RETRIBUTION, NOT PUNISHMENT.
An article under the above heading by the Rev. James H. Ecob, published in the Christian Union of Dec. 28, while inculcating some doctrines that we cannot indorse, contains some wholesome truths so vigorously told that we cannot forbear sharing them with the readers of the REVIEW. Speaking of the evil effects of a belief that the punishment of sin is wholly in the future, Mr. Ecob says of death-bed repentance:— “Men have been taught, or perhaps it would be more charitable to say, from our teaching have somehow got it into their heads, that that future whipping is the one thing to be dreaded. It does not come in this life. The only item calculated to ‘give us pause’ is the uncertainty of life. So our congregations are full of men who are ‘taking the risk.’ Practical righteousness is adjourned; practical wickedness indulged; and in the background is this thin purpose, this flimsy hope: ‘By and by, when I have squeezed the world of its last drop, I will turn my face to the wall and weep a little, and get my minister to pray a little. I will take a turn or two at that mysterious something-or-other, faith, and so beg off from that long-promised whipping, and then I am scot-free forever.’ This is no travesty; it is a transcript from life. I could myself give names of these dying saints who have been resuscitated to a most lusty career of iniquity. Repentance in its entire significance is perverted by this scheme of the future. It is made, not a turning point from living sin against a living God, but a makeshift to avert the penalties due to past sin to be inflicted by a future God.” After denouncing the idea that men are “saved, not from sin, but from the effects of sin,” he says:— “Our future scheme fastens the thoughts upon rewards, not holiness; upon penalties, not upon sin. A salvation that saves us from the pains of sin instead of from sin itself is a damnation. If I could invent a medicine that would save the drunkard from headache and ‘shameful spewing’ and delirium, I would be hardly less malevolent than Satan to make it known. ‘God hath yoked to guilt her pale tormentor, misery;’ what God hath joined, let not man put asunder.” Again he says: “‘Sin is the transgression of the law.’ God’s law is right; i. e., rectilinear. Sin pushes or strains the law from this true rectitude, and it pays back, upon the sinner.”