BY A. SMITH.
The following article, replete with interesting subjects of thought to the student of prophecy, is clipped from a recent issue of the Chicago Journal:—
THE REVISION OF CREEDS.
It is not surprising that after the revision of the New Testament, and the generally cordial acceptance and approval of the work, a discussion in regard to the propriety of a revision of religious creeds should spring up in religious circles. All creeds pretend to formulate doctrines derived from the inspired word of God; and when it is admitted that the word needs restating, it would seem logically to follow that the uninspired formulas of the church founded on the Scriptures might properly need recasting also.
The church, in its organized form, generally condemns that man as a heretic who even hints that its creed does not contain the sum total of all religious wisdom and knowledge, and assumes that it is too perfect to need revision. But the North American Review for January prints three able and exhaustive articles from eminent orthodox clergymen on the revision of creeds, which looks as if the work were soon to be undertaken by those most interested in having it done. These articles are by the Rev. Newman Smyth, D. D., Rev. Henry Ward Beecher, and Rev. Lyman Abbott, D. D. The key-note of all the articles in the Review is contained in Dr. Smyth’s opening sentence, which is as follows: “The restatement of creeds has always been only a question of time.” This statement is elaborated at great length, with signal ability and great learning, by each of the three eminent divines named, and the same conclusion is reached, although it is not probable that they knew the views of one another, or that they were to furnish articles upon the same subject.
It is easy to predict that whenever this revision of the creeds of the religious denominations is undertaken, there then will be a season of uneasiness and excitement in the church. To speak of the necessity of revision presupposes some inherent imperfection in the thing to be revised, and religious people of all sects have been in the habit of believing that their particular faith has been pinned to the Rock of Ages. To be told by their own teachers that there is some doubt about the absolute truth of some of the cardinal dogmas of the church, is to unsettle the very foundation of religious belief.
It is not easy to imagine in what these revisions of the creeds will consist. It is possible that they will begin where all the creeds begin, with the mythological story of the first pair in the Garden of Eden, and the fall of man, upon which the whole orthodox theory of the plan of salvation is based. What will become of many of the “essential” doctrines, it is hard to predict. Infant damnation, election, predestination, a personal devil, and a literal lake of fire and brimstone for the wicked after death, have long since, in most intelligent minds, been consigned to the realm of tradition and superstition. How a belief in the trinity, the vicarious atonement wrought by Christ, and the resurrection of the dead at the day of Judgment, will stand the test of an attempted readjustment, remains for the future to disclose.
The natural tendency of all denominations in America is toward Catholicity; the partition walls are being broken down, and a revision of creeds will help forward the good work. The man is alive to-day who can remember when a Methodist minister was not allowed to enter a Presbyterian pulpit, and less than twenty years ago, a Methodist minister who had kindly preached for a destitute “close communion” Baptist society, took a back seat among the spectators after delivering his sermon, while the deacons administered the sacrament to the faithful of their own sect. The preacher had not beenp. 84 baptized by immersion, and was not good enough to commune with those who had a proper contempt for sprinkling. Much of this Pharisaical “I am holier than thou” exclusiveness will pass away in the sweet by and by, and brethren of all sects will dwell together in unity.
Then, again, with the revision of the creeds will be permitted a greater liberty and a wider latitude in all matters of mere theological speculation. Possibly the church may honestly and frankly confess that it knows absolutely nothing concerning the next state of existence. It is “the undiscovered country, from whose bourne no traveler returns,” and man’s destiny and occupation in the next life are matters of mere conjecture. It is clearly a mistake, therefore, for any religious creed to attempt to formulate a definite belief concerning things in the future, of which the wisest are necessarily ignorant.
Let us hope, too, when this reform takes place, that the church will attach more importance to correct living and less to orthodox, speculative believing, and lay more stress upon works than upon faith. It will not then repel from its embrace thousands of good men and women who are willing to square their lives by the Golden Rule, but will not and cannot conscientiously indorse all the absurdities of the Thirty-nine Articles. Then persons of noble and exalted lives, who possess all the essential characteristics of a Christian manhood, will not be hunted down for heresy—then the Collyers, the Swings, the Thomases, and the Cheneys, who love their fellow-men and are trying to benefit them, will not be thrust out of the synagogues because they doubt what others do not know.
“Fly swiftly round, ye wheels of time, And bring that happy day.”
Long ago the prophet Isaiah uttered the following important prediction concerning an event now soon to transpire, and which, no doubt, is distinctly foreshadowed in the above article:—
“And it shall come to pass in the last days; that the mountain of the Lord’s house shall be established in the top of the mountains, and shall be exalted above the hills; and all nations shall flow unto it.” Isa. 2:2.
The popular churches have, doubtless, not yet reached the point of exaltation contemplated in the prophecy; but when, by a revision of creeds on the basis of Catholicity, her doors will have been thrown open alike to the conservatist, the liberalist, and the rationalist, the concluding terms, which I have emphasized, will be fully realized in a great accession to her membership, and she will speedily become the repository of all the unclean things enumerated in Rev. 18:2. Then, united, it would not be at all difficult to enforce her dogmas at the point of the sword; the image to the beast would be quickly formed, his worship required, and his mark imposed.
Although the picture is strongly drawn, it evidently does not exceed the limits of probability when measured by the terms of revelation.