AdventAI

SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 8., February 20, 1883

The answers to all the following questions have been kindly furnished by Bro. W. H. Littlejohn.

66.—SINGING AT THE LORD’S SUPPER.

When the Lord’s supper was instituted, did the disciples sing Psalms 115–117 inclusive, before going out therefrom? Matt. 26:30. A. M. D.

Ans. It is probable that the hymn or psalm sung at the time in question was made up from selections taken from Psalms 113–118 inclusive. That they did so is inferred from the fact that Jewish writers generally agree that it was customary to employ a hymn made up from those psalms on such occasions. See American Tract Society Bible Dictionary, Art. Passover.

67.—SONS OF GOD, AND DAUGHTERS OF MEN.

Who were the sons of God, and who the daughters of men, spoken of in Gen. 6:1, 2? Why the distinction? J. W. L.

Ans. Some have supposed that the children of God spoken of in the passage in question were the angels. This view, however, is absurd. A more reasonable one represents the descendants of Seth as being the children of God alluded to, and the descendants of Cain as being the children of men. The children of Seth were spoken of as being the children of God because they served him, having been “born from above,” John 3:3; Gal. 6:15. The children of Cain were styled the children of men in contradistinction from the children of God, because they were such in a bad sense; i. e., they were the children of men (fallen men) in the sense that they inherited depravity and practiced sin. In the Scriptures those who accept the doctrines and imitate the lives of certain ones, are called their children. Luke 16:8; John 8:43, 44.

68.—ROMANS 14:5, 6.

Will you please explain Romans 14:5, 6. S. J. M.

Ans. 1. These verses do not refer to the Sabbath day at all, else we are left without either a first-day or a seventh-day Sabbath, or, in fact, without any Sabbath whatever, since they teach that it is a matter of indifference whether the day under consideration is kept at all.

2. The reference, unquestionably, is to the Jewish ceremonial feast-days of the Mosaic law. In proof of this, it is only necessary to cite to the connection. In verses 1 to 4 inclusive, the apostle is talking about the eating of herbs, etc. He declares that he that eateth should not despise him that eateth not. In verse 4 he prohibits the judging of one another in these matters. In verse 5 he connects this eating and drinking with the observance of days; but the only law which in any way attempts to regulate eating and drinking, is the law of Moses. In speaking of its services, the apostle says, in Heb. 9:10, that they consisted in “meats and drinks, and divers washings and carnal ordinances, imposed on them until the time of reformation.” In that same law also was found a class of ceremonial Sabbaths which were abolished along with the meat and drink ceremonies at the cross. Col. 2:14–17. As was very natural, however, some of the Jewish Christians were inclined to hold on to these days and ceremonies, and, as a consequence, a dispute arose between them and those who discarded them altogether. To allay this dispute, the apostle, in the chapter in question, inculcates the lesson of forbearance, and declares it to be a matter of indifference whether a man keeps one of those ceremonial days or eats meat, provided only he is actuated by the fear of God, either in eating and observing the days in question, or in refraining from eating or observing the same.

69.—ACTS 3:19–21.

In Acts 3:19–21, the old version and the new translation differ considerably in their renderings. In the King James translation the word ὅπως is rendered “when.” In the new version it is translated “that so.” Which is the correct reading? *

Ans. Both of the translations are possible under certain circumstances; but we think that King James’ rendering in the passage in question is much to be preferred in this connection, because it gives a better sense to the passage, and agrees better with reason and Scripture declarations found elsewhere. We give the two renderings side by side:—

Common Version.—“Repent ye therefore; and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord; and he shall send Jesus Christ, which before was preached unto you; whom the heavens must receive until the times of restitution of all things, which God hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began.”

New Version.—“Repent ye, therefore, and turn again, that your sins may be blotted out, that so there may come seasons of refreshing from the presence of the Lord; and that he may send the Christ who hath been appointed for you, even Jesus; whom the Heaven must receive until the times of restoration of all things, whereof God spake by the mouth of his holy prophets which have been since the world began.”

Now, let it be observed that in the one translation the murderers of Christ are exhorted to repent and be converted, that their sins may be blotted out at a given time; i. e., at the coming of the Lord. In the other, they are exhorted to repent that their sins may be blotted out, “that so there may come seasons of refreshing from the presence of the Lord; and that he may send the Christ who hath been appointed for you, even Jesus: whom the Heaven must receive until the times of restoration of all things, whereof God spake by the mouth of his holy prophets which have been since the world began.” Now there is no incongruity in the proposition that if men will repent, their sins will be blotted out at the coming of Christ. The blotting out of sins could occur at that time as well as at any other time, and the promise that they should be blotted out then, would furnish sufficient motive for their repentance. On the other hand, according to the new version rendering, there are two things which are made contingent upon the repentance of the murderers of Christ, one of which, at least, is unreasonable in itself. The first is the blotting out of their sins at some time. The second is the blotting out of them in order that Christ may return to the earth. But it is submitted that this second proposition is absurd, first, because the repentance of the murderers of Christ would not have secured his return to the earth at any time, as it will take place whether they had repented or not. Secondly, because his return according to the passage itself did not depend upon their conversion, but could only take place in the remote future, when everything which God had spoken by the prophets should be fulfilled.

Having shown that the old rendering was not inconsistent with the possibilities of the case, in locating the blotting out of sins at the time of thep. 123 coming of Christ, it may be remarked that such a doctrine is the only one which can be admitted to be true. The record of sin is the evidence of its existence. That record also is the basis of judgment, and furnishes the measure of punishment. Therefore, when the record is gone, there can be neither judgment nor punishment. Now suppose that the murderers of Christ had repented agreeably to the invitation of Peter, and lived blameless lives for several years. Then suppose that some of them had backslidden, and after a brief space of time had died in their sins. This being so, what, we ask, would have been the result? The answer is obvious. If their sins were blotted out at the time of their conversion, then they will escape all punishment for the murder of Christ, since the record of their sins (i. e., the basis of judgment and punishment) had been blotted out. But such an idea is preposterous; it is also contrary to the positive declaration of Scripture. We read, for example, in Ezekiel that if the righteous man turneth away from his righteousness, etc., he shall die in his sins; all his righteousness which he has done shall not be mentioned. This would not be true, however, first, if he could not fall away, and secondly, if after having fallen away he could escape punishment for the sins committed previously to his fall; for it would then be true that his righteousness had been remembered, inasmuch as it had saved him from the punishment of his former sins.

Should it be replied to our theory that the blotting out of sins rendered their punishment impossible by the destruction of the record; that God could recall the sins by the operation of infinite recollection, it might be replied that such an hypothesis would destroy the whole force of the figure. The symbol of the blotting out is one which is adapted to our comprehension. God either keeps a record or he does not keep one. If he keeps a record, then that will be the basis of judgment, and will therefore be preserved until the judgment takes place. If, on the other hand, he does not keep a record, but depends on recollection, then if the blotting-out symbol means anything, the sins in question are as effectually effaced from his memory forever as is the writing from the page from which it has been blotted out. But this being true, they will never again be called to mind.

In confirmation of our theory that sins will not be blotted out until the close of time and the end of the judgment, we might call attention to the typical service in the tabernacle of Moses. In it the yearly round of service represented the whole period of man’s history down to the end of the final judgment. In the type, the people confessed their sins in the first apartment, for three hundred and sixty-four days in the year. On the three-hundred and sixty-fifth day, or the last day of the year, the atonement, or judgment, took place in figure. It was on that day that the high priest confessed the sins of the people over the scape-goat, which was sent away into the land of forgetfulness, and presented the blood of the goat, which typified Christ, before God, for the sins of the people. The manifest signification of this symbolic year and service was this: sins can be confessed all through the period of probation, but they will only be blotted out at its close, when Christ will offer his blood before the Father for that purpose.

In conclusion, let me say, I understand that when a man is converted he is accepted of God, and pardon is written conditionally opposite to his name in the book in Heaven. If he continues faithful to the end, then his sins will be blotted out at the time of the coming of the Lord. If, on the contrary, he shall backslide, then his former righteousness will not be remembered, and he will receive the full penalty of all the sins of his life.