The Christian Advocate of Dec. 1 publishes an editorial article on “Insanity Experts,” showing the prominent part played by these gentlemen in all important law cases, particularly in murder trials. The persistence with which this plea is urged in the case of the assassin Guiteau may help to arouse public attention on this point. While it would be cruel to punish a really insane man, we cannot but feel that this plea is urged to an extent that makes the query pertinent, “Are all criminals insane?” The Advocate says:—
“The superintendents of our great public lunatic asylums, where their appointment does not depend on the mutations of local politics, and of the best private institutions, are among the most learned and honorable men in the country. But there is a class of professional insanity experts who are retained in most important cases. Some of them stand high as specialists in brain and nervous diseases; some were formerly assistants in lunatic asylums, and some are professors in medical colleges. Of these, a very few are reliable men, whose words are entitled to great weight. But of some it has long been observed that they testify unscrupulously for the side that retains them; of others, that in different cases they testify in an almost contradictory manner; of others, that they appear to have the notion that all criminals are crazy. As certainly as an important murder trial occurs, as certainly as an important will is contested on the ground of the alleged insanity or mental weakness of the testator, so certainly do these experts appear. Seldom do they have any doubt; the case is plain; the man is crazy or not crazy, according to the position which they are brought forward to sustain. Seldom, if ever, in the course of the investigation, is one of them known to convert an ‘expert’ on the other side to his views. Those who once swear that the person is sane never afterward admit that he is crazy, and those who once testify that he is crazy never afterward concede that he is sane. With regard to wills, the testator is dead, or supposed to be dead, when his will is probated, and his subsequent conduct can shed no light on the question whether he was of sound mind or not. But in murder cases, where the prisoner is acquitted on the ground of insanity, or where that plea is strongly made in his behalf and he escapes, his subsequent life shows whether he was insane or not. The fact is that a large proportion of those who thus escape never show any signs of insanity afterward. The plea of insanity was powerfully urged in behalf of Gen. Daniel E. Sickles when he was tried for the murder of Philip Barton Key. He has since fought through the war, and been Minister of the United States to the Spanish Court, and returned to his former party allegiance. Daniel M’Farland, who murdered A. D. Richardson, was acquitted on this plea, but has never since shown any other evidences of insanity than dissipated and ill-tempered men generally do. Fanny Hyde, of Brooklyn, and Mrs. Margaret P. M’Carthy, were both acquitted of atrocious murders, principally on the testimony of ‘insanity experts,’ one of whom testified in both cases. Neither has been insane since. General Cole, who slew Hiscock, was acquitted on the same ground. So was Miss Mink, of Maine, for shooting a physician, and Mrs. Fair, the infamous Californian. These all were not insane, or were cured by the crime, or by the testimony of the insanity experts.(!) Numerous instances could be given of criminals thus acquitted, who have lived in luxury at asylums for a few months, and then been discharged, ‘having recovered their reason.’”
“The community does not expect a trial for murder in high life without an attempt to prove by experts the prisoner to have been insane. But if a man were really irresponsibly insane when he committed a crime, or if he were sane enough to incur guilt, it can be proven to the satisfaction of a court and jury without the finespun theories and microscopical distinctions of the ‘insanity experts.’”
“In Guiteau’s case the testimony of experts may or may not preponderate in favor of his insanity. The government is strong and popular, and he is weak and detested, yet close inspection confirms the view tersely expressed by the Daily News, of London, Eng., last week in the following words:—
“LONDON, Nov. 24.—It seems obvious that the question of Guiteau’s sanity and responsibility is a matter of word-chopping and of psychological casuistry. Guiteau is perfectly well aware of the nature of the act. We might say that Guiteau was crazed, just as so many people are called cracked who are yet acknowledged to be fit to control their own affairs. If Guiteau is declared insane, a vast number of people like him, feathered-brained, conceited fools, will justly infer that they too may indulge in eccentricities and murder.”
“In any event, the testimony of so-called experts in insanity is of least value and most open to suspicion of all that may come before the jury of twelve, or the greater jury of all civilized nations.”
The opinion of Dr. Samuel G. Armor, Dean of the Faculty of the Long Island College Hospital, as given the Guiteau trial, is very pointed and sensible. He says: “The world is full of Guiteaus,—ill-balanced mental monstrosities, composed of badly arranged intellectual forces, feeble moral faculties, and enormous self-conceit. . . . If such persons are pronounced irresponsible for their deliberately planned purposes of murder, society has no longer any safeguard against the worst elements in its population. Compared with such characters, insane people are comparatively harmless, for they are usually confined.”