STRAUSS' MYTHICAL THEORY

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 27, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 13.

Read the full edition

STRAUSS' MYTHICAL THEORY.

Young men here, or those no older than your present lecturer, remember when the mythical theory of Strauss was passing through its haughty, domineering period, and was supposed to be something with which it was a little dangerous to meddle. I can remember that, when I entered Yale College, I was seriously advised to read and not to read Strauss' book on the life of our Lord. I took it down and turned it over, obtained possession of the theory, and for many years it lay in my mind without an adequate answer to it. No adequate answer had been given in 1858. Up to that time we were unable to show the masses of the people just how this theory should be confuted, although scholars knew, of course, that it was not tenable. I was not a scholar. I was in a period of unrest. I was passing through that transitional era in which young men can raise more questions than they can answer. Scholars were annoyed by this theory, because it was not easy to state to the people clearly what the answer to it is. A reply presumes considerable knowledge of early recondite matters in Christian history, and I am now venturing much in trying to condense into a few minutes what has been wrought out by the debates of a generation.
Here is, as I suppose, a correct statement in outline of this whole mighty matter. It was supposed, a generation or two since, that the earliest date to which we can trace back the New Testament literature was 180 or thereabouts. The date commonly assigned to the crucifixion and resurrection is 34. Here, then, was a gap between the upper and the lower blade of a pair of chronological shears; and in this opening between 34 and 180 there was time for myths and legends to grow up. It was Strauss' theory, that, between 34 and 180 and 200, exaggerated accounts of what the Founder of Christianity did were woven about his idolized memory by his disciples, and that these exaggerations were mistaken for history. Elaborate illustrations were drawn from the growth of myths and legends in connection with heathen religions. A whole science of myths was originated, and you have it taught occasionally by sufficiently advanced retrograde thinkers in this country and in England to this hour. I presume a rumbling carelessness of liberal thought can be found even in the city of Boston that will, to-day, stand on this system of myths and legends, and haughtily reject the New Testament literature as not containing contemporaneous evidence of the reality of the Christian miracles. But for reasons, some of which I have indicated, we have now shut these shears until the lower blade stands at 60, the upper at 34.
Now we know that Paul wrote his Epistles, at least the four I have named, before Festus succeeded Felix in the government of Judea. When did Festus succeed Felix? In 60. Paul was in prison in Cæsarea two years before Festus succeeded Felix, and he wrote these epistles before he was imprisoned; so we carry the date of the youngest of these epistles up to 58. And for reasons which I will not enter upon in detail, the date of Galatians is now put at 54. Very well; 34, 54—twenty years only between these blades! There is not time in twenty years for myths and legends to grow up and be mistaken for history. Is it asserted that human memory is good for nothing if it stretch over a score of years? What is your memory worth as to things happening twenty years ago? What was happening then? 1882, 1872, 1862—we were in the midst of the civil war. Your testimony before any jury as to matters of any size would be worth something to-day even as to events a score of years gone by. But I open this first chapter of Galatians and read that Paul went down into Arabia and spent three years. Fourteen years after he went up to Jerusalem. Now if, as most commentators do, you add the three to the fourteen, you obtain seventeen years to take away from the twenty between 54 and 34. You shut those blades of the chronological shears until only three years remain between them. St. Paul's testimony as to the origin of Christianity is indisputably contemporaneous evidence, and the sneer of the infidels is overwhelmed. There is not enough left of Strauss' mythical theory between these two blades to make a fig-leaf large enough to cover the shame of historic skepticism. [Loud laughter and applause.] —Joseph Cook, in 152d Boston Lecture.