AdventAI

THE CHURCH AND STATE CONFLICT IN PRUSSIA.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 21., November 22, 1881

There is evidently a growing spirit of compromise now appearing between Prussia and the Vatican, and both parties are anxiously looking forward for some means whereby to end a conflict that has in some regards been bootless to them both.

The main cause of the trouble was the senseless endeavor on the part of Pius the Ninth to force Prussia and Germany to bow to the insane demand of the syllabus. This late pontiff was nothing if not obstinate, and unless he could rule in the new Germany that was about to arise out of the conflict between France and the whole series of German States, he seemed determined to ruin. This interference with its internal officers Prussia especially repudiated by a long series of enactments in self-defense against the aggression of the church, of which the crowning ones were the May Laws, mainly intended to take all educational matters out of the hands of the priests and Jesuits, and confide them to those of lay teachers appointed and sustained by the State. The result was a refusal on the part of the ecclesiastical agents of the State to obey its dictates, which rebellion ended in the deposition of a great number of church dignitaries, from bishops down to the lowest church officials.

These malcontents then commenced a fierce conflict with the State on the political arena, which has lasted with varying fortunes until quite recently, when negotiations began between the two parties with a view to cease hostilities and come to a better understanding of their mutual relations. Now both sides claim a victory in this result, which in reality belongs to neither. Bismarck has not been humiliated by the pope, nor has the latter and the Curia absolutely yielded any vital position. The May Laws are not abrogated on the one hand, nor are the claims of the church abandoned on the other. But while Leo XIII. has assumed a conciliatory policy in great contrast with that of his predecessor, the State has gladly accepted and welcomed advances by administering the offensive laws in the mildest manner, so as to make it easy for willing ecclesiastics to resume all their church functions.

The first practical outgrowth of this renewal of negotiations and resumption of duties, is the installation of the new Bishop Korum, in the diocese of Treves, which has given rise to great rejoicings on the part of the Catholics of that district, who have given him a grand reception on his entrance into the old city of Treves to assume his duties. But this first episcopal appointment does not in a manner change the political situation, for the same laws exist to-day that were in force a year ago; it simply opens the way to find a means to live together in harmony instead of rebellion and antagonism. The act offers much for the future in the possibilities for negotiation, for which reason a great deal is now said about the resumption of relations between Prussia and the Vatican. If this takes place by means of a resident ambassador in Rome, as now hinted, it will only be in the effort on the part of the State to be better informed of the true position of the pontiff and his court. Indeed, the principal significance of the act is the fact that the State is leaving the so-called ultramontane party of Prussia in the background, and is communicating over their heads directly with the head of the Catholic Church—and this to the discomfiture of the great body of Prussian Catholics, who have enjoyed the opportunity of using their church influence for political purposes.

The installation of the new Bishop is, therefore, the indication of a change in the manner of conducting the conflict in the future, not an abandonment of the position formerly taken. And the only concession made by the Curia is the cessation of the stubborn resistance adopted by Pius IX., whose policy in Prussian church matters was to let things go as they might, and then throw all the blame for the misfortunes of the church on the State. It was a sort of strike on the part of the employés of the pope, by his order, refusing to move on with their work until the abrogation of certain conditions that were imposed on those who really paid and employed the parties to carry on the work of the Catholic Church in Prussia. The worse matters became, the louder would the Ultramontanes exclaim, “See the result of the May Laws!” And when it was clearly demonstrated to them that it lay in the power of the church to mend matters, there came back the same answer: “Abolish the May Laws, and we will step in and make things right.” In this effort to embarrass the State, the Ultramontanes have not hesitated to call to their aid the worst elements of discontent and disloyalty; they and the Socialists and Communists have frequently joined hands to effect some hostile purpose toward the State; and when the people were ready to support good and useful measures, the Catholic clergy would incite to antagonism toward the State authorities.

This mode of procedure is now in a fair way to be greatly altered by a conciliatory policy on the part of the church, as is shown by decisive action of the State in rejecting several vicars elected for other dioceses, with a full knowledge of their antagonisms to the State. These were rejected, while Doctor Korum was accepted and welcomed by the State authorities as an official who would endeavor to cultivate harmony instead of discord. Therefore, this opposition is one that causes rejoicing on both sides, as promising less bootless conflict in the future, and much less interference on the part of the church in the political or rather partisan questions of the hour. Great hopes are now cherished in the minds of all that this unfortunate conflict may cease, and the new Bishop may succeed in bringing peace and reconciliation into his diocese.

No section of Prussia has so much suffered from this struggle between the church and the State as has this diocese of Treves. The city is full of ecclesiastics of all names and functions, priests, seminarians, friars, etc., who deftly used invisible hands to move the masses and control them, so that it was a political machine in full blast. The older and more tolerant portion of the clergy could gain no hearing with the masses, and measures were carried that were clearly intended to insult and embarrass the State, and the latter taught them a good lesson in rejecting their nominations for vicars or bishops, and accepting that of a conciliatory and wise prelate, who is known to be honest and efficient, and who will do his best to advance an era of peace. He will doubtless meet with some opposition from those who did not want him, but his high position in the church will make his wishes respected, and his policy in this first of the vacated Episcopal chairs a model for others in the future. The State now proposes to proceed to accept all candidates for the remaining empty chairs who are presented in the right spirit, with the sanction of the pope. But in doing this it repudiates the charge of yielding principles, and performs just what it would have done long ago had the papal authorities made the concessions that are now granted. And, therefore, we do not see in this policy so much a failure on the part of the State to effect its purpose, as a disposition to accept this in the way of compromise.—Christian Weekly.