Some men may be much better than the evil organizations of which they are members; but their connection with such organizations is to be deplored, and it should be candidly considered and abandoned. The following are believed to be correct, and not uncharitable, statements of facts concerning secret societies:—
1. They cannot bear the light, but curtain and guard their lodge-rooms, shade their councils with oaths and obligations of secrecy, and endeavor to avoid and suppress candid discussion of their merits. 2. They promote guilefulness, slyness, and cunning, and are opposed to openness, candor, and simplicity of character and conduct. 3. Their work is underhanded, and tends to promote unfairness and underhandedness. 4. Their general tendency is to promote their ends by indirect and insincere words and acts, and this inclines to disciplined deception and dishonesty. 5. They are conspiracies against society, proposing to promote the interests of their own members at the expense of those who are not members of those orders. 6. They not only promote clans and rings, but are themselves clans and rings of a very objectionable order.
7. Professing the reverse, they administer obligations and impose “duties” which practically conflict with the duties of their members to themselves, to their families, to the church, and to the State. 8. While the family, the church, and the State are ordained of God, and sanctioned by his word, these orders and their methods are not ordained of God, but are contrary to the precepts of the Bible. 9. They swear their candidates in advance to do, or not to do, things not yet made known to them, which is expressly forbidden in the Holy Scriptures. Lev. 5: 4–6.
10. Their initiatory ceremonies are degrading to the candidate initiated. 11. They resort to put-up terrors and devices to frighten or bewilder those they initiate, and to public show, for effect. 12. They invade the most sacred relations of the family, requiring of the husband obligations, and furnishing him with plans and conversations, which his oath forbids his making known to his wife, thus building up, even without the consent of the wife, a middle wall of partition between wedded souls. 13. They promote a sense of irresponsibility to public opinion, and to the church of Christ, by hiding under oath-bars a considerable part of the lives of their members. 14. The obligations they impose, and the precepts they inculcate, cause their members to resort to dodges, pretense, and even falsehood to conceal facts relating to these orders, which they are sworn to conceal. 15. Their obligations, ceremonies, and ritual have been published to the world and attested by many good witnesses,—and in the case of Freemasonry, by many good men of national reputation, and by thousands of seceding and adhering members of the lodge,—yet these orders pretend to sell their degrees as secrets, thus cheating the credulous and swindling the uninformed.
16. The titles used by secret orders are generally anti-Christian and anti-republican. 17. Their brotherhoods, confessedly composed largely of the unbelieving and profane, and even of vile men, are profane brotherhoods. 18. In these orders, men of fraud and craft flourish and govern, while merit and straightforwardness among their own members, are at a discount and sink into subjection.
19. These orders feign piety, yet—except in the papal degrees of Freemasonry; as, Knights Templar, etc.—their authorized forms of prayer purposely exclude the name of Jesus Christ, to satisfy and gratify Jews, deists, and other enemies of Christ and his holy religion, so that the authorized worship of these orders in general is either papal or deistic, and all other is illegal, and can be tolerated in the lodge in the absence only, or by the consent, of unbelievers of Christianity. 20. They are almost as ritualistic as paganism or papacy. 21. They unblushingly pretend to benevolence, though often they do not expend even one-third of the tax exacted of their members for initiation, dues, etc., in the relief of their sick and unfortunate, their widows and orphans; so that much of this paid-for benevolence is expended otherwise. 22. They claim to give donations to relieve the suffering; but some of the wholesale liquor firms of Chicago donated somewhat liberally for the relief of the storm-swept New Ulm sufferers in Minnesota, not limiting their relief to their own craft, as secret societies often do. Can the donations of the liquor-dealers sanctify the liquor traffic?
23. They pervert history and the Holy Scriptures in their lectures and legends. 24. They are full of imposture. 25. They pervert their own history, feigning to be either more ancient or more honorable than they really are, in their origin and progress. 26. Their really pious members are such as have been ensnared by lodge tricks, bound by impious oaths or obligations; and they only remain in the lodge from fear of its frowns and persecutions, or from inattention and obliviousness to its real character and operations, or from latitudinous judgment and conscience, just as some really pious men have, for some reason, continued in the communion of corrupt, sacrilegious Rome. 27. Their zealous, active members—if also members of evangelical churches—are generally observed to be lukewarm, backslidden, or entire strangers to piety, and are often reputed to be tricky.
28. Really, there seems to be a close relation between the joining of secret orders, by church members, and their backsliding. 29. Deep, thorough conversion often leads the most intelligent and conscientious to abandon, and even renounce, secret societies; and full consecration and deep piety, if attended with thoughtfulness and good judgment, are always averse to them. 30. Revivals, attended by intense spirituality, have been observed to follow the declension and abandonment of the lodge. 31. Secret orders are powerful engines for the destruction of souls.
32. Secret orders dupe and tax their “mud-sills” to bountify and luxuriate their magnates. 33. They waste vast sums of money. 34. They waste much precious time. 35. The state of the church does not suffer when secret orders decline, nor advance with their prosperity; but the very reverse is true. 36. These orders, though clans, often aspire to represent the church or the nation in laying the corner-stones of church buildings and of State and national edifices. 37. These orders often dispense office and place in a republic, and even in the church of God. 38. They influence the courts of justice. 39. They very generally muzzle the press, secular and religious.
40. Their literature is spread-eagle and bombastic, glorifying the darkness of the lodge, “calling evil good, and good evil,” putting “darkness for light and light for darkness,” and “bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!” Isa. 5: 40. 41. Their literature fails to meet, or even clearly contradict, the ample exposures of the orders made by reliable men and attested by numerous witnesses of truth and veracity. 42. Such failure to vindicate or deny explicitly, was, in the case of Freemasonry, seen even though forty-five thousand, out of fifty thousand, members of the lodge abandoned it, after the abduction and murder of William Morgan.
43. Secret orders impair confidence and beget distrust in society, these effects, of themselves, being great evils. 44. They do not generally succeed in entrapping men of conscious ability and worth, unless at an age when their merit and independence are as yet unrealized. 45. These orders are most proscriptive; for while men may expose error and trickery in State and national affairs, or errors and abuses in the church, or even attack the most sacred faith of the people without molestation, secretists, filled with rage, will vilify and abuse those who attack and expose secret orders, and often proceed to violence, thereby confessing that they cannot rely on truth and argument for the defense of their cause. 46. They resort to threats, persecutions, and even violence in many cases, to silence argument, stop exposure, or to punish those who have seceded from their ranks, however just the argument, correct the exposure, or conscientious the defection from their ranks may be.
47. Each secret order, by sanctioning the principle of secretism, gives countenance and aid to other secret societies, though of unknown, pernicious, or most dangerous principles. 48. The upper degrees of a secret order control the lower ones, and the major orders the minor ones—through cunning managers, who creep into them for that purpose;—and thus is built up a vast tyrannical empire of secretism, the chief despot of which is generally a wicked man, often an enemy of God and a scourge of men; for Freemasonry generally places at its head bold, bad men like Albert G. Pike, the butcher of Fort Pillow, or prodigal, self-indulgent men like the Prince of Wales. 49. The secret orders become, to many, a substitute for the church, and attendance on lodge meetings, even by ministers and church-members, is often preferred to the most spiritual and interesting services of the church; and the “duties” of the lodge are preferred to duty to Christ and the church. 50. The power of secret orders to make really good men do evil and abominable things, is one of the most shocking features of the lodge; hence, there is the greatest reason why the church should require its members to come out of fellowship with those deceitful, profane, underhanded, and deistic orders, that they be not partakers of their abominations.
Many of the propositions contained in the foregoing are either self-evident, or they are attested by the observation of the candid and intelligent reader. For the fullest justification of some of them, which may require more information than some possess, we refer the inquiring mind to John Quincy Adams’s Letters on Masonry (for which, address M. Wright, Richmond, Indiana); Light on Masonry (published at the United Brethren Publishing House, Dayton, Ohio); or the following books and pamphlets, to be had of Ezra A. Cook, Chicago, Illinois: Finney on Masonry; The Broken Seal; Revised Oddfellowship Illustrated; Temple of Honor Illustrated; Knights of Pythias Illustrated; United Sons of Industry Illustrated; Ritual of the Grand Army of the Republic; Ritual of the Machinists’ and Blacksmiths’ Union; Good Templarism Illustrated; Exposition of the Grange, and other works on secretism. We also refer such to the following standard books, published by the orders themselves: Mackey’s Lexicon of Freemasonry; Webb’s Monitor of Freemasonry; Oddfellows’ Pocket Manual, etc. We forbear making a list too much extended lest the reader should be lost in the multitude of references. One or two special references will show the reader how these various works can be used: Proposition 16th in the foregoing is shown most clearly by reference to The Broken Seal, pages 212, 213; proposition 19th, by Light on Masonry, pages 21, 143, etc.; Oddfellows’ Pocket Manual, pages 190, 191, 242, 243; Knights of Pythias Illustrated, pages 8, 14. While it may be true that some of the propositions are not applicable to every secret society, many of them are thus applicable, and most of them apply to most of the orders, and others to many of them.