AdventAI

IX. A Famous Falsehood Exposed

By H. A. St. John

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 16., April 17, 1883

SYNOPSIS.—SECULAR HISTORY OF THE SABBATH.—NO. 3.

BY ELD. H. A. ST. JOHN.

IX. A Famous Falsehood Exposed.

IN the time of Pliny, A. D. 104, Dr. Edwards says that “persecutors when they wished to know whether men were Christians, were accustomed to put to them this question; viz., ‘Dominicum Servasti?’ Hast thou kept the Lord’s day? If they had, they were Christians. This was the badge of their Christianity, in distinction from Jews and pagans. And if they said they had, and would not recant, they must be put to death.”—Dr. Edward’s Sabbath Manual, p. 120; Mr. Gurney, History, Authority, and Use of Sabbath, chap. 4, pp. 87, 88.

1. “Dr. Edward’s gives no authority.”

2. “Mr. Gurney refers to Dr. Andrews, bishop of Winchester.”

3. “Dr. Andrews (of the 17th century) refers to Acta Martyrum.”

4. “Not found in Acta Martyrum, nor anywhere else.”—Sir Wm. Domville, Examination Six Texts, pp. 258, 261.

5. Acta Martyrum not an authentic work. “Entitled to no sort of credit whatever.”—Mosheim, Historical Commentaries, cent. 1, sec. 32.

6. James Gilfillan repeats the falsehood, referring to Cardinal Baronius (A. D. 303) for authority.—Jas. Gilfillan, The Sabbath.

7. “Gilfillan has deliberately falsified the testimony of Baronius.”

a. “No such question in Baronius.”—J. N. Andrews’ Hist. Sabbath, pp. 252, 253.

X.—Ignatius of Antioch, about A. D. 100.

“Wherefore: if they who are brought up in these ancient laws came nevertheless to the newness of hope; no longer observing sabbaths, but keeping the Lord’s day, in which also our life is sprung up by him, and through his death whom yet some deny; . . . how shall they be able to live different from him; whose disciples the very prophets themselves being, did by the Spirit expect him as their Master.”—Magnesians 3:3–5; as some divide chap. 9.

1. “Ignatius’s words relate to the ancient prophets.”

2. DAY interpolated, should read, “living according to our Lord’s life.”

a. Kitto, Cyc. Bib. Lit., Art. Lord’s day.

b. Sir Wm. Domville, Examination Six Texts, pp. 250, 251.

c. Morer, Dialogues on Lord’s day, pp. 206, 207.

3. Epistles of Ignatius Spurious.

a. Dr. Killen, Ancient Church, pp. 413, 414.

b. Calvin, Ancient Church, p. 427.

c. Prof. C. F. Hudson, Future Life, p. 290.

d. Dr. Wm. Domville, Ex. Six Texts, p. 237.

e. Robinson, Eccl. Researches, chap. 6, pp. 50, 51, Ed. 1792.

4. There are fifteen epistles from Ignatius. Some authors think some of them genuine, others think all spurious. All think the epistle to the Magnesians spurious.

XI.—Pliny to Trajan, about A. D. 104.

Pliny, Roman governor of Bithynia, to the Emperor Trajan. He says of the Christians of his province:—

“They affirmed that the whole of their guilt orp. 245 error was, that they met on a certain stated day, before it was light, and addressed themselves in a form of prayer to Christ, as to some god, binding themselves by a solemn oath, not for the purposes of any wicked design, but never to commit any fraud, theft, or adultery; never to falsify their word, nor deny a trust when they should be called upon to deliver it up; after which it was their custom to separate, and then re-assemble to eat in common a harmless meal.”—Coleman, Ancient Christianity, pp. 35, 36.

1. Cannot tell which day is meant.

a. Coleman, Ancient Christianity, chap. 26, sec. 2.

b. Chas. Buck, Theological Dictionary, Art. Christians.

c. Tertullian, Apology, sec. 2.

d. W. B. Taylor, Obligation of Sabbath, p. 300.

e. B. Just. Hen. Boehmer, Mosheim, Historical Com., cent. 1, sec. 47.