Holy Scriptures themselves Jews, and writing at a time when polygamy was permitted, but that also some of the writers of Scripture were polygamists themselves. It has been thought by some that Moses was a polygamist, but of that I see no proof in Scripture. But David and Solomon were polygamists, and wrote, between them, no inconsiderable proportion of Holy Scriptures. To Solomon in particular we would refer. With his magnificent court, including a thousand wives and concubines, he has, especially in his book of Proverbs, passed in review every condition of human life. The relation of man to woman, the question of marriage, often occupied his thoughts and his pen.
We must also remember that this question of polygamy must in all countries engage notice. If it was practiced and justified in some nations, it was disused and condemned in others. If by some it was supposed to have its advantages, by others it was judged to be attended by inconvenience which far outweighed them. Tacitus, in his History of Germany, remarks of the Germans, that while all other barbarous people practiced polygamy, they alone married only one wife. By the laws of Cecrops polygamy was forbidden in the State of Athens, the most civilized community of those times. Rawlinson tells us that it was not only forbidden in Athens, but also in the ancient and civilized kingdom of Egypt. Sallust, living in the most dissolute age of the Roman Commonwealth, judges that polygamy had the evil effect of causing the marriage tie to be lightly thought of. David Hume, in one of his ingenious essays, has presented in one view the various arguments for and against polygamy which have from time to time presented themselves to the human mind.
Is not, then, the attitude of the Old Testament toward the great question of polygamy so very extraordinary that it may without any strain be reckoned among the internal evidences of its divine inspiration? A state perpetually discussed for or against among men; a state practiced throughout the entire period during which the Old Testament Scriptures were written,—practiced, too, by many of those men whom those Scriptures held up to our veneration, and by some of whom those Scriptures were written; a state which must have been constantly brought before the attention of all sacred writers,—it is yet a fact that not one text, not one chance or designed expression, can be found in favor of polygamy from Genesis to Malachi! More than this, indeed, is true. It is true that wherever the subject of marriage is spoken of or alluded to, while polygamy is not formally condemned, yet marriage to a single wife is spoken of in terms which imply God's approval of it, and this by persons from whom we might expect the very opposite.
Let us take a case in point. In our time has risen up the abominable system of Mormonism, which has sought as one of its main objects to establish polygamy. In a very remarkable book lately written to expose it, The Englishwoman in Utah, by Mrs. Stenhouse, we have brought before us the treatment of this question by the apostles and prophets of Mormonism. They are not contented with advancing the example of Abraham and others in the Old Testament. They adduce also every plea by which it may be shown to be not only lawful, but also far the preferable way, and, indeed, a duty incumbent upon all saints. How different the Old Testament! It narrates many examples of polygamy among its most lauded men. It never praises it. It sometimes implies the very opposite, and this where we should least of all expect it.310
Let us take the case of Solomon. In Prov. 5:15–19, he speaks of marriage. In reading it we should never suppose it to have been written by a polygamist. It breathes throughout the spirit of one who lived after Christ had propounded his law of marriage. “Rejoice with the wife of thy youth,” is not the language of a man whose affections and thoughts were divided among many, but of one who only loved one woman, whom he loved in youth and continued to love in age. We would scarcely suppose these verses were written by the man who “loved many strange women,” in whose gorgeous harem were brought together “seven hundred wives, princesses, and three hundred concubines.” 1 Kings 11:1–3.
Where among them was “the wife of youth?”
And so it came to pass that when Christ was on earth, and restored marriage to its original condition, and quoted the description in Gen. 2:24, as descriptive of that which alone obtained his permission and sanction, not one text written during ages when polygamy reigned in full force, was, or could be, counted in opposition to his teaching. Scripture was throughout the dispensations and the ages true to truth, because holy men of old spake throughout it as they were moved by the Holy Ghost.—The Rainbow.