Conference Boundaries

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 2, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 1.

Read the full edition

Conference Boundaries.

THE readers of the REVIEW have probably noticed, in the report of the General Conference Committee last week, the resolutions passed concerning the boundaries of our State Conferences. The subject was quite thoroughly canvassed, and an auditing committee of four leading brethren was added to the General Conference Committee, making a committee of seven, to consider the whole subject.
The preambles and resolutions reported in last week’s REVIEW were the result of much thoughtful deliberation. The reasons why this subject was considered by the Conference, were that confusion seemed likely to arise in the future. Some has already arisen in the past. The Wisconsin Conference had one church within the limits of the State of Illinois. Minnesota had two or three companies within the limits of Iowa, and some ten churches in the State of Wisconsin.
The question of boundary lines has never been considered, to any great extent, in our counsels during the past. Ministers laboring in one Conference near the limits of another have freely crossed the State lines, and labored in the territory of another Conference, where they thought a good interest existed; then, if a company came out, and were organized into a church, it was natural they should connect themselves with that Conference which sent the laborer to them, and brought them into the truth. After a while the Conference located in the State where such companies had been raised up, would send laborers into that vicinity.
It can readily be seen that some embarrassment would be likely to arise in the formation of ministerial and tract-society districts, where companies belonging to two different Conferences were found close to each other. The difficulties in the past on this subject have not been so great as to cause serious trouble, although some dissatisfaction has already resulted from this condition; but it seemed important that these matters should be considered, and some principle of settlement adopted. After giving the matter much thought, the committee appointed by the Conference recommended that the boundary lines of a State “should, in all cases, be the boundary lines of the Conference bearing the name of said State, except in cases where good reasons shall exist for varying this rule.”
This general principle seemed to commend itself to the good judgment of all, as being the only proper rule to adopt; and we feel sure that this principle will be the established one, and that all exceptions will sometime in the future be brought to correspond with it. Because this matter has not been fully understood in the past, and the boundaries of our Conferences have sometimes diverged from this principle, certain exceptions—temporary we trust in duration—were provided for by the committee; such as the Scandinavian church in Chicago, and the boundaries between New York and Pennsylvania and some churches which are with the New England Conference for the present. Some of these exceptions arise from the fact that the cause is not strong enough in some of the States mentioned to form State Conferences without the assistance of the stronger Conferences which lie near to them. This difficulty will perhaps disappear in time.
Our Scandinavian brethren in Chicago, having received their ministerial help mostly from the Wisconsin Conference, naturally desired to be with that Conference, and by vote expressed that choice. The committee appointed to consider this subject hardly felt it would be proper to deny this wish on their part, for the present; but we hope in the near future, after a more full consideration of the subject, that they will conclude to connect themselves with the Conference in the State where they are located. It seems to us that it would be better to have all the churches in any given territory belong to the same Conference, rather than with a different one. It will avoid confusion, and save great trouble; it will tend to union, because of similarity of interests.
One of the most perplexing questions the committee had to consider, was the course to be pursued in reference to some ten churches belonging to the Minnesota Conference, within the limits of Wisconsin. It seemed quite a loss to the Minnesota Conference to take them from that State to connect them with Wisconsin. It involved many perplexing questions. We feared it might not be pleasing to the brethren belonging to these churches, and yet we could see no other way to do than to advise the establishment of the boundary lines of the Conference to correspond with the line of the State in question. Wisconsin reasonably claimed all of the territory within the lines of that State as belonging to that Conference. She was already sending laborers into that field to follow up interests created by her tract workers. It was not reasonable that these Conferences should have churches mixed up together, with no well ascertained boundary lines between them. It was almost certain to result in difficulty and trouble in the future, and might even occasion bitterness of feeling. The longer the matter remained unsettled, the worse would be the difficulty; and although the shock seemed considerable to make the change now, yet on the whole it was thought best to do so.
In the settlement, quite a sum was allotted to the Minnesota Conference for the labor expended in the past in raising up these churches. The officers of both Conferences, being present, accepted the settlement in good faith and with cheerfulness, and we trust our brethren belonging to the churches in question will acquiesce in it, and that no further trouble may arise from this perplexing question. We understand that meetings will be held in these churches in the near future, and that the whole matter will be properly explained to the brethren by representatives of both Conferences, and we greatly hope that mutual good feeling will prevail. A settlement was also made in reference to the Minnesota churches within the bounds of Iowa.
One other point must not be forgotten,—that which relates to the churches whose members are separated by State lines. There are several companies of this kind in different parts of the field, the place of meeting being situated near the State line, and members living both sides of it. It was decided that where members usually attend the meetings of such churches as are partly in one State and partly in another, a majority of such a church shall decide to which Conference they will belong, and the individual members may pay their tithes to which Conference they choose. Hereafter, if a minister of one of the Conferences goes into the territory of another to labor, and raises up a company, before he organizes a church he must obtain the full consent of the Conference in whose territory the company is located.
We trust this settlement will avoid all difficulties in the future, and that all parties interested will carefully consider the decisions made by the General Conference.
GEO. I. BUTLER.