AdventAI

Is It Sunday or Thursday?

By N. J. Bowers

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 18., May 1, 1883

BY N. J. BOWERS.

There are plenty of people who tell us that the first day of the week is entitled to special honors by reason of the Troas meeting recorded in Acts 20:7–12. An examination of the account, however, fails to discover that sanction and authority that the many so readily find.

1. The brethren did not assemble, as far as we are informed, to hear Paul preach, but “to break bread.”

2. It is not beyond reasonable question that this breaking of bread on this occasion was a religious act.

3. There is nothing to show from the record that this meeting and breaking of bread on this day was an accepted custom among the churches.

4. Paul, the preacher, did not enjoin upon the brethren, nor did he advise them to make the day the one for standing religious services.

5. Luke, the historian, does not inform us that it was the “stated day” for “prayer, praise, and devotion” of the Troas church.

6. We have no account that this church, nor any other Christian church during the time covered by the Acts and much later, ever regarded the day with any special honor.

7. This meeting was a special and not an ordinary one.

8. The restoring of the young man to life as one of the acts of Paul, gained for the circumstance a record in the early apostolic history.

9. There is nothing that can be drawn from this narrative in favor of the first day of the week as the day of Christian assembly and worship, save the fact that the brethren did meet together on it once and heard preaching.

10. If this circumstance gives to the day divine honor and authority, then all days may rightly claim them. Acts 5:42.

11. Especially does Thursday, upon this principle, lay upon us a just claim to religious regard. Acts 1.

a. The brethren were “assembled” and “were come together” on this day. Ver. 4, 6.

b. Jesus was with them and imparted religious instruction. Ver. 6–8.

c. They were instructed by angels from Heaven in regard to the second advent. Ver. 10, 11.

d. They with Jesus went no farther than a Sabbath-day’s journey. Ver. 12.

e. Returning from the Mount Olivet, they assembled themselves with others, making a company of at least sixteen; and had a meeting for “prayer and supplication.” Ver. 13, 14.

f. Is not Thursday, then, especially held out to us, challenging our regard from these several items; viz, 1. That the brethren assembled and Jesus preached the gospel of the kingdom to them; 2. That holy angels preached the advent to them; 3. That a Sabbath-day’s journey was as far as they went on that day; 4. That when they returned, they had a prayer-meeting among themselves; and 5. That the last meeting Jesus had on earth with his disciples was on this day. Was not this Thursday sabbath a fitting day on which to close his work on earth?

g. Not one of these facts relates to the first day of the week.

Which day then shall we devote to the Lord, Sunday or Thursday?