AdventAI

INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC.

By George I. Butler

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 21., May 22, 1883

THERE was a time in the history of this cause when no musical instrument could have been found in any of our worshiping assemblies. They are now becoming quite common. They are thought by some to be almost indispensable in camp-meetings, Sabbath-schools, tent-meetings, and in temperance gatherings, and are being used to quite a degree in our Sabbath worship. It cannot be denied that among our old, staunch brethren there was quite a strong feeling against the introduction of organs into our worship. It was thought to be another evidence of our approximation to a worldly standard, and a giving in to influences leading away from Bible simplicity. But the influence of some in leading positions, and the strong desire of some of the younger members, who had a special interest in music, has brought about the results now apparent. It is probable that instrumental music has come to stay. The feelings of those who were opposed to it have become somewhat modified since its introduction, and many who were indifferent have come to like it, and think it quite a help in some directions. Those who were in favor of using it as a help in worship would of course cling to it strenuously if there was any thought of putting it aside. Hence we conclude it is likely to remain.

The writer has never felt like opposing its introduction; neither has he been enthusiastic in its favor. We see some reasons in its favor, and some dangers if it is abused, or given too much prominence. We cannot see that instrumental music is morally wrong in itself. It is plain that it was in common use in David's time, and that many of his psalms were composed to be performed upon various instruments. Had the use of these been wicked, this would not have been. The New Testament recommends vocal music. We are “to sing and make melody in our hearts to the Lord.” Why should we do this? Evidently because there is something elevating to the soul, a calling out of feelings of devotion and reverence, in singing the songs of Zion. The strains of music, uniting with the sentiments of love, gratitude, and devotion contained in the words, lift and inspire the soul with the spirit of true worship. Thus God is glorified and we are benefited. It is right that we should use all methods which will lead to such excellent results. If instrumental music will help to accomplish such results, by all means let us use it. If it is a hindrance, we do not want it.

May such music be made helpful in the service and worship of God? We think it can. And we also think it can easily be made harmful. We think it is self-evident that the pure, rich, mellow tones of a well-tuned instrument, blending with the voices of the singers, adds to the effect upon the ears and hearts of the hearers; that it increases the good effect if not made too prominent. It helps to keep the voices together. It lessens the liability of discord by furnishing a correct standard of tone, by which the voices may be guided. It helps to keep the time. It gives the proper key and the point of commencing. We think these are good results, and it is of considerable importance that they are attained. Music is a precious gift of God; and if not perverted, is a great blessing to the race. Everything that is worth doing is worth doing well. Instrumentalp. 329 music may be made to lift the soul toward God. In a great crisis, the prophet Elisha called for a minstrel; and when he played, the Spirit of God came upon his servant, and he was able to give directions which wrought a great salvation. 2 Kings 3:15. Other instances might be mentioned where the strains of musical instruments fired the soul with the holiest thoughts.

We have no question but that it is possible in our tent-meetings to make the use of the organ a real help. Many at first will come out to hear the music if it is good, who may become interested as they listen to the truth from the minister's lips, and they may thus be saved. Perhaps they would never have attended but for the music. No doubt the organ, if well played, adds to the attraction of the Sabbath-school, and tends to make the children love to be present. This is a good result. In our large camp-meetings, the organ often subserves a very useful purpose. Where hundreds are singing in the tent, separated necessarily far apart, there is great danger of not keeping good time. The singers come from different churches, and are not accustomed to singing together. Some are used to singing slow and some fast. When these all come together, it is almost inevitable that they get mixed up on time, unless there is an organ and leading voices to carry the tune so that all can hear. Keeping poor time will ruin the music, no matter how good the voices may be. Here the organ may be a real help. We have little sympathy with that narrowness and prejudice which would deprive us of any real help in the service and worship of God, whereby real good could be done and the good cause be advanced, just because of certain notions entertained without good reason.

We cannot doubt but that instrumental music may be made a real curse. We fully believe this has generally been the effect of it in the past history of God's people. We are of the opinion that in times of great religious awakening and reform, when the people of God are humble, zealous, and consecrated, very little attention or interest is given to it. At such times it is most generally laid aside; we hear nothing of it in the apostles' days. Christ nowhere commands it; we hear little of it among the Reformers or Early Methodists; and in the great and glorious advent movement in 1843–4 such things were looked upon with great indifference or positive dislike. We cannot conceal from ourselves the fact that among us, many of those most spiritual have little interest in it, or really fear its effects; and that many of those least spiritual and most worldly are its strongest advocates. This does not show that its proper use is wrong. But it does show that it is not as important as many would have us believe.

The natural tendency of mankind is downward and away from spirituality. When real religious interest and enjoyment is lost, we naturally seek for something else to take its place. Music is often made a substitute. Good music affords pleasure to the natural heart as well as to the Christian. Music is thus made to minister to pride, to educated taste, and to our sense of enjoyment outside of any spiritual good, which God no doubt intended it to help. When music is thus perverted, it becomes actually a great curse. It lulls the spiritual senses to sleep. It pacifies and satisfies the conscience without God, which is a condition of great danger. It leads the heart to worldly pleasure, to worldly associations, and worldly enjoyments, and many otherwise good people become so blinded that they do not discern its tendency.

Anything which tends to satisfy the soul without God's blessing is full of danger. The amount of vanity, pride, self-love, self-gratification, and forgetfulness of God which has come in among our young people, with their great eagerness for musical enjoyment is enormous; and they do not realize their danger. Music is adored, and God often forgotten. We greatly fear this spirit often mingles with the instrumental music in our meetings. If so, the result is bad.

We are very apt to rely upon such helps, and make too much of them. We have heard ministers talk as though a tent-meeting could hardly be carried on successfully unless an organ was taken along, with a good player and a trained band of singers, to draw out and hold the people by the charms of sweet music. We pity ministers who are so blinded as to hold such sentiments. Have they forgotten the crowds which used to attend the courses of lectures in the early days of the message, when it was nothing strange for from fifty to one hundred and fifty to embrace the truth within a few weeks? Our lecturers in those days generally had three times, if not ten times, the success they do now. The idea of having an organ to help the interest was never thought of. The earnestness, zeal, and spiritual fire with the preachers was worth more than a tent full of organs to hold, convict, and convert the people. There was a power which went with the preaching then that we do not often see now. When we get to the point where we rely upon organs, or anything else but the power of God's truth presented with intelligent zeal and the Spirit of God, we shall make but small headway in converting the people to this truth.

Such ministers would do well to spend more time in secret prayer and self-examination, and humbling the soul before God till they discovered the source of true power with God and the people. With the heart tender and full of love, and solemn with a deep sense of the tremendous importance of this last great message for mankind, people will listen spell-bound, and be compelled to say that God is in the work. Organs, however skillfully played, can never produce such results. While we have no objection to the organ in tent-meetings, and while believing they may be sometimes quite useful in their proper place, yet we tremble for our ministers who exalt them too highly, and rely upon them measurably as a substitute for the Spirit.

The only reason we can see why organs should have a place in our religious services is that they may be a help to them. If they are a help, we want them; if not we have no use for them. We think they may, if properly used, be of service; but we fear they are often otherwise. When we meet in camp or church to worship, we spend from one to two hours at a time in the service of God. That time is sacred to him that he may be glorified, and that we may be benefited. Anything which will not tend to this result has no business there. We should pray and sing with the spirit and with the understanding also. We should raise our hearts in adoration to God in both these exercises. We should listen with reverence to the preached word and to the testimonies given. This is the business we are there to attend to. Nothing else is in place.

We cannot see that at such a time and in such a place it would be edifying or fitting for any performer on a musical instrument, however excellent he or she might be, to sit down and go to playing a tune for the people to listen to, or to take up that sacred time in any such manner. It might be a good chance to exhibit his skill, and the music might be pleasant to hear, and it would be all very agreeable at the fire-side or home-circle. We should enjoy it there as well as any one; but when we are met to worship God, and engaged in that solemn business, we cannot see that it is in place, or has any business there. It is not worship. We are sure all our readers will agree with us that such a course would not be proper. If this be so, where is the propriety of playing through a long prelude every time before the congregation sings? The minister rises and reads the solemn words of the hymn, sometimes a stanza of eight or more lines, then the organist strikes up, and plays the familiar tune all through. All the singers know it as well as he. The audience sit there and wait. We can see that this affords an excellent opportunity for the organist to show his skill as a player in quavers and quirks, slurs and diminuendoes, etc., etc. He has a goodly number of hearers who must perforce sit very quiet and still; the proprieties of the place require it, but we can't see the worship in it. We fail to see that it adds to the devotion or interest. It seems to us to check and cool both. The solemn words read by the minister are more likely to be forgotten. It does not add to the information of any unless it shows in a clearer light the skill of the performer, for the time is well known to the singers; or, if it is not, they would not become acquainted with it because it was played through once. If the organist would give the key note, or play very quickly a line while the singers were rising, showing the proper key and tune, it would be very well and a great improvement.

The same principle applies to the interlude. We have never been able to see the propriety or benefit of a long performance on the organ between the stanzas, the singers meanwhile standing there waiting for the organist to finish up, unless it be a still further exhibition of said skill. We do not see that it glorifies God, or helps anybody but the organist, or that it is worship, or that it adds to the spirituality or solemnity of the occasion. It seems to us oftentimes to greatly cool off the fervor and interest of the singing, especially in tunes of a slow or solemn measure. In a quick, lively tune when the singers are slightly out of breath, a very short interlude to give time to recover the breath, would be reasonable and sensible between some of the stanzas in a long hymn; but for the life of us, we can see no benefit in any more.

These reflections we wish to apply to ordinary and good performers, who have in a fair degree a sense of the proprieties of the occasion, but who follow the customs which have become sanctioned in the popular churches, perhaps because they have never stopped to give the matter thought. If such will stop and carefully consider this matter, they will see that such a course tends to formality, and chills the devotional element, exalts the musical instrument to a position higher than it deserves in God's worship, attracts attention to the performer unduly, and is really out of place because not a part of true worship.

But there is another class of performers on the organ who have sorely tried our patience at times. They take this time of sacred religious worship to show off their skill as players. They are generally young persons who have taken lessons, and possibly have received a diploma of some sort after practicing some time on waltzes, marches, and other worldly stuff now so prevalent. Somebody having seen their skill in lively manipulation of the keys, invites them, or they invite themselves, to preside at the organ in public worship. They think it a favorable time to exhibit their proficiency as players before the congregation, and so favor us with interludes, perhaps between most serious and solemn verses, resembling the kind of music they are familiar with. They throw in all sorts of movements and fantasia, apparently trying to come as near making a discord as possible, thinking to please the fancy of the listener as they would at a parlor exhibition. It is hard to tell whether to pity or censure such players most for their utter lack of good sense and taste in discerning the proprieties of the occasion.

Everything partaking of vanity and pride are out of place in God's worship. Everything whichp. 330 draws attention away from the sacred influences of religion and thoughts of God should not be tolerated in connection with it. Our greatest difficulty is to hold the mind to these things. We must cultivate humility, seriousness, and solemnity in this age of self-love and vain pride. If we do not, we are surely on the wrong road. Does the organ minister to pride, and lead away from God by calling attention to itself? It may or may not, according to the way we use it. It never should be made a prominent object in religious worship. It should always be held as a very humble assistant if used at all. It is not a necessity in any sense. We have got along without it in the past very well, when we enjoyed greater spiritual blessings than we now do. We can use it as a help if we guard against its abuses.

The writer perhaps ought to apologize to our professors in musical taste and skill for venturing into their peculiar field in this outspoken manner, since he puts forth no claims to wisdom in their line. But perhaps it is well that they should know how things appear sometimes from the common standpoint. Perhaps these words may provoke reflection, and quite likely disapproval, and possibly censure; but be that as it may, we ask that no one be held responsible for them but

GEO. I. BUTLER.