AdventAI

CAN THE WORLD BE REFORMED?

By Wm. Penniman

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 23., June 5, 1883

Such is the question asked by the St. Louis Evangelist, a leading Presbyterian paper, of April 5, 1883. As the article so well represents the reformatory measures of the day, and is published by a paper which advocates the millennium, we deem it a good argument against that doctrine, and worthy of a place in the REVIEW.

Wm. Penniman.

About thirty years ago, when the venerable Albert Barnes, of Philadelphia, was finally retiring from the pulpit, he preached a sermon which he entitled “Life at Threescore and Ten.” Reviewing the world of morals beyond the church during all those previous years, and fixing his gaze on the temperance cause, which had just met with a serious back-set, he cried out, “We have suffered a Waterloo defeat.”

Were that zealous man alive in this present year of grace, he might see occasion to repeat the depressing cry with increased emphasis. The repulse of prohibition all along the whole line, reads to us once more the oft-taught lesson that the most strenuous efforts of the church for the reformation of the outside world, would seem to be labor almost thrown away.

Moved with benevolent grief at the havoc made by vice, ministers and active Christians, not content with building up the kingdom, have stepped beyond, and thrown themselves ardently into the various movements of moral reform,—Sabbath observance, the suppression of the “social evil,” and other good works; but notably the temperance cause.

Yet, what is to-day seen accomplished, after half a century of toil and sweat, in these specific labors? How now stands the Sabbath outside the church? After many and long trumpet appeals from the pulpit, and the most vigorous employment of the press, and all our organizations to re-instate holy time, things are at this hour worse than ever before in our country. The railroads everywhere drive right over Sabbath law. All summer, our cities weekly vomit forth more immense crowds on pleasure excursions. Especially on Sunday the crack of the rifle is everywhere heard in our forests. Enormous hosts congregate to cheer and shout over boisterous games. The low theaters are crowded of a Sabbath evening. As if in defiance of our reasonings, warnings, and pleadings, the orderly Sabbath of our fathers is driven clean out of the land.

Look, for a moment, at the prostitution of the sacred law of marriage, especially in the practice of divorce. Right in the face of the constant reading of the divine precept, over against the severest denunciations of the pulpit, and as if in purposed contempt of organizations to rescue the marriage tie, the practice of “putting away for every cause,” or for no cause, is daily becoming worse and worse. In certain States, the yearly number of divorces sum up many hundreds, and form a large ratio to the whole number of marriages. Lately, in one of the gravest and most thoughtful of our Reviews, appeared an article entitled “Polygamy in New England,” and written by no less a man than the New Englander, Dr. L. W. Bacon. The very title is humiliating; and it is made damning by the array of facts which the essay contains, and especially by placing side by side the consecutive polygamy of New England and the simultaneous polygamy of Utah, the comparison showing, in some respects, decidedly in favor of the Utah institution. The evil has spread, and is still spreading, west and south, over the whole country; and to-day the vile immorality more than ever outbraves the church, her weekly pronunciation of the decalogue, and all her utterances of woe because of this sin.

Returning to the subject of intemperance: For many decades of years, Christian men by thousands have joined hands with thousands of reformers beyond the church, and concerted measures, now after this shape, now after that, to stay the plague of drunkenness. After trial of various methods of assault on the enemy's works, and after repulses just as many, it was determined, from bitter experience, that prohibition was the remedy, and that prohibition would win—was winning.

But suddenly the enemy comes in anew like a flood. All that was supposed to be gained in Kansas, in Iowa, in Vermont, in Indiana, seems on the verge of being swept away. And what do they propose to give us instead? “High license,” which means a tub to the whale, and lawless rum-selling in city and country. With the existing low license, the evasions, and dodgings, and defiance of law are general and notorious. The beast that spurns the long tether, will much less be held by a short one.

What, on the whole, is the practical outlook of the temperance cause to-day? In all our cities, drunkenness and the entire host of its attendant miseries are more than ever rampant. Newspapers of New York and Chicago have been giving us plats of contiguous square after square in those cities, all fully built up, and nearly every house a grog-shop! The pictures would surely be taken for gross slanders, were it not that the localities are expressly given, and the houses counted in detail. In the nation at large, the dreary host of inebriates, “with banners beckoning on to death,” so far from being at all reduced, is yearly increasing—some say now a million strong. And the enormous volume of revenue from this one vice, draining the people more than ever, perplexes and amazes all thoughtful men. Verily, moral reform beyond the church seems a threshing of thrice-threshed straw. Individuals there (we hope they are to be counted by thousands) have been snatched from drunkenness and other pits equally deep; and these have well repaid the toil. But for society and the nation there has as yet been no deliverance whatever.

Can the world outside of the church be reformed? Have we any reason, or facts, or prophecy, to justify the expectation?—John Leighton.