In a recent number of the REVIEW we noticed an article entitled, “A Dangerous Counterfeit.” In regard to all such counterfeits we feel like saying, as did one of old, “If this work be of man, it will come to naught; but if it be of God, ye cannot overturn it.” And again it is said, “By their fruits ye shall know them.” But says one (of a spurious faith), Why has not our faith come to naught? Our numbers are increasing constantly. In reply we answer, Why have not Romanism, Mohammedanism, Mormonism, Spiritualism, and many other erroneous isms, come to naught, as they are not of God? They will come to naught in the day of final reckoning. We know that all of these isms are not of God, as their evil fruits are clearly seen.
In a recent tent-meeting conducted by the “Holiness People,” which the writer attended a few times, the demonstrations of falling over, etc., were quite similar to those represented in the article entitled, “A Dangerous Counterfeit.” If the Spirit of God prompts the people to speak very loud, we say, Amen; for the psalmist says, “Let the inhabitants of the Rock sing; let them shout from the tops of the mountains.” If it makes some fall upon the ground, we must say, Amen. But when some are shouting, others jerking, others praying, others singing, speaking, and laughing, all at the same time, it is hard for us to believe that this work is of God; for “God is not the author of confusion, but of peace,” and requires that everything be done “decently and in order.”
Finally, when these people become so holy as to claim that the law or decalogue is not binding in this age of the world, and that the Sabbath is a “side issue,” we have great reason to think that their holiness is not genuine. In the meeting alluded to, a gentleman whose attention has recently been called to the subject of the Sabbath presented the following question: “Do you consider the law binding in this age of the world?” The preacher, as if anticipating what was coming, replied, “Not as a whole.” The interrogator, not yet satisfied, said, “We wish to know what you will do with the Sabbath of the fourth commandment?” After making a few remarks representing that he would not unchristianize those who kept the Jewish Sabbath, he closed by saying that he considered the Sabbath question a “side issue”!
If the law in this age is not binding as a whole, when did it cease to be binding? It had not ceased to be binding when Christ delivered his sermon on the mount (Matt. 5:19; he recognized all the precepts of the law); nor when he told the young man that if he would enter into life, he must “keep the commandments” (all, not a part of them). Neither had it ceased in Paul’s day (Rom. 3:21), as he did not say, “We do not establish the law ‘as a whole,’ but, ‘Yea, we establish the [whole] law.’” It did not cease to be binding in A. D. 96, when John wrote the book of Revelation; for he did not say (Rev. 22:14), “Blessed are they who do a part of His commandments”; but, “Blessed are they that do [all] His commandments.”
These preachers of holiness may, like a certain popular modern divine, think that the law was made for the barbarous age of the world, and is of no use now. If it can be proved that the Sabbath is only for the Jews, or a Jewish institution, then our opponents will gain the point. If the Sabbath is a “side issue,” then the law is a side issue. Ask one of these sanctified men what he will do with the man who commits theft, adultery, etc.; and, to be consistent, he should reply, “Oh, those commandments are ‘side issues’!” This, no doubt, is the way the Free Methodists (referred to in the article entitled, “A Dangerous Counterfeit”) would dispose of the question.
Wm. Penniman.