AdventAI

WHEN DID CHRIST RISE FROM THE DEAD; ON SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 10., March 6, 1883

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Concluded.)

SYMBOLIC ARGUMENT.

It is now time to pass to the symbolic argument, as a sufficient number of texts have been advanced to make it clear that it was on the third day from the crucifixion that Christ was to rise, according to positive statement, and not after the expiration of the third day. In Lev. 23:9–11, the Jews were commanded to bring each year a sheaf of the first-fruits of their harvest to be waved before the Lord on the morrow after the passover sabbath. It will be generally conceded that this sheaf of the first-fruits was a type of Christ as the first-fruit from the dead. 1 Cor. 15:20. To those admitting this proposition, there is a significance in the time in which it was waved, which will be felt in the discussion of that subject. Each year the passover was slain on the fourteenth day of Abib; the fifteenth day of Abib was the passover sabbath; the next day, or the sixteenth of Abib, was the day on which the sheaf of first-fruits was waved before the Lord. Here, then, we have an order of events exactly harmonizing with the view advocated in this article. The passover lamb was a type of Christ, and was slain on the fourteenth day of Abib, as seen before, on which day also Christ was crucified. The fifteenth day of Abib was a sabbath, or day of rest. Christ, being crucified on Friday, rested in the tomb on Saturday, the fifteenth day of Abib.

On the morning of the first day of the week, the sixteenth day of Abib, the priests waved the passover sheaf of first-fruits before the Lord. On that morning also, Christ rose from the grave as the first-fruits from the dead. Here is not only a complete harmony between the type and the antitype, but here also is found the proof that there should be but one day intervening between Christ’s crucifixion and his resurrection, since but one day intervened between the slaying of the passover lamb, which typified the death of Christ, and the waving of the sheaf of first-fruits, which represented his resurrection from the dead. Thus it appears that the impressive symbolism of the Old Testament unites with the explicit declarations of the New, to prove that Christ was crucified on Friday and rose on Sunday.

THE JEWS WENT TO PILATE ON THE SABBATH.

To the foregoing conclusion it is sometimes objected that the Sabbath following the crucifixion could not have been the weekly Sabbath, as the Jews would not have gone to Pilate for a guard on that day. Such an objection proceeds upon the hypothesis that the piety of the Jews exceeded their hatred of Christ and his followers. The weak point, therefore, is in that hypothesis. The men who did not hesitate to imbrue their hands in the blood of the Son of God, to allow him to be smitten on the cheek, to insult him to his face, and to suborn witnesses to swear falsely against him, would not have scrupled to commit so slight an offense as that of asking a guard on the Sabbath day to be placed over the tomb of Christ. Nay, who cannot discover that by a ready ingenuity they would have found a defense for their action, in the necessity which called it forth. According to the record, they felt that had Christ really been stolen away, and the report circulated that he had risen from the dead, that would have been a calamity greater than any which he had brought upon them by his life and teachings. Matt. 27:62–64. Furthermore, one who is acquainted with the history of the Jews at that time, is well aware that when occasion offered, they could lay aside their reverence for the Sabbath with but little difficulty. Josephus states that at the time of the destruction of Jerusalem they so far conquered their scruples in this matter that when Cestius retreated from the city on the Sabbath they opened the gates, pursued his army, and gave him battle. Jewish Wars, b. ii., chap. xix. Such a fact, standing alone, would dispose of the objection under consideration most fully.

SYNOPSIS.

A brief résumé of the argument is in place at this time, inasmuch as it would serve to refresh the mind of the reader in reference to the points presented, which have been so numerous and so conclusive that further argumentation is altogether uncalled for. Such a résumé would run somewhat as follows:—

I. It is never safe to adopt an unsound view for the sake of a temporary advantage, as such a course would not only be dishonest, but would in time react upon those pursuing the same.

II. The words, “In the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week,” cannot mean that the event spoken of took place before the going down of the sun, 1. Because the mass of scholars have not so understood it, as proved by their practice in past ages, and by citations from Clarke, Barnes, the International Revision Commentary, the Lexicon of Greenfield’s Greek Testament, and the translations of Sawyer, Campbell, and the Emphatic Diaglott; 2. Because Mark, in speaking of the event, says that it took place when the Sabbath was past; 3. The Scriptures themselves throw various side lights on this subject, which prove that Christ was not resurrected on Saturday afternoon, among which are the following: (1.) The two Marys bought spices for the embalming of Christ after the Sabbath was past. Mark 16:1, 2. This they surely would not have done had they known that he had risen from the grave on the previous afternoon, as they had no money to throw away. (2.) They came to the sepulcher on the morning of the first day of the week, lugging along the spices which they had purchased the previous evening. But this again they would not have done had they known that Christ had risen previously, as no one is inclinedp. 148 to encumber himself with useless luggage. (3.) As they were on their way to the tomb on Sunday morning, they queried among themselves as to who should roll away the stone for them from the mouth of the sepulcher; but if they had seen an angel roll away the stone from the sepulcher Saturday afternoon, they would not have expected to find the stone at the mouth of the sepulcher on Sunday morning, and therefore would not have been solicitous as to who should roll it away for them. (4.) The priests and elders hired the guard to circulate the report that the disciples stole away the body of Christ in the night while they slept; but if Christ rose on Saturday afternoon, they ran great risk in circulating such a story, inasmuch as the earthquake, the descent of the angel, and the flight of the terrified guard, could not have taken place in broad daylight without attracting the attention of many, thus rendering the exposure of the priests and elders certain. (5.) The two disciples whom Christ accompanied to Emmaus were not informed of the resurrection of Christ until the morning of the first day of the week; but had he risen on Saturday afternoon it is to be presumed that they would not have been allowed to remain in ignorance of the fact until Sunday morning. (6.) The guard entered the city on Sunday morning to inform the priests of what had occurred at the same time that the women entered it to enlighten the apostles in regard to the same event. But if the resurrection took place on Saturday afternoon, it is impossible to explain why the guard should remain outside of the city and neglect to inform the priests and elders of what had taken place, since such a delay in and of itself would have been criminal. (7.) It is argued by our opponents that Matthew alone alludes to the visit which took place just before sunset on the afternoon of the Sabbath, and that the other three evangelists speak only of the visit made by the women on Sunday morning. But this theory, though necessary to enable them to make out a case, is absurd in itself, since it is incredible that Mark, Luke, and John should have contented themselves with referring to the comparatively unimportant visit on the morning of the first day of the week, while neglecting to give any account whatever of the one of such thrilling interest which took place on Saturday afternoon, at which time Christ actually rose from the dead, according to the opinion which we are controverting.

III. The testimony of the Fathers of the church is against the idea that Christ rose on the Sabbath. Without a single exception, so far as we know, they locate the resurrection on the first day of the week.

IV. It is generally conceded by our opponents that the Sabbath was changed from the seventh to the first day of the week by the papacy. Such a change was possible if it be admitted that the first day of the week was the day of Christ’s resurrection and as such was celebrated at a very early period in the history of the church as a festival, being subsequently exalted into the dignity of a Sabbath. Take the view, however, that it was not the resurrection day, and the change is placed almost beyond the range of possibilities, since it would have been necessary not only to change the Sabbath, but also to deceive the whole Christian world by making them believe that Christ rose on the first day of the week, whereas he actually rose on the seventh day of the week.

V. Concerning the objection that according to Matthew 12:40 Christ was to be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights, as Jonah was in the belly of the whale, it has been shown, 1. That the terms “day,” and “day and night,” are interchangeable, and cover alike a period of twenty-four hours when thus used; 2. That as they are alike, that which is true of one form of expression will be true of the other; 3. That according to Jewish usage, a transaction which covered parts of three days was spoken of as covering the three days in question, and therefore that inasmuch as Christ lay in the tomb on a part of Friday, the whole of Saturday, and a part of Sunday, it must have been proper to say that he was in the tomb three days, or that which is equivalent, that he was in the tomb three days and three nights; 4. In confirmation of the foregoing, several positive statements were introduced from the Scriptures establishing the proposition that Christ could not have remained in the tomb three full days, since it is emphatically stated several times that he was to rise “on the third day,” “in three days,” “the third day,” etc., etc.; 5. As additional testimony to prove that it was not necessary that Christ should remain in the grave three full days, the symbol of the wave-sheaf, which typified Christ, has been brought forward. From the provisions regulating the time at which it was to be offered, we found that the paschal lamb was to be offered on the fourteenth of Abib; that the fifteenth of Abib was to be a sabbath, and that on the day following, the sheaf was to be waved before the Lord, thus demonstrating that Christ, our passover, was to be crucified on, say the fourteenth of Abib, rest in the grave on the fifteenth of Abib, and rise therefrom on the sixteenth of Abib. In other words, that as but one day was to intervene between the slaying of the paschal lamb and the waving of the sheaf of the first-fruits, so there was to be but one day between the crucifixion of Christ and his presentation as the first-fruits from the dead.

VI. To the objection that the Jews would not have gone to Pilate for a guard on the Sabbath day, it has been replied that the murderers of Christ and his followers hated him and them so thoroughly that they would not have hesitated to commit so slight an offense as the breaking of the Sabbath if they could advance the interests of their own cause thereby. By way of fortifying that position, reference was made to the fact that when Cestius retreated on the Sabbath day from Jerusalem, they pursued him to give him battle in A. D. 63, or thereabouts.

With the conclusion of the foregoing résumé of the arguments offered in this article, it is necessary to bring the article itself to a close. As we do so, we are more impressed than ever before with the utter unsoundness of the view which has been under examination. It would seem as if nothing were lacking to prove its unreliability, since Bible, scholarship, history, tradition, and inference are all against the same. It is not a little singular that it should ever have found favor with as many minds as it has. There can be no doubt that some have conscientiously believed that it was true; others again, unquestionably, have accepted and pushed it from unworthy motives. Among the latter we would mention those who have resorted to it for the purpose of proving that the visions of Mrs. E. G. White are not from the Lord. The syllogism which they have employed runs as follows: The Bible teaches that Christ rose on the Sabbath or seventh day of the week; the Testimonies of Mrs. E. G. White teach that he rose on the first day of the week; therefore her Testimonies are false. The capital which they have made out of this line of argument has not been inconsiderable. If any who have thus employed the same should happen to read the present dissertation, it is proper to say to them that this is not the first nor the second time that elaborately constructed theories against those Testimonies have been proved, in process of time, to be utterly illogical and incorrect. That which is to be regretted is the circumstance that those who elaborate those theories, in the act of so doing frequently become so prejudiced that no amount of proof can cause them to change their views; while those who have been unwillingly deceived, in many cases never are fortunate enough to see the refutation of the opinions which unfortunately they have endorsed. The responsibility for such results we leave with those upon whom it ought to rest.

To such as have cherished the view that Christ rose on the seventh day because it seems to strengthen the claims of the seventh-day Sabbath, it is enough to say that those claims need not be fortified in this manner. The reasons which may be offered in behalf of the binding obligation of the ancient Sabbath of the Lord are both sound and abundant. It rests its claims upon the only Sabbath law which is found in the Bible, i. e., the fourth commandment. That law was written by the finger of God upon the tables of stone, and is both explicit in its statements and enduring in its character. So long as the earth stands, whether in its present or in its renewed form, it is fitting that the creative act of God which brought it into existence should be commemorated, and there is one, and but one, institution which has ever been appointed for that purpose, i. e., the seventh-day Sabbath. If any desire to celebrate also the resurrection of our Lord, they have a divinely constituted ordinance for that purpose in baptism by immersion. As the believer goes down into the water, is buried in the liquid grave, and is lifted therefrom by the administrator, he thereby gives an impressive expression of his faith in the death and resurrection of our Lord. Let him not attempt therefore to rob another great event, i. e., the rest of God, after the work of creation was finished, of its most significant memorial in the rest of the weekly Sabbath.

None need fear that God will ever become so indifferent to the question of exact obedience to his word as to allow one of his explicit statutes to fall permanently into contempt. There may be brief periods, nay even centuries, in which it may appear as if such a thing were taking place. The reaction, however, will occur at last. In the case of the Sabbath, it is already transpiring. Intelligent and conscientious men and women in all parts of the world are having their consciences quickened to the importance of exact obedience to God in the matter of the Sabbath, as well as in that of everything else. In a short time the world will be mightily stirred upon this subject.

If the prophecies are rightly understood by those who connect them with the most marked phase of the Sabbath movement which is taking place in our day, we are about entering upon the loud cry of the third angel’s message of Rev. 14:9–12, during which the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus are to be preached in a brief space of time and with unparalleled power in all the nations of the earth. Let all be assured, therefore, that it is not necessary to bring to the rescue of the down-trodden Sabbath any such doubtful support as could be given to it by the employment of false logic. As stated in the commencement of this article, such argumentation always reacts with tenfold power upon its originator. In the case before us, we have a striking illustration of this fact. By taking the position that Christ rose on the Sabbath, and seeking to employ such a consideration for the purpose of inducing first-day observers to hallow its hours, they seem to countenance the idea that the fact of his resurrection on a given day would establish the proposition that such an event would render holy the day on which it took place. Failing to prove their point, therefore, since their efforts simply serve to render it more certain than ever before that Christ actually rose on the first day of the week, their attempt serves to confirm Sunday-keepers in their unscriptural practice, as they have partially conceded that the day of Christ’s resurrection should be looked upon as holy time. Should it be replied that they had never intended to make such a concession, but were only trying to convince first-day observers of seventh-day sanctity, when regarded from the standpoint of the latter, we reply, that such a course of reasoning is not the most satisfactory, as it seeks to bring men to an acknowledgment of the truth through conclusions which are based upon deductions drawn from their own errors; i. e., it is an attempt to lead them to keep Saturday as the Sabbath because of the fact that it was the day of Christ’s resurrection, and because they believed that such resurrection hallowed the day on which it took place. Could such men ever intelligently observe the Sabbath of the Lord while holding such views? The reply is manifestly in the negative. God never told any man to observe any day because Christ rose thereupon; if they do so, therefore, they do it uponp. 149 their own notion and without divine sanction. What God has commanded men is, that they shall celebrate the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath, because that is the day on which he rested after the creation of the world.

This, therefore, is the truth which must be impressed upon the minds of all before they can become acceptable Sabbath-keepers. Sooner or later, this whole doctrine about the relation of the resurrection of Christ to the sanctity of any day must be wholly rooted out of their minds. Why not, therefore, start in right at the very outset? Why spend any time on false issues? Why not strike at the root of the evil at once? Is it not clear that such a policy would be wise? Nay, more; would it not be more sweeping in its results? Suppose we should reason in this way, for example, when approaching our first-day friends: Were it to be granted that Christ rose on Sunday, such a fact in the absence of any positive command for the hallowing of Sunday would by no means convert it into a Sabbath day; nor does the fact that Christ met with his disciples on two first days in any way affect the question at issue, 1. Because God would not leave so important a matter as that which relates to the day which man should observe as a Sabbath, dependent upon doubtful inferences while it was so easy for him to settle the whole question by an explicit command; 2. Because, were we to keep Sunday on account of Christ’s resurrection thereupon (the fourth commandment never having been repealed), we should still be obliged to observe Saturday in commemoration of God’s rest thereupon, and thus we should have two Sabbaths in each week; 3. The meeting of Christ with the apostles on the first day of the week furnishes no good ground for supposing that he meant thereby to teach that it was holy time, else we have not only Sabbath and Sunday as holy days, but also an unknown fishing day when he met them at the lake of Tiberias (John chapter 21), and Thursday when he met them at the time of his ascension. Acts 1. Furthermore; if example proves anything in this matter, it is against the idea of first-day sanctity, since the day on which Christ rose was one of great confusion and labor with the twelve, and one which Christ, in walking with the two who went to Emmaus, recognized as secular in its character. Luke 24:1–35. Not only so, but Paul, twenty-eight years later, in traveling on Sunday morning from Troas to Assos, a distance of nineteen and one-half miles, furnishes the most incontestable proof that it was regarded by him, and therefore by all who like him were led by the Holy Spirit, as a day of common travel. Acts 20:7–14.

Such reasoning is clear, straightforward, unanswerable. He who resorts to it draws sound conclusions from sound premises; while he who relies upon the other line of argument reaches his conclusions through a premise, which is not well taken; i. e., that Saturday was the day of the resurrection. Not only so; should he succeed in bringing his hearers to the point of hallowing the Lord’s Sabbath, or Saturday, they will be compelled to abandon every reason which had led them to the consecration of that day, and to adopt those suggested above before their Sabbath-keeping will be acceptable to the Most High, since men cannot observe the Sabbath until they understand the true reason upon which it rests.

Allegan, Mich., Feb. 6, 1888.