AdventAI

Something Concerning “Corners” and “Futures.”

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 2., January 9, 1883

As unlawful speculations are now prominently before the public, the Christian Weekly gives its readers a chapter on the subject, from which we extract the following:—

A “corner” in business operations is defined by Mr. Rufus Hatch, who knows what he is talking about, as “buying more than there is in existence of any commodity.” A “future,” according to the same authority, is “buying what you don’t want from a man who hasn’t got it.” Yet a very large portion of the business of the various exchanges of the country is of this character. Mr. Hatch says that this system of speculation is not, in his opinion, beneficial to the country. “It is beneficial,” he says, “to a very few individuals. The others—we call them ‘lambs’—we fleece when they come down to Wall street.”

There seems to be a general concurrence in the opinion, Mr. Jay Gould excepted, that speculation, at least in its extreme forms, is only harmful. Indeed, how could it be otherwise? Here is Mr. Hatch confessing: “I owned last June a year ago three times as much corn as there was in the city of Chicago. I bought other people’s imaginations. If I had held it thirty days longer, I would have made $600,000 more than I did. It was as illegitimate as could be. I bought what I didn’t want, and the other man sold what he didn’t have.” But now somebody must pay the final price of these transactions. Mr. Vanderbilt puts it in a nutshell, when, saying that he never bought stock for speculation, while multitudes in Wall street never put up a cent on their transactions, he added, “I’m like the man who goes to the tailor—I expect to pay for my own clothes and for all those who don’t pay.” It is the legitimate industry of the country that must pay for the transactions of the speculators. As Mr. Hatch said, if the present methods continue, “the end will be that every few years we’ll have a smash up as we did in 1873, a Black Friday.” It is not with over-much consolation that he adds, “But the recuperative power of this country is extraordinary, and we’ll be on our feet very quickly.”

As to the remedy, we have no wisdom. It does not seem to us that legislation can accomplish much. Men that want to speculate will find some way of doing it in spite of any legislation that can be devised. Moral evils cannot be cured by legislative enactment. It is the testimony of long experience that laws are worth no more than the moral sentiment that is behind them. The main remedy that we see is, to discourage, by every available means, the spirit of speculation, and especially to cultivate in young men the desire to be producers, adding to the real wealth of the world, rather than mere speculators, dealing in “other people’s imaginations.”

The Senate Committee have been discussing the morals of speculation with Messrs. Gould, Vanderbilt, and Keene. Mr. Vanderbilt thus expresses hearty disapproval of these practices: “I think all these transactions are wrong and immoral. They have a bad tendency. They have a bad tendency on young men, who are a great concern to all of us. They tend to idleness, to getting money easily.”

The fact that “speculations, whether on the stock or produce exchanges, are a fruitful source of individual dishonesty,” is forcibly illustrated in the following paragraph from the New York Observer of Dec. 28:—

Mr. C. E. Upton, who is President of the City Bank of Rochester, besides being a member of a prominent broker’s firm in this city, has been for some time operating in oil; and it is just now discovered that in order to cover his losses he has misappropriated the funds of the bank—to the extent, it is said, of $350,000. The bank has been obliged, in consequence, to suspend, and its failure has carried down, also, another concern at Victor, N. Y. A like case is reported from Jefferson, Ohio, where the cashier and assistant cashier of the Second National Bank are defaulters to the amount of from $50,000 to $75,000. Both men had been indulging in speculations which turned out badly. When the exposure came, the cashier absconded, while his assistant, and partner in crime, was stricken with paralysis.