ANSWERS BY W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
102.—THE THIEVES ON THE CROSS.
1. What were the names of the two thieves crucified with Jesus?
2. Was Barabbas released to go free or to be crucified? M. E. L.
ANS. 1. Tradition has it that the one on his right hand was named Zoathan, and the one on his left hand Chammatha. If you are a good Catholic, you will probably accept the tradition, and believe that such were the precise names of the thieves. If a Protestant, you will probably shake your head, and say, Well, why did not he give me some better authority on this subject than tradition?
2. To go free.
103.—CHURCH TROUBLES VS. THE ORDINANCES.
Can the ordinances be administered to a church not living in harmony with one another? S. W. B.
ANS. That depends upon the extent of the troubles. If they involve quite a percentage of the church membership, it might not be best to undertake to administer the ordinances. If, on the other hand, the difficulties are confined to two or three, it would not seem right to deprive the majority of the church of the benefit of the ordinances on their account; otherwise large churches might never be able to administer them at all.
It is not a bad plan, when difficulties cannot be settled, to request those involved in them to refrain from participating in the ordinances until such time as their affairs shall be adjusted.
104.—THE FEAST OF UNLEAVENED BREAD.
1. Did the feast of unleavened bread begin with the fourteenth day or at its close?
2. How could Christ have eaten the Passover on the first day of the feast, and yet have been crucified the day before the Passover? B. F. L.
ANS. 1. Strictly speaking, with the commencement of the fifteenth day of Abib; but in Christ’s time it was customary to speak of the fourteenth of Abib as one of the days of the feast of unleavened bread. This usage sprang from the fact that the Jews commenced on the fourteenth to remove the leaven out of their houses.
2. The second question is explained by the answer to the first. Christ was crucified on the first day of the feast only in an accommodated sense; i. e., the day of his crucifixion was calledp. 282 the first day of the feast at times according to usage, though in reality it was not such. See Clarke’s Notes on Matt. 26: 17.
105.—FAMINE OF THE WORD. AMOS 8: 11.
“Reader of REVIEW”: The “famine of hearing the word of the Lord” spoken of in Amos 8: 11, doubtless has reference to a condition of things in which the people will be deprived of all spiritual food. It is supposed that the time for the fulfillment of this prediction is in the near future, and immediately following the close of probation. Then the Spirit of the Lord will be withdrawn from the earth, and men will experience a desire to communicate with God, but will find it impossible to do so, as their fate will have been hopelessly sealed.
It is not impossible that the prediction also had a partial fulfillment in the experience of the Jews during the captivity. The destruction of Jerusalem, and the carrying of the Israelites to Babylon, seem to have been in some sense typical of the last days. It not infrequently occurs that prophecies have a double fulfillment. This one may be of that kind.
106.—SUNDAY OBSERVANCE IN “LIFE AND EPISTLES OF ST. PAUL.”
We give the “Life and Epistles of St. Paul” as a premium with the Signs, and are met with quotations from its pages in favor of infant baptism and Sunday observance. Is such a course of action expedient? F. W. H.
ANS. The book in question would of course be more valuable if it were entirely free from errors; but inasmuch as it contains a very large amount of valuable matter independently of its errors, we read it ourselves and give it to others to read. Should we decide to circulate or read no books which are not entirely free from error, our libraries would necessarily be very small and our usefulness very limited. There is not even a school book which we put into the hands of our children but is unsound in some of its teachings. Indeed, it would not be safe to conclude that all error has been winnowed out of even our denominational works. We must do the best that we can, therefore, under the circumstances. If we can get a man to take the Signs or REVIEW, with the “Life and Epistles of St. Paul,” by Conybeare and Howson, as a premium, we mix the antidote so thoroughly with the poison that there is not only no harm done, but great good is actually accomplished. These papers are so full of ringing testimonies in favor of the Sabbath and against the Sunday—brought from the Bible, and even some of them from the “Life and Epistles of St. Paul” itself—that if read for one year, they will wholly obliterate all the unsound doctrines which one may draw from other sources upon that subject. The same is true of baptism.
So far as our brethren in the faith are concerned, if years of careful study of the Bible evidences for our faith have not sufficiently indoctrinated them so that they can be trusted to read the unsupported opinions of others in opposition to our views, then the task of making them sound and intelligent S. D. Adventists is a hopeless one, and we might as well let them go by the board first as last.
107.—THE SAVIOUR’S AGE.
In Luke 3:23 we learn that our Saviour was about thirty years old when he was baptized. He preached three years and a half, and yet we say that he was crucified in A. D. 31. How do you reconcile these facts? J. B.
ANS. Our “A. D.” was fixed by Dionysius Exiguus, and not by inspiration. He reasoned that Christ was born in a certain year, and so called that year A. D. 1. In this he made a mistake of about four years; that is, he did not locate his “A. D.” early enough by about that length of time. That, of course, would put it out of joint with the events of the gospel history. We read, consequently, in Luke 2:42, that when Christ went up to the temple with his parents, and disputed with the doctors of the law, he was “about twelve years old;” but in the margin of some of our Bibles we have this event set down as having taken place in A. D. 8; i. e., it would make out that Christ was only eight, whereas, in reality, he was twelve years old at the time in question.
The same is true of the baptism. According to Usher’s chronology—i. e., the one found in our Bible—Christ would only have been twenty-seven years old when he was baptized; whereas, Luke says that he was thirty years old when that event took place. In other words, as Christ was baptized in the fifteenth year of Tiberius Cæsar, or A. D. 27, he must, according to Mr. Usher, have been only twenty-seven years old at the time of his baptism, while Luke says that he was thirty years old at that time. In other words, Luke proves again that Usher’s “A. D.” is too late by about four years. This discrepancy is of no account except in calculating the age of Christ, as our present “A. D.” is a fixed date, from which Scripture dates are calculated backward or forward with just as much accuracy as though that date synchronized with the birth of Christ. He was actually baptized in A. D. 27 according to our reckoning. As he preached for three years and a half between his baptism and his death, it follows that he was crucified in A. D. 31 of our era, or in the same year in which we locate the death of Christ in all of our computations.
For a fuller discussion of the subject, see “Thoughts on Daniel,” page 269, note.
108.—PUNISHMENTS AND REWARDS.
1. Does not Matt. 13:30 teach that the wicked are punished before the righteous are rewarded?
2. What real proof have we that Gen. 3:15 refers to Christ? T. H. G.
1. Not necessarily. The parable is designed to explain the reason why the wicked are allowed to exist along with the righteous in this world. The Saviour shows that from the necessity of the case they are spared, as otherwise the righteous could not be developed. The thought is this: Good men are descended from bad men; destroy the bad men of this generation, and you would prevent the appearance of some of the good in the next generation, as you would cut off the sources whence they are to spring. The wicked, therefore, must live until all the righteous are complete in number. This done, the wicked will be gathered out and burned, and the righteous alone left in the kingdom. The parable is one which covers centuries in its scope. At the time of the harvest, the command will go forth for the separating and burning of the wicked. These processes will cover in their complete fulfillment the thousand years mentioned in Rev. 20: 4-9; that is, the fires which purify the earth and render it a fit abode for the saints eternally, will consume the last trace and vestige of the wicked therefrom. 2 Peter 3: 9-13.
2. It must, from the very nature of the case. It is manifest that the real character upon which the judgment is denounced is Satan, who worked through the serpent. Rev. 20: 1-3. To bruise his head, must mean to destroy his life. But no merely human being can destroy the life of Satan. That Christ alone has power to do, and that he will do. Rom. 16: 20. Again: Satan does something more than to merely bruise the heel, or inflict a temporary injury upon the ordinary descendants of Eve, as, through the injury done by him, the unrepenting wicked are to die eternally. Rom. 6: 23. To Christ, on the other hand, the figure applies exactly. Satan brought about his death temporarily, but he could not hold him in the grave. Again: It was to be the seed of the woman in contra-distinction from that of man. But all the descendants of Eve, save Christ, are as much the seed of the man as of the woman. Isa. 7: 14.
109.—2 COR. 5: 8.
What is the exposition which you give of 2 Cor. 5: 8? J. V. M.
ANS. To be “absent from the body” is to be either in the state of death, or to be clothed with the immortal resurrection body. This condition is spoken of in verse 1 as the dissolution of the earthly house, and in verse 4 as the state of being “unclothed.”
To be “present with the Lord” is to be in the immediate presence of Christ. It appears, therefore, that what the apostle wanted was to be with Christ. In verse 2 he says: “For in this we groan, earnestly desiring to be clothed upon with our house which is from Heaven.” The only question which presents any difficulty in the passage is the one which relates to the time when the apostle expected to be present with the Lord. Was it immediately at death, or at the resurrection? We reply, At the resurrection. Were his presence with the Lord a necessary and immediate consequence of death, then he would have hailed the latter as something greatly to be desired; but in verse 4 he says distinctly that he does not desire to be unclothed; that is, it was not the state of death which he was anxious to enter, but Heaven itself, where Christ was. Three things are brought to view in the passage; first, the present existence, or life in the present body with all the infirmities which environ the same; secondly, death, or the unclothed state; thirdly, eternal life, or the condition in which we shall be when clothed upon with the house which is from Heaven. He was not satisfied with the present existence or body, because of its temptations and labors; he did not desire the grave, because in it there is no device nor knowledge nor wisdom. Eccl. 9: 10. He wished to be with the Lord, because there will be fullness of joy and pleasure forevermore. Ps. 16: 11.
In other words, Paul, when writing the passage in question, felt just as every man feels in whom there is an instinctive dread of death, and an earnest longing for eternal life with all of its glories. The grand objective point which was before his mind, was the coming of the Lord, and the putting off of this corruptible body, and the putting on of the glorious immortal one. 1 Cor. 15: 53, 54. That such is the case will become apparent when we stop and reflect that he speaks of two bodies under the figure of a house, verse 1. One of them is the earthly house, the other the house from Heaven. The former is to be put off; the latter is to be put on. Now if the latter house is, as claimed by some, the habitation which the soul is to enter at death, then at the coming of the Lord, when the present bodies are to have a resurrection, the question arises, What will become of the house from Heaven? It cannot be destroyed, for it is immortal. The resurrected house cannot be destroyed, for it is likewise immortal. Here, then, we are presented with the anomaly of souls dwelling in two tenements at one and the same time. Rather a superfluity of bodies, we think. But take the view spoken of above, and all is rational and clear. The earthly house is our present decaying body. The house from Heaven will be the resurrected, or glorified, body. It is said to be from Heaven, because God its author dwells in Heaven, and so effectually eliminates from it everything which is corruptible, that it can be admitted with propriety into Heaven.
For a more complete exegesis of the passage, see “Man’s Nature and Destiny,” published at this Office. Price, in paper covers, 40 cents; in cloth covers, $1.00.