Dr. Joshua Leavitt was the editor of a religious newspaper in this city. He was a smart man, radical in his views, sharp and ready in their expression. He retired from the paper when he was in full vigor. A few weeks after his retirement, he was met on the street by the late Nicholas Murray, D. D. (Kirwan), who said to him,—
“Dr. Leavitt, I am sorry you have left the paper.”
“But I did not suppose,” returned Dr. L., “that you read it.”
“Oh, yes, I did,” said Kirwan; “while you were its editor, there was always a spice of wickedness about it that made it readable.”
I wonder if this keen witticism of one of the keenest men of that day did not have as much truth as wit in it. There is no need of pressing the pleasantry into an imputation of evil purpose. It was quite as hard on Murray himself as on Leavitt, for it is no worse to furnish the spice than to enjoy it. The remark was playful, but there must have been something behind it in the way of justification, or it would have been a poor joke and very rude.
There is in the pulpit and the newspaper, in conversation and public address, a style that has just that feature about it which Dr. Murray so deftly described by the brief and quite sufficient phrase, “a spice of wickedness.” Many a remark would fall flat on many an ear but for the emphasis wickedly given to it by the use of a strong, improper word. The ear of the good man is pained by the epithet, but the wicked hear it, and are glad.
Now, none are perfect. There is in each one of us enough of the old Adam left to have elective affinity with what does not inhere in saints or angels. It doth not yet appear what we shall be. But it is very certain, at present, that we are not what we ought to be. And this explains the readiness with which even good people find amusement and pleasure where they should not.
Just on the outer verge of what is right, and on the edge of that which is wrong, is a doubtful and dangerous place, where it is exhilaration, if not enjoyment, to walk. I remember the fun in boyhood of sliding on ice that bent under the feet; to stand on it would be to go through, but to slide swiftly across, though not safe, was exciting and possible, and therefore great sport. Playing with danger is amusing, though often fatal, as every day’s reading of the newspapers proves. No amount of warning has the slightest tendency to abate the use of deadly weapons in household play. Wherein consists the fun that a brother has in pointing a loaded gun at his sister, and “making believe” that he is going to shoot? There is a spice of wickedness in the thought of killing. He would shrink with horror from crime, but finds a secret pleasure in the rehearsal of a tragedy he would not perform for the world.
In this affinity for what is forbidden lies the secret of the boundless popularity of literature tinged—not deeply tainted—with wickedness. The gross, sensual, and devilish, finds open and secret admirers, but not so many as those novels and poems that suggest, but do not inculcate, vice—that make it attractive even under the guise of condemning it. “You naughty, naughty man,” saith the siren, while she tempts her victim to his undoing. When such literature is condemned by the stern judge as dangerous, he is challenged to point to a page or a word that is wicked. He may not be able to do it, but he knows there is a spice of wickedness seasoning every page, and making it extremely palatable and pleasant to the taste of men made a little lower than the angels. The voluptuous poetry of the Byron and Swinburne school, French novels reeking with scarcely concealed filth, are not more poisonous than the scientific tract which eliminates God from creation, or the sermon that makes light of the retributions of eternity. They are popular, because the people are not saints. Some love darkness rather than light, because their deeds are evil; but more love the taste of that which has the flavor of sin, because their taste is depraved, though they have been hitherto restrained from sins “they are inclined to.”
It is probable that a preacher, left to himself, may be tempted to tickle the ear of the multitude by extravagant utterances that startle the audience; the few are grieved, while the people applaud. They like it. One of these rattlers was blazing away with frequent use of the name of the Almighty Maker, when a child, looking up to her mother, whispered, “What makes him swear so?”
Last week one of the courts made a legal decision in a suit, pronouncing officially that the use of a certain word, often heard among business men, is profane swearing. A word may be used properly in one manner and sense, while the same expression under other circumstances would be highly unbecoming. And so it happens that the mixture of strong words, the name and attributes of God, in pious discourse, may savor so much of the reckless and profane as to be suggestive of swearing, and seem to the ignorant multitude as very splendid oratory. The spice of wickedness is just what they like.
“Stolen waters are sweet, and bread eaten in secret is pleasant.” It was not the wise man who said that, but it has a mighty deal of wisdom in it. It is wonderful, even to the outer rim of belief, that the hearts of men four thousand years ago so nearly, so exactly, correspond with the hearts of those on whom these ends of the world have come. Thoughts we would not confess to the one nearest to us, are fondled with affection. “We know the right, and yet the wrong pursue.” The sweet morsel under the tongue is forbidden fruit, and all the sweeter because it is against the law to taste it. The attraction of gravitation is the strongest force in the natural world, and the strongest in the moral world is the attraction of gratification. We go to what we like. The evil that is in us has fellowship with all the evil in the universe. The leaven of ill that pervades our nature leavens the lump of humanity. The whole world is kin.
“Hence we view” that the man who seasons his conversation, his writings, his preachings, with a spice of wickedness, has a fair chance of pleasing the many. But he is not the highest style of man. To please, to titillate, “to make it readable,” is not the noblest end of life. But to win souls to the true, lovely, and of good report, that is the highest purpose of the good man, and happy he who has the power, the chance, and the will to do it.—Dr. Irenæus Prime, in N. Y. Observer.