AdventAI

THE COST OF INTEMPERANCE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 20., November 15, 1881

The city of New York is more heavily taxed by the intemperance of its people than by all other causes of expense. The Herald, in the following article, has compiled the facts and figures in such a shape as to astonish and convince:—

With regard to the proportion of crime and pauperism properly chargeable to the abuse of liquor, opinions vary. Some good judges say that 90 per cent of all crimes are instigated directly or remotely by drink. Others say 80 per cent, and none will go lower than 70 per cent. With respect to pauperism, it is safe to say that 75 per cent is directly or indirectly chargeable to the use of liquors. In a recent report to the Commissioners of Charities and Correction, the chief of the medical staff of the Homœopathic Hospital says:—

“The causes of pauperism and consequent disease and crime have received careful and thorough investigation by those long enjoying favorable advantages for observation. Many reasons for this painful and rapidly increasing pauperism among the people have been assigned, but that which takes precedence above and beyond all others is the curse of intemperance. It is this which robs the pocket of the poor man; this which benumbs his brain, destroys his faculties, and predisposes himself and his children to fatal disease. It is this that breeds sensuality in all its protean and disgusting forms; this which induces shiftlessness and irresponsibility among the masses, and this which saps the life from those who would otherwise be healthy and vigorous. The statistics of almshouses, workhouses, penitentiaries, asylums, and hospitals all attest this dark and gloomy fact. A sure remedy for this sweeping scourge, so devastating in its deadly influence, is beyond human ken. Yet if the malignant character of this enemy of the people’s health, and its far-reaching tendencies toward disease and death, were more thoroughly understood, a revolution in sentiment on the question might the more readily be inaugurated. If the masses of intelligent citizens will examine carefully the records and the case books at your hospitals, they will find in them most convincing evidence that a large proportion of pauperism and life-destroying disease is caused by the excessive use of intoxicating liquors. The creation of an almost universal popular sentiment that shall not only uphold the passage, but insure the enforcement of restricting laws is the most hopeful remedy.”

In another report the Commissioners say, referring to the large number of persons committed for simple acts of intoxication unaccompanied by disorderly conduct or breach of the peace:—

“The law imposes a penalty of $10 upon every person found intoxicated in the public streets, and in default of payment they are committed to the workhouse for ten days. A large proportion of the inmates of the workhouse are common drunkards. They are sent up by the magistrates clothed in rags, covered with vermin, and broken down in health by their debauchery. They must be clothed at the expense of the city, and by the time they are discharged from the care of the physician and are capable of labor, their term of imprisonment expires and they are released, to be in a few days sent back, their clothing destroyed, again to be re-clothed and assigned to the hospital. It would be difficult to devise a more expensive or ineffectual means of reformation than is by law established.”

In their report for 1875 the Commissioners of Charities and Corrections say of the Inebriate Asylum:—

“This establishment has been given a fair trial, and no means have been spared to make, if possible, one successful inebriate asylum. The conclusion the experiment has led to is that habitual drunkenness is not to be regarded as a disease, but as a habit practically within the control of each individual case. The majority of those admitted during the year were so demoralized by excessive drinking that their discontent was only appeased by the knowledge that their time of commitment would soon expire, and they would again be at liberty to return to their former imbibitions. There is little need of asylums for the cure of this infirmity, for the very small number who desire reformation can attain the object at home and with their families. The Commissioners, from past experience, are of the opinion that the public funds can be put to a much better use than in equipping and maintaining an inebriate asylum.”

PRISON STATISTICS.

“Out of 51,466 persons committed to the city prisons in a single year, 34,316 were of foreign birth, and 17,150 native; of 19,342 females, 14,077 were foreign born, and 5,265 native. Of all the males 19,937 were intemperate, and 12,187 temperate; of all the females, 12,770 were intemperate and 6,572 temperate. In the same year 31,491 were sent to the First District Prison—the Tombs. These were from the lower part of the city, where the foreign element largely predominated. The arrests directly or indirectly caused by the use of liquor were:—

Males Females Totals
Assaults 2,058 295 2,353
Delirium Tremens 14 — 14
Disorderly conduct 4,679 4,159 8,838
Intoxication 5,462 7,593 13,055
Vagrancy 1,007 645 1,652
Totals 13,220 12,692 25,912

Of the 254 persons admitted to the Asylum for the Insane in a single year, 127 were intemperate, 69 moderate drinkers, 55 unknown, and only 3 abstinents. Another year’s record shows 280 intemperate, 90 moderate drinkers, 17 abstinents, and 11 unknown.

“If we assume, and we believe it to be much within bounds, that 70 per cent of the crime and pauperism of the city is chargeable to the use and abuse of intoxicating liquors, we shall have to charge to liquor that percentage of the cost of the Police Department, of the Department of Charities and Correction, of the criminal courts, and properly a considerable fraction of the expenses of the Health and Fire Departments. In 1880 the following appropriations, excluding the money for street cleaning, were made:—

For Police Department, $3,459,917 Police Courts and Gen’l Sessions, about, $350,000 Charities and Correction, 1,618,680 Total $5,428,597

Awarding 70 per cent of these items to liquor, we find the figures to be $3,800,015. With various items that cannot be precisely classified, we may put the round sum at $4,000,000, or $3.30 for each man, woman, and child of our population.

RUM AND CRIME HAND IN HAND.

“The Excise Board do not seem to know how many places they have licensed, nor to have any definite idea how many rum shops there are in the city. But in 1877, the year of the smallest receipt for licenses, a census was made by police precincts. This showed in the whole city 7,874 liquor shops, of which 2,177 had licenses. There were at that time in the Fourth precinct 440 liquor shops, to a population of 20,000, and in the Fourteenth precinct 387 to a population of 30,000.

“Here was 1 ‘gin-mill’ for every 60 inhabitants. The Ninth precinct had just about as many inhabitants, with twice as much territory, and 250 liquor shops—1 to 200 inhabitants. Now, the records of police arrests for the last six months of 1880 show this comparison:—

Liquor Shops Men Women Total
Fourth precinct 440 2,072 1,259 3,331
Fourteenth prec’t. 387 2,153 1,361 3,514
Ninth precinct 250 889 182 1,071

“The precincts named correspond almost exactly to the wards of the same numbers. The two rum-ridden precincts (the Fourth and Fourteenth) furnished almost 20 per cent of all the arrests in the city. It is needless to say that more than seven-eighths of the arrests were chargeable to drink.”