WHAT CATHOLICS SAY

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 27, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 9.

Read the full edition

WHAT CATHOLICS SAY.

HARD QUESTIONS FOR SUNDAY-KEEPERS.

THE first of the following paragraphs we find in a newspaper article credited to the Palmer Journal. It is an explanation of the Sunday question by a Catholic from a Catholic standpoint. This paragraph shows how Protestants are involved in papal tradition by the observance of the day. How can they clear themselves from the charge of recognizing the authority of the Catholic church? He says:—
“The observance of Sunday as a religious festival by Protestants implies a recognition of the authority of the Catholic church in spiritual matters, as the Bible is silent on that matter. No apostolic command or suggestion has been given for the change of day. Protestant compilers of Bible Dictionaries are driven to despair when they come to explain the adoption of the first day of the week in lieu of the seventh-day Sabbath on Bible authority; they usually explain away the change, in words meritoriously brief, by saying that the Apostles, Acts 20:7, broke bread on the first day of the week. But as it is not customary for Protestants to break bread on the first day after the Sabbath, the mere recital of this occurrence has no binding force on them. A Protestant cannot on any principle of his religion defend or explain the adoption of Sunday in lieu of the Sabbath of the decalogue.”
The following is from James Blake, M. D., another Roman Catholic. In a debate with a Protestant he drove the latter to the wall with the following unanswerable charges:—
“Christ never wrote, but God the Father did. He wrote the ten commandments on the tables of stone, and the only commandment he emphasized was that to keep the seventh day, ‘Remember to keep holy the seventh day’; and there is no command so often repeated throughout the Old Testament. If the Bible alone be the gentleman’s rule of faith, he is bound by this commandment; but does he observe it? No, he does not. Has he any Scripture authority for rejecting it? No, he has not. Why, then, does he not observe it? Because the church thought fit to change it. Here the gentleman admits the authority of the church to be superior to the hand-writing of God the Father. And yet he will look you in the face and declare that the Bible, without church authority, is his rule of faith.”