The Caliph of Islam

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 27, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 9.

Read the full edition

The Caliph of Islam.

An interesting side-light is thrown on the Turkish question by the following, which appeared in the editorial of the N. Y. Independent of Feb. 15, 1883. Read it.
“There is a Sultan of Turkey; there is a Caliph of Islam. The Sultan of Turkey is not necessarily Caliph of Islam, although he has been since, three hundred and fifty years ago, Sultan Selim I. compelled Caliph Mohammed XII. of Cairo, to yield to him the title. From that time, the Caliph, or spiritual head of all Islam, has not been of the family of Mohammed, of the tribe of Koreish, nor even of Arab descent. He has been a Turk, and has held the title of Caliph simply by right of force. Because he possessed, as Sultan of Turkey, the highest civil power in the Mohammedan world, his claims have been allowed to be also the Pope of Islam.”
“The Sultan holds Turkey only by the active military support of Christian Europe. Ever since the Crimean war, this has been confessed. Even lately, a single European power has, in a short campaign, released the larger part of what was European Turkey from the hold of the Sultan. If England and France were to take off their hand, Russia would in a year seize Constantinople and Asia Minor, and drive Sultan Hamid to Mecca. But Mecca would not receive as Caliph the man who could not maintain his power as Sultan. Already it is England that maintains the caliphate at Constantinople. But for England, Arabi would have been master of Egypt, and soon after recognized Caliph; for, though Hamid gave him qualified and diplomatic aid, as a Moslem fighting the infidel, yet Hamid well knew that Arabi, victorious and powerful, would as certainly supplant him as the Head of Islam, as would Mohammed Ali have done it, but for European intervention. Then Europe decided who should be Caliph, and Europe does it now. This does not satisfy the Mohammedans of Egypt, Tunis, Arabia, scarcely of Turkey. It is as if China and Japan were to settle who should be Pope of Rome. Pan-Islam knows that Turkey is weak, and that Hamid is Caliph not by the grace of Allah, but by the grace of the Giaour. Pan-Islam feels the humiliation; and, if left to itself, the Sherif of Mecca, who is of the lineage of the Prophet, or of any Mehdi who could claim the title, would be gladly recognized as the spiritual head of the Moslem world. It is only lately that the Sherif was deposed by the Turk because he aspired to be Caliph, and another was put in his place. The Turk is not loved by the Arab. Give the Arab a chance, and he would be free from the Turk.”
“But Sultan Hamid holds on with great tenacity to his religious power. Unlike Abdul Aziz, he is a pious Moslem, and cares more to be Caliph than Sultan. It is not his ambition to make Turkey great and prosperous, but to see Pan-Islam successful against the Infidel, if not by war, then by diplomacy. Hence the plots in Tunis, in Egypt, in India. Hence he sits in his palace and dreams of the victories of the Faith of the Prophet. Meanwhile there are no reforms in Turkey; no believer is punished that murders a Christian; new fanaticisms and outbreaks against Christians are encouraged; Christian churches can get no firmans; Christian books can scarcely be printed even in a Christian language; no Mussulman would now dare abjure his faith; and the counselors of the Sultan are not the ministers of the Porte, but the astrologers, eunuchs, and holy men of the Palace. Meanwhile Islam gains no benefit, while Turkey suffers that Islam may be exalted. The Caliph could do nothing for Tunis against France, nor for Egypt against England. He is dishonored before the Islam which he claims to lead.”
“Why should Europe still support his spiritual claims? Grant that the Sultan shall still rule in Constantinople over Turkey; why uphold him as the chief plotter of outbreaks among two hundred million Moslems? Why not let the Sherif of Mecca take the honor which he aspires to, and tell the Sultan that he will be held responsible by Europe, as the Khedive of Egypt is held responsible by England, for the good government of his Turkish dominions? Only let England lift her protecting hand from Hamid, and Mecca would again become the spiritual center of Islam. There is good reason to believe that here is the best solution, for the present, of the Turkish question.”