A SKEPTIC’S QUERIES

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 17, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 16.

Read the full edition

A SKEPTIC’S QUERIES.

(Concluded.)
9. THE story that Jonah was swallowed by the whale is altogether improbable and without foundation.
REPLY.—If the event transpired, then the story respecting it is not without foundation. Whether the story is improbable depends upon the standpoint from which we look at the subject. If we undertake to explain that which claims to be miraculous from the standpoint of the natural, then of course the account will not only appear to be improbable, but the transaction also impossible. Infidels, for example, are in the habit of reasoning this way: The throat of a whale is so small that it will hardly admit the passage of an apple, much less that of a man. It is therefore impossible that a whale should have swallowed Jonah. It might be replied, first, that however small the throat of the whale, God, who made the whale, could certainly expand the throat of the same to any size required for the performance of the miracle. Such an answer would be legitimate when looking upon the affair as a supernatural event.
But as our infidel friends are wonderfully weak-kneed on the subject of God’s capability to do large things, it is proper that the proportion of the miracle should be reduced as far as it can consistently with the truth, in order to adapt it to the weak faith of our skeptical neighbors. To do this we call attention to the following facts: The word “whale” is not employed at all in the account in the book of Jonah. In that record the creature spoken of is called a “great fish.” In our Lord’s account, however, in Matt. 12: 40, the translators of the accepted version make him refer to it as a “whale.” Now what are the facts in regard to the original? The answer is, that the term translated “whale” in King James’ version, is from the Greek word κῆτος, which is equivalent to “sea monster;” in other words, it is an undeniable fact that in the gospels as originally written, we are not told that a whale swallowed Jonas, but simply that he was swallowed by some “sea monster.”
In the absence of any proof to the contrary, the presumption is that the creature in question was not a whale, since whales do not inhabit the Mediterranean Sea, where the transaction passing in review is said to have taken place. Is it inquired whether there is any sea monster in those waters which is so constituted that he could swallow a man? The answer is in the affirmative. The white shark, which is found in the Mediterranean Sea, has such a capacity that it has been known to swallow even a horse. (For the existence of the white shark, see Barnes’ Notes in loco.) This therefore is probably the fish which the Lord employed in the miracle of Jonah. We come to this conclusion, not because God could not have employed the whale for the purpose under consideration; but because, in discussing any transaction with which the Almighty is connected, it is wisest to explain it as far as possible upon natural grounds, allowing the miracle only where the natural will not account for the phenomenon.
In the case before us, the presence of a shark in the vicinity of the boat need not surprise any one who is acquainted with the habits of that fish. Furthermore, we can readily suppose that the shark, following its natural instinct, would have swallowed Jonah immediately upon his being thrown overboard. Right then and there the miracle commenced. The prophet, once in the bowels of the monster, must have perished speedily, but God intervened, and in a supernatural manner preserved his life. In so doing, he demonstrated the following propositions; viz., first, that there is a God superior to nature; secondly, that God, though infinite, watches over men by his providence, and, when it can be for his glory, will deliver them from the jaws of death itself; thirdly, that God is so merciful that he will permit those who have departed from the ways of his commandments to return unto him, and even become co-laborers with him for the salvation of others, provided they will repent and call upon him for pardon.
10. Christ never left any document to which his signature was attached, and never said to Matthew, Write this in your gospel, or to Mark, Write that in your gospel, but left the whole to uncertain man.
REPLY.—It is true that we have no document to which is attached the signature of Christ. Suppose we had, then what? would the infidel have accepted it as authentic? By no means. He would have said just what he does say now about the signatures of those sacred writers who have left autograph epistles; that is, that he wrote so long ago, that we could not tell whether his signature was genuine or counterfeit. As to the declaration that he never instructed his disciples to write, we reply, that it is not quite certain that this statement is correct. We know, for example, that on one occasion, he said to John the beloved, “What thou seest, write in a book, and send it to the seven churches which are in Asia.” Rev. 1: 11. Furthermore, we know that on another occasion he taught them that they should proclaim on the house-top what they had heard in the ear. This injunction in itself would be sufficient authority for them to write what they had heard. Concerning the statement that the whole matter “was left to uncertain man,” as such, it is enough to say that it is not correct. He told his disciples to tarry at Jerusalem, until they were endued with power from on high. He also taught them that when he had ascended up on high, he would send them the Holy Ghost, which “would teach them all things, and bring all things to their remembrance.” John 14: 26. Thus it appears that the very reverse of what is charged was true. In other words, that Christ, instead of leaving the matter of writing and teaching to the failing memories and imperfect judgment of men, has for the purpose of handing it down to us in the most trustworthy manner possible, caused men to write as they were inspired by the Holy Ghost sent down from Heaven.
In conclusion let me say, It is one thing to criticise, but another thing to improve. Again, it is one thing to tear down, but another thing to build up. Infidels have been carping at the word of God for thousands of years, but they have never furnished a system of morals or a plan of salvation, independently of the Scriptures, which has ever made any lasting impression upon the world at large, or one in which they could inspire enough confidence to induce men to substitute it, for any great length of time, for the religion of the Bible. Neither are they agreed among themselves. What one builds, another demolishes. What one pronounces sublime, another declares to be absurd. This they will probably continue to do until time shall end. In the meanwhile, the more modest and thoughtful will recognize in the word of God, through the silent operations of his Holy Spirit, the only plan of redemption which answers to the intuitions of our profounder natures, and exactly meets the necessities of a fallen race.
W. H. L.