AdventAI

A SKEPTIC’S QUERIES.

By W. H. L.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 12., March 20, 1883

Having been requested to answer some queries proposed by a skeptical friend, we cheerfully comply. We shall endeavor to treat the questions candidly; and though the thoughts we offer are necessarily brief, we trust they will be found sufficient to meet the difficulties in question.

1. “In the first place, man was cursed for eating of the fruit of the tree of knowledge, and afterward the people of God were admonished to get wisdom, or understanding. Who would now think of censuring any one for getting knowledge?”

Ans.—Our friend is in agreement with the Bible on one point; that is, he admits that it very wisely commands men “to get wisdom.” Thus much, therefore, is admitted in favor of the Scriptures. He next finds fault with the God of the Bible because he punished Adam and Eve for eating of the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil for the purpose of obtaining information, taking the position that no one at the present time would think of censuring an individual for obtaining knowledge.

Let us see whether this logic is sound. Suppose some builder should ruthlessly break into our objector’s house, against his positive command, for the purpose of ascertaining how it was constructed inside. Would that be a commendable act? Nay, is not such an act justly made punishable by law? The reply is in the affirmative.

Then we have learned that to obtain information without regard to the methods employed cannot be defended. Now apply this principle to the case in hand. Grant, if you please, for the sake of the argument, that the fruit of the tree of knowledge was of such a nature as to impart wisdom to those eating the same. Grant, also, that God communicated that fact to Adam and Eve, andp. 186 then forbade them to eat of the fruit of the tree. Now, provided that they disregarded the injunction of the Almighty, and ate of the fruit, would any one deny that such an act would have been worthy of punishment, while admitting, as above, that he who would ruthlessly break open a house-door for the purpose of obtaining information sought to be withheld from him, would justly be subjected to punishment? If so, that person would place a lower estimate upon God’s prerogative to command perfect obedience than he would upon that of an individual to keep his door closed against his neighbor. We think that every reflecting man will agree that it is more important to the universe that God should be obeyed than it is that men should obtain knowledge, however desirable in itself. This, and this alone, is the lesson which God sought to teach the race in its infancy in the use of the “tree of knowledge of good and evil.”

2. “I cannot see how so many living things could live in the ark without ventilation. We know of no method now by which eight persons could care for so many living creatures, even if the ark could have held them, which to me seems impossible.”

Ans.—Is it quite certain that the ark was not ventilated? We read in the 6th chapter of Genesis that the ark had a window and a door. We also read in chapter 8: 6, 13, that Noah opened the window and removed the covering of the ark. The covering of the ark may have been the same as the window, and it may have been different. The difference between the words “remove” and “open,” the first being applied to the cover and the second to the window, would seem to imply that they differed from each other. It is not impossible that the covering of the ark was so constructed as to be removed at pleasure. It is observable also that Noah was able to open the door when he wished to depart from the ark. Nor is it by any means improbable that there were other points in the ark which could have been opened at will. In a record so brief as that found in Genesis, ten thousand details were necessarily left out for want of space. Granting, therefore, that the olfactories of the Noachian family were as good as those of their descendants and that they were no more lazy than the average man of the present time, it is certain that they could have detected the necessity for, and provided a supply of, fresh air, which was evidently very abundant in the vicinity of the ark.

As to how eight persons could feed all the inmates of the ark, we are just as ignorant as is our friend. If we knew more about the internal arrangement of the ark, it is not impossible that this difficulty could be very easily solved. No one can now determine how the immense blocks of stone which are at present found in the pyramids of Egypt were elevated to their present positions; yet a single glance at the men while in the act of doing the work in question would have made the matter perfectly plain to our comprehension. Again, from the record itself it can be ascertained that angels played an important part in the matter of gathering the animals and directing the ark itself. It is not improbable, therefore, that they may have rendered the necessary aid to Noah and his family. That which is represented as being partly miraculous and partly natural should never be judged from the natural standpoint exclusively.

Respecting the capacity of the ark to hold representatives of the different genera of animals, it is enough to say that distinguished mathematicians, after separating those species which are the products of crosses which have taken place in later ages, have no difficulty in finding sufficient room in the ark for all the creatures which must necessarily have entered there, together with a sufficient supply of food for their use. See this matter discussed at large in Clarke’s Commentaries.

W. H. L.

(To be continued.)