THE FATHERS

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 9, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 7.

Read the full edition

THE FATHERS.

BY H. WREN.
(Concluded.)

BARDESANES.

This writer says: “On one day, the first of the week, we assembled ourselves together,” etc. Bardesanes is ranked as a heretic. He was a Gnostic, which shows what kind of a heretic he was. It means that he belonged to that mystical class who, in all ages, attach but little importance to the literal language of the Bible, but depend upon an inward guide. The Gnostics believed in the writings of Plato, and were far more Platonic in doctrine than Biblical. Like others who held to the first-day festival, he did so without attempting to give any Bible authority for the practice.

THEOPHILUS OF ANTIOCH.

This Father is alleged to have said: “Both custom and reason challenge from us that we should honor the Lord’s day, seeing on that day our Lord completed his resurrection from the dead.” J. N. Andrews says: “I have carefully examined every paragraph of all the extant writings of this Father, and that several times over, without discovering any such statement, I am constrained to state that nothing of the kind above quoted is to be found in Theophilus.”
—Complete Testimony of the Fathers, p. 55.

THE APOSTOLICAL CONSTITUTIONS.

It is often claimed that these writings were framed in the apostolic age, if not by the apostles themselves. Guericke, in his Church History, says of them: “This is a collection of ecclesiastical statutes purporting to be the work of the apostolic age, but in reality formed gradually in the second, third, and fourth centuries.” These documents enjoin in a number of places the observance of Sunday, under the title of the Lord’s day. Here is an instance: “But keep the Sabbath and Lord’s day festival, because the former is the memorial of creation, and the latter of the resurrection.” It is easy to show from the Bible that the Sabbath is the memorial of creation, and that Christians should keep it; but where would one turn in the Bible to show that Sunday is the memorial of Christ’s resurrection, or that anybody ought to observe it as such? The above quotation shows that Sunday was only a festival; that is, a voluntary institution, like Easter and other days. There is quite as much in the Apostolical Constitutions enjoining the observance of the Sabbath as there is enjoining the observance of Sunday. Besides, when speaking of the Sabbath, they refer to its Bible character and design, but they never refer us to the Bible to find authority for Sunday observance. This absence of reference to the Bible on this point, by all these early writings, is a plain confession on the part of their authors, that they were not acting in the matter in harmony with that book. We come now to

TERTULLIAN.

one of the greatest of the Fathers; and on this subject generally thought to be very strong. He says: “We solemnize the day after Saturday, in contradistinction to those who call this day their Sabbath.”—Reeve’s Translation, p. 1. There are several other passages in his writings to the same effect. But he says in another place: “The Lord commanded the eucharist to be eaten at meal times,” and, “We make offerings for the dead as often as the anniversary [of the resurrection] comes round. We count fasting or kneeling in worship on the Lord’s day to be unlawful. We rejoice in the same privilege also from Easter to Whitsunday. We feel pained should any wine or bread, even though our own, be cast upon the ground. At every forward step and movement, at every going in and out, when we put on our clothes and shoes, when we bathe, when we sit at table, when we light the lamps, on couch, on seat, in all the ordinary actions of daily life, we trace upon the forehead the sign [of the cross].” Then, like an honest man, he proceeds to tell us what his authority is for these things. He says: “If, for these and other such rules, you insist upon having positive Scriptural injunction, you will find none. Tradition will be held forth to you as the originator of them.”—De Corona, sects. 3, 4.
The foregoing shows that Tertullian had ceased to regard the Bible as the only source of authority in religious matters, and had no hesitancy in following customs and ceremonies which he acknowledged could not be found in the word of God. We will now show that he did not claim that the Sabbath was done away by Christ, but by his adversary. In his book known as “Tertullian Against Marcion,” he uses this vigorous language: “Christ exhibits in a clear light the different kinds of work, while doing what the law excepts from the sacredness of the Sabbath, while imparting to the Sabbath itself, which from the beginning had been consecrated by the benediction of the Fathers, an additional sanctity, by his own beneficent action. For he furnished to this day divine safeguards, a course which his adversary would have pursued for some other days, to avoid honoring the Creator’s Sabbath.”
What could have induced Tertullian to make such statements as these, bearing so heavily as they do against the very work he was engaged in, if he did not know they were true? He says that Christ furnished the Sabbath divine safeguards; and that it was his adversary that would have this done for some other days. This is an honest confession that those who were seeking to substitute Sunday observance in place of the Sabbath, not only were acting without authority from Christ, but contrary to his will. Such is the conclusion to which the writings of Tertullian conduct us.

ORIGEN.

Origen is brought out as a good witness for Sunday observance. He says: “If it be objected to us on this subject, that we ourselves are accustomed to observe certain days, as for example the Lord’s day, the preparation, the passover, or pentecost, I have to answer, that, to the perfect Christian, all his days are the Lord’s, and he is always keeping the Lord’s day.”—Against Celsus, book 8, chap. 4. This passage shows that Origen classed Sunday-keeping with several other festival days, and finally, with all the days of the week, by saying that all days are the Lord’s. Origen’s real belief was that there is no day more sacred than another. We close the list with

EUSEBIUS.

This writer lived in the first half of the fourth century. He was the friend of Constantine, and an able writer. His account of Sunday observance is somewhat on the grandiloquent style. He says: “Christ, by the new covenant, translated and transferred the feast of the Sabbath to the morning light, and gave us the symbol of true rest; viz., the saving Lord’s day, the first of the light, in which the Saviour of the world, after all his labor among men, obtained the victory over death, and passed the portals of Heaven, having achieved a work greater than the six days creation.” He says in the above passage that Christ transferred the feast of the Sabbath to Sunday; but a little further down he contradicts this statement by saying: “All things whatsoever it was duty to do on the Sabbath, these we have transferred to the Lord’s day.” (See “Cox’s Sabbath Literature, vol. 1, p. 361.)
So much for the Fathers. What have they said to show that we can follow them in upholding the observance of Sunday in place of the Sabbath? They never tell us where in the word of God we can find the Sabbath changed to the first day of the week, or where we can find it stated that Christ caused the Sabbath to cease and erected a Lord’s day in place of it. They have been as silent as death about the Bible when speaking in behalf of the first day. One professed to quote that sacred book, but so mutilated and added to its language that any one can see his zeal far outstripped his piety and reverence.
Another, in attempting to draw an argument from that book, made it support the observance of the day on which God began creation, instead of the day after he ended it, as the Bible expressly says. While a third says it was the adversary who wanted to change the Sabbath to another day. A fourth appeals to a heathen philosopher. While one alone says that Christ did it; but in the very next verse he repents, and says that himself and other men did it. Besides, nearly all of them speak of the seventh day as the true Sabbath of the Bible.
Why did these Fathers make such a poor spectacle of that day that was to be the central feature of the New-Testament dispensation, as is now taught, if Christ and his apostles authorized them to make the change? Why did they not boldly produce their divine authority, instead of pursuing the weak and extremely doubtful course they did? The answer is easy. There was no authority of a divine character to appeal to, and they knew it. Many at this day make arguments that are but little, if any, better than those of the Fathers, simply because they have no real, solid material to use in the case.
We shall now give a few extracts from the writings of leading Protestants, to show in what esteem the Fathers are held by those best acquainted with their writings.
Dr. Adam Clarke speaks thus of them: “There is not a heresy that has disgraced the Romish church that may not challenge them as its abettors. In point of doctrine, their authority is with me nothing.”—Com. on Prov. 8.
Martin Luther says: “When God’s word is by the Fathers expounded, construed, and glossed, then, in my judgment, it is even like unto one that straineth milk through a coal sack, which must needs spoil the milk, and make it black; even so, likewise, God’s word is sufficiently pure, clean, bright, and clear, but through the doctrines, books, and writings of the Fathers it is very surely darkened, falsified, and spoiled.”—Table Talk, p. 228.
Dr. Cox says: “In the early ages of the church, the writings of the Fathers were corrupted without scruple, to serve the purpose of contending sects. The truth is, that the practice of vitiating, and even of forging whole treatises and letters, detracts materially from the value of all that has come down to us as the productions of the Fathers.”—Cox’s Literature, vol. 1, p. 123.
Du Pin says: “It is a surprising thing to consider how many spurious books we find in antiquity; nay, even in the first ages of the church.”
The Fathers are the men who laid the foundation of Roman Catholicism; and hence the Catholics always appeal to the Fathers. Adam Clarke says: “No part of a Protestant’s creed stands on the decision of Fathers and councils. By appealing to the Bible alone as the only rule of faith and practice of Christians, they [the Reformers] confounded and defeated their papistical adversaries, who could not prove their doctrines but by Fathers and councils.”—Com. on Prov. 8.
The doctrines and ceremonies that shut the light of God’s word out of the world, and kept men in the most profound darkness for a thousand years and more during the Dark Ages, were drawn from the Fathers; and every advance step taken by men, in coming back into the light of God’s word, has been met and opposed by an appeal to the Fathers. Luther, Zwingle, Calvin, Knox, Wesley, and all other reformers, have been confronted by the Fathers; as if the world were not allowed to advance without the consent of the Fathers. And now, the same old Fathers are flung across the path of the Sabbath reform. But the Sabbath, like every other down-trodden truth, will rise and assert itself in spite of the Fathers, or those who appeal to them.
“Truth crushed to earth will rise again; The eternal years of God are hers.”
But it may be asked, Did not some of the Fathers live in the second century, within forty or fifty years of the death of the last apostle? And how could they be in error so near the time of those who had been inspired? We have already shown that the sacrament of the Lord’s supper had been changed in the days of Justin Martyr, by adding water to it, and by sending it to the absent. Now, Justin lived as near to the apostolic age as any Father. We have shown that in the time of Tertullian, A. D. 200, the sign of the cross was made at every act of life; also that offerings for the dead were made, that Easter and a number of other days were observed, and that tradition had come to be openly appealed to in defiance of Scripture.
Here is what Robinson says of the early ages of the church: “Toward the latter end of the second century, most of the churches assumed a new form, the first simplicity disappeared, and insensibly, as the old disciples retired to their graves, their children, along with new converts, both Jews and Gentiles, came forward and now modeled the cause.”—History of Baptism, book 2, chap. 1, sec. 1.
Archibald Bower says: “False and lying traditions are of an early date; and the greatest men, out of a pious credulity, have suffered themselves to be imposed upon by them.”—History of Popes, vol. 1, p. 1.
Taylor says: “The period dating its commencement from the death of the last of the apostles, or apostolic men, was altogether as little deserving to be selected and proposed as a pattern as any one of the first five of church history. We need, therefore, neither feel surprise nor alarm, when we find in particular instances that the grossest errors of theory and practice are to be traced to the first century. The scheme of religious sentiment had shifted its foundation; a different standard of good and evil had come to be appealed to, and the commandments of God were displaced without scruple by the whims of man.”
How could the Sabbath remain as God had given it in such an age, and among such men? Discarding the teachings of men, whether the ancient Fathers or their modern followers, let us “fear God and keep his commandments;” for God will judge both the ancient and modern Fathers, and all others, by his word.