A SKEPTIC'S QUERIES

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 10, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 15.

Read the full edition

A SKEPTIC'S QUERIES.

(Continued.)
8. Read the 109th psalm, and imagine a Christian of our day making such a prayer.
REPLY.—Any system of morals or religion which has in it no provision for retributive justice, would prove a failure in a world like ours. Rewards and punishments are both necessary to the restraint of crime. The State recognizes this fact, providing a penal code to insure the punishment of offenders against its laws. But a few months ago, the whole nation was crying out for the execution of Guiteau. He was a murderer; and the common sense of justice, and the protection of human life in future, demanded that he should die; and he was, therefore, hung, according to law. In his case, however, as in every other where the sinner is brought face to face with his doom, there were sympathizers who felt that it was cruel, after all, to kill the man. Did the hangman, therefore, hesitate to do his work? No; he did it at the appointed hour, and the nation breathed more freely. They felt that there was less danger; that, in the future, desperate office-seekers would at least deliberate a little while before shooting the chief magistrate in order to get him out of the way of their promotion.
Thus much for the general principle. Now for its application to the 109th psalm. It is claimed that in it there are imprecations against the enemies of David too terrible to be reconciled with the principles of Christianity. Well, let us see. The first thing to be considered is the application of the psalm. To whom does David refer? By reading the psalm itself, we shall find that it refers to those whose sins were terrible, and whose ingratitude was unparalleled. Scholars generally have understood that David speaks in the person of the Lord Jesus Christ in this psalm, and that its denunciations are uttered against Judas and the crucifiers of the Lord. That they are right, is rendered quite probable by the circumstance that Peter applies the words, “his bishoprick let another take,” directly to Judas. Acts 1 : 20.
Now we inquire respecting the amount of punishment of which Judas was deserving, according to Christianity, which our objector makes a stand and of retribution. Christ says that it were better for Judas if he had never been born. That is, the punishment of Judas will be so terrible that he will wish that he had never seen the light. In view of this, will any one say that the denunciations in the 109th psalm are too severe, or that they indicate a measure of punishment greater than Judas ought to bear? Before doing so, let him recall the circumstances of the case, and the divine character of the victim, in whose blood he deliberately imbrued his hands. In the dark outline of his horrible crime, there cannot be seen one ray of palliating light. Nearly the same may be said of the crucifiers of the Lord.
Had the psalmist, in the judgments denounced, consigned Judas and his coadjutors to everlasting torment in a hell of fire and brimstone, there might be some show of reason for objecting to the severity of his punishment. Singularly enough, however, there is not in this psalm a single punishment evoked upon him which is not limited in its character, and which might not be suffered in this life. Should the objector, with a ready ingenuity, answer that it was not Judas with whom he sympathized so much as his mother, his wife, and his children, the first of whom was not to have her sins blotted out, the second to be a widow, and the last to be orphans and want for bread (verses 9, 10), we reply, first, that it is not impossible that what the psalmist meant, was this: Let the punishment of Judas be such as a man would feel when he realized that, as a consequence of his own act, his mother would be lost, his wife become a widow, and his children become orphans and beg for bread; secondly, should it be insisted that the calamities referred to are actually denounced upon the mother, the widow, and the children of Judas, it is by no means certain that such an imprecation was undeserved by the parties in question. Who does not know that, in many instances, mothers are largely responsible for the sins of their children? It may be that such was the case with the mother of Judas. Again, did we know all the circumstances in the case, it is not unlikely that we should ascertain positively that the wife and the children of Judas made themselves parties to his crime by sympathizing with him in his wrong course of life, and even by encouraging him to do the deed which he accomplished.
The record shows that Judas from the outset was a thief. From the alms-bag he had been in the habit of pilfering the sacred funds which had been donated to the starving poor. If, therefore, his wife and his children were accomplices with him in these thefts, it was no more than just that they who had taken the bread from the mouth of the starving, should in turn suffer hunger themselves.
Once more: Who can appreciate the agony of the virgin mother while her son was writhing in the throes of death upon the cross? The aged Simeon, in describing the agony of that hour, compares it to that which would follow were the soul of Mary to be pierced through with a sword. Luke 2 : 34, 35. Now if, as may be fairly inferred by the relation of the parties to Judas, and the denunciations of the psalmist, the wife and children of Judas were responsible in a large measure for the crucifixion of Christ, then they had been instrumental in robbing the virgin mother of her darling child, and in bringing upon her all the anguish of the crucifixion hour. It was, therefore, a judgment by no means too severe which made one feel what it was to lose a husband, and the others what it was to lose a father.
Here we leave the subject, with the remark that if Judas and his family, being guilty as argued above, should escape with a punishment as light as that denounced by the psalmist, it would indeed be a tender-footed justice which would lift its hands in holy horror at the severity of their fate.
W. H. L.
(Concluded next week.)