AdventAI

HAS THE SPIRIT A FORM?

By N. J. Bowers

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 22., May 29, 1883

BY N. J. BOWERS.

The popular idea of the human spirit meets with many difficulties, crosses, and absurdities in its march to a place in consistent theology.

Last fall, in Republic Co., Eld. Lockwood, a presiding elder of the Northwest Kansas Conference of the M. E. church, gave a discourse on “The Immortality of the Soul, and the Intermediate State” by request of some who had been disturbed by the preaching of “soul-sleeping.” The elder is a smooth, pleasant, and courteous speaker, and apparently well-read and abreast of the times. He tried hard to make a point out of the fact that the properties of matter and spirit are very unlike, the first alone possessing form, divisibility, etc.

He insisted much that spirit, love, hate, etc., are not round, square, angular, and the like. Certainly they are not; yet the elder did not stick to it all through, either from forgetfulness or from the exigencies of the case. In the progress of his discourse he came up to the case of Saul and the woman of Endor, and of course he had to make use of it. It was too valuable to pass by. He said, in speaking of it, that the woman “was alarmed when she saw the spirit of Samuel,” and that “Saul expected to see the spirit of Samuel.” Then the spirit has a form in order that it may be seen. The elder was positive the spirit of Samuel appeared on this occasion. In verse 14 of 1 Sam. 28, margin, the question is asked What is his form? Then again, the spirit has a form contrary to the elder’s statement. He stated form to be an attribute of matter and not of spirit, yet he has the spirit of the old prophet possessing shape or form. I don’t know how to help him out of his awkward predicament, and he cannot get himself out unless he “goes back” on one of two things; either admit that spirit has a shape, or deny that the spirit of Samuel appeared.

Let us suppose the spirit of Samuel really appeared, and we will have some very interesting things to think about,—

1. Saul wanted Samuel brought up. Ver. 8, 11. Then he was down somewhere.

2. He came up out of the earth. Ver. 13, Was his spirit down in the ground?

3. An “old man” came up. Ver. 14. The spirit, then, is in the form of a man. It has a head, arms, hands, feet, ears, and eyes. In other words, the spirit has a body, or is in bodily shape,—is itself a body.

If it is a body, has it an interior soul and spirit, or is it a body having neither soul nor spirit? If this body-spirit has a spirit, has it a form, too?—is it in bodily shape like the first? Moreover, if the spirit is the shape and size of the body, does it grow as the body grows? These are odd things to think about, yet the thought grows naturally out of the common view.

4. This spirit or spirit-body was covered with a mantle or cloak. Ver. 14. Do spirits wear cloaks over in the spirit world? If so, is it to cover their “unclothed” condition, or is it to keep them warm? Do our orthodox friends think Nero, and Pope Leo IX. and his Inquisitors are now wearing cloaks for this last reason? Did the reader ever stop to think whether the cloak that covered the spirit of Samuel was a material or a spiritual one? Was it a spirit cloak, or was it the spirit of the cloak the old prophet wore around his material body when here on earth?

5. This spirit of Samuel was disquieted in order to bring it up. Ver. 15. To disquiet means to disturb the quiet of, to arouse. Then Samuel’s spirit was roused from its quiet and rest—was it asleep? and being thus disturbed, was brought up. The spirit of the old prophet was down in the earth, and not up in Heaven. Our friends seem to mistake the location of spirits. They somehow get them above when they belong below.

6. Wicked, witch-consulting, God-forsaken Saul was to be next day with holy Samuel in glory, for there is where all good spirits go, so we are told (ver. 19), and Saul was so overcome with this information that he fell prostrate, and was “sore afraid.” Ver. 20. He didn’t seem to cherish the idea of going over into the spirit land.

7. We are not told that the soul, or spirit, of Samuel appeared. The words do not occur in the entire account.

8. If Samuel was really present on this occasion, it was by a resurrection from the dead.

9. But we do not think Samuel was raised.

We were told this case has no connection with spiritism. We dissent. We think it has. This woman had a “familiar spirit,” and by it she professed to communicate with the dead. This spirit personated Samuel by “materializing,” so to speak, or produced upon the mind of the woman by mesmeric power an image of the dead prophet, and likewise she heard him speak.