BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
OBJECTIONS ANSWERED.
I RECENTLY published in the REVIEW an article entitled, “Seventh-day Adventists and the Testimony of Jesus Christ.” In that article, I endeavored to prove that Seventh-day Adventists have in their midst the spirit of prophecy. In doing so, it was shown, first, that Seventh-day Adventists answered to the remnant church of Rev. 12:17; secondly, that the remnant church is to have the testimony of Jesus Christ; thirdly, that the testimony of Jesus Christ is the spirit or gift of prophecy.
A friend takes exception to the reasoning employed in that article. As he discussed the subject in the spirit of candor, it has been thought best, although some little time has elapsed since the article was published, to give a summary of the principal points made by him, with brief replies thereto.
Before doing so, it may be well to premise that the objector agrees with us that S. D. Adventists are the remnant church spoken of in Rev. 12:17, and that they keep the commandments of God, the only point upon which we differ being that respecting their possession of the gift of prophecy. Trusting that the readers of the REVIEW will remember the substance of the argument which I made in the article spoken of above, I will take up the objections offered without an attempt at recapitulation.
OBJECTION I. If there are those among us who have visions, Rev. 12:17 and 19:10 do not prove that fact. The proof must be sought elsewhere.
ANS. It is true that these passages, standing alone, would not prove the genuineness of the claims of any in the church of S. D. Adventists to the exercise of prophetic power. If, however, as the gentleman agrees, S. D. Adventists are the same people spoken of in Rev. 12:17, they must have the gift of prophecy, provided we were right in defining the testimony of Jesus as covering the gift of prophecy. Rev. 19:10. Farther on, we will see whether our friend has invalidated the argument on that point. Let it be remembered, however, that independently of the argument from Rev. 19:10, twelve texts were introduced to prove the possible perpetuity of the gifts in the Christian church, and that it was maintained that the gift among S. D. Adventists bears all the Scripture tests of a genuine gift. To these points the objector has taken no exception. They stand, therefore, unchallenged.
OBJECTION II. The Greek word marturia, means “testimony” or “witness.” The testimony of Jesus is not confined to the gift of prophecy, but covers everything which Christ has said in the Bible. It is made up partly of his personal teaching while on the earth, and partly of what he has taught through the gift of prophecy since he ascended.
ANS. It is true that marturia, standing alone, signifies simply “testimony” or “witness.” It is true, also, that in a general sense, Christ did bear testimony in person, when he was on the earth. All this, however, does not invalidate the proposition that the term “testimony of Jesus Christ” is employed in Rev. 12:17 and 19:10 in a specific sense, to signify the “spirit of prophecy.” Words are sometimes employed in a general, and sometimes in a special sense. The connection must determine as to which of these senses must be given to them when employed in a specified place. The use of the word in the above text will be considered more fully further on. Let the reader bear in mind, however, that by the admission found above, the testimony of Jesus has been given, partly at least, through the prophetic gift.
OBJECTION III. Having the “testimony of Jesus,” Rev. 12:17, and “keeping the faith of Jesus,” Rev. 14:12, mean the same thing.
ANS. Those who have the testimony of Jesus, i. e., the spirit of prophecy, will of course “keep,” or obey it. Again, those who “keep the faith of Jesus” in the complete sense of the word, will have the “testimony of Jesus,” or the “spirit of prophecy,” and will keep it also. In proof of this proposition, see the declaration of Christ that miraculous powers would be manifested among believers in the fullest sense of that term in all ages and countries. Mark 16:16–18. See also the twelve texts cited in original article to prove the perpetuity of prophetical gifts.
As the gentleman is agreed with us that the company in Rev. 12:17 and 14:12 is one and the same, and as he also admits that they are the same as those now known as S. D. Adventists, he must either concede the point that the latter have the spirit of prophecy, or else he must admit that there is one very important branch of the faith of Jesus which they neither possess nor keep.
OBJECTION IV. The inspired writings never defined words. They employed words already defined by common usage, and with them expressed the ideas which they desired to convey. Rev. 19:10 is an illustration of this practice.
ANS. We had taken the position that Rev. 19:10 furnished an inspired definition of the term “testimony of Jesus,” calling it the “spirit of prophecy.” It is objected that the Bible never defines words. Let us see: “Sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3:4. Does not this define what sin is? “Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.” Heb. 11:1. Are we not here told what faith is?
But to avoid hair-splitting, suppose we concede that the Scriptures do simply define the nature of things, and not words themselves, what then? Why, it would be just as broad as it is long. In Rev. 19:10, where it is stated that the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy, we would understand it to teach that the testimony of Jesus is of the same nature as the spirit of prophecy. Now, if these two things are identical in nature, are they not for the purpose of our present argument, one and the same thing? i. e., is not the testimony of Jesus the same as the spirit of prophecy? If so, then we have made out our point; for that is all we sought to prove. But now for the point that Rev. 19:10 is an illustration of the practice of inspired writers to employ words in their accepted meaning at the time in which they wrote. Here our friend is unquestionably sound as to the rule. But did we not in our article prove, both from the Talmud and the Scriptures, that in the days of the apostles and previous to that time, the term “spirit of prophecy” had an accepted signification, which was the same as that of the gift of prophecy? Perhaps the objector had forgotten our argument on that point. We thank him for the concession, but suggest that it will be a difficult thing for him from his standpoint to climb over or get around such a concession, unless he can prove that the authorities which we cited on that subject were at fault. Until he does so, further discussion might be waived as unnecessary, since he admits that in Rev. 19:10 the term “spirit of prophecy” is used to define the nature of the testimony of Jesus Christ, and since we have shown that, according to the verbal usage in the days of John, the term “spirit of prophecy” was synonymous with the term “gift of prophecy.”
OBJECTION V. Neither the Greek word of which “spirit” is the translation, nor the English word “spirit” means “gift.” Hence the words “spirit of prophecy” cannot mean “gift of prophecy.” There are several Greek words which mean “gift.” It would be necessary to employ one of these in connection with “spirit,” in order to make it signify “gift of prophecy.”
ANS. This is a matter which depends entirely upon usage. We have already seen that in apostolic times it was customary to use the term “spirit of prophecy” to signify “gift of prophecy.” (See citations from Talmud quoted in original article.) The reason of this is found in the fact that it was through the operations of the Spirit of God that the prophetic gift was bestowed. The gifts of the Spirit were various in their forms. To one was given the power to work miracles, to another that of healing, to a third that of talking with tongues, to a fourth prophecy, etc. 1 Cor. 12:8–10. The gift of prophecy consisted in the possession of the spirit of prophecy, or that manifestation of the Spirit of God which enabled one to prophesy, etc. Hence the cause was put for the effect.p. 482 Sometimes even the word “gift,” standing alone, stood for the phrase “gift of the Spirit of God,” as in the following: “So that ye come behind in no gift.” 1 Cor. 1:6, 7. In a like manner the words “spirit of prophecy” might be used for the words “gift of the spirit of prophecy.”
OBJECTION VI. In 1 Cor. 1:6, 7, the testimony of Christ is spoken of as that which occasioned the gifts, and not the gifts themselves.
ANS. To the above we shall take no exception. The angel says in Rev. 19:10 that “the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy,” i. e., it is the Spirit of God manifested in such a way as to result in the bestowment of the gift of prophecy. By metonymy (a form of speech in which a part is taken for a whole, a cause placed for the effect, or the effect for the cause) the spirit of prophecy is said to be the testimony of Jesus because the former is said to be the result or effect of the latter; or in other words, where the testimony of Jesus is fully confirmed, the spirit of prophecy, as well as the other gift, follows as a consequence. Therefore, the testimony of Jesus is called the spirit of prophecy, though the spirit of prophecy is only the effect or consequence of the possession of the testimony of Jesus. Such a form of speech is very common in the Bible, as well as in our ordinary style of conversation. Take, for example, these words: “I am the resurrection and the life.” John 12:25. It is obvious that what is meant here is, not that Christ was actually the resurrection itself, but that he was the cause, or that which would bring about the resurrection. Again: “I am the way, and the truth, and the life” (John 14:6), does not teach that Christ was actually a way, or the truth, or the life, but that he pointed out the way, presented the truth, and will give the life. Once more: “There is death in the pot.” 2 Kings 4:40. These words were not designed to convey the idea that death itself was really in the pot. That could not be, for death is not a thing, but a condition or state. The idea is this: The wild gourds which were in the pot, being poisonous, would produce death. Therefore, by metonymy,—the effect being placed for the cause,—they were put for death itself, in the same manner as in Rev. 19:10 the spirit of prophecy is said to be the testimony of Jesus, because the latter is the cause or occasion of the former.
Thus much by way of laying a foundation upon which the objector and I can stand together.
Now, conceding that our friend is right in regard to the testimony of Christ in 1 Cor. 1:6, 7, in taking the position, as he does, that the testimony of Christ was that which occasioned the gifts, instead of being the gifts themselves, what then? Why, such a position wholly overturns his entire argument. Now, mark it! He says that the testimony of Christ, according to the passage in question, is that which occasions the gift of the Spirit. Having taken that position deliberately, and being an honest man, of course he will be ready to stand by it, let the consequences be what they may. Well, in Rev. 12:17, it is said that the remnant church is to have the testimony of Jesus Christ. He admits that S. D. Adventists are that remnant church. It follows, therefore, even from his own premises, that they must have the spirit of prophecy in their midst, since they are said to have the testimony of Jesus Christ, which, confessedly, is the very thing which causes all the gifts of the Spirit to spring up in the church, and since the gift of prophecy is one of the gifts of the Spirit. 1 Cor. 12:4–11.
We repeat, therefore, that the gentleman must either abandon his objection, or else he must endorse our theory, that the S. D. Adventists, being the remnant church, must have the spirit of prophecy.
OBJECTION VII. If the testimony of Jesus means visions, then every person in the S. D. Adventist church should have visions, or else they do not meet the prophecy of Rev. 12:17 concerning the remnant church.
ANS. This objection is not well taken, as will be seen from 1 Cor. 1:6, 7. In those verses the apostle declares that the Corinthian church, as a church, came behind in no gift. Now, if it might with propriety be said of them, as a church, that they came behind in no gift, it might, with equal propriety, be said of them that “they have the gifts,” or the testimony of Jesus Christ. But will any candid person insist that every member of the church at Corinth actually had visions and exercised all the other gifts of the Spirit? Such a proposition is so preposterous that no man possessing as good sense as our critic evidently does, would ever venture to declare it publicly. It is, indeed, probable that but very few of the members of the church of Corinth ever enjoyed the possession of even one of the gifts. Do you ask, In what sense, then, they could be said, as a church, to have the gifts? I answer, In the sense that the gifts existed in the church to which they belonged, and that they individually recognized them as gifts of the Spirit and obeyed them as such.
In the same sense, the remnant church could be said to have the gifts, if they possessed and adopted them as such, even though there were but few among them who were actually honored by the bestowment upon them of any of the gifts themselves.
OBJECTION VIII. If the testimony of Jesus means spiritual gifts, or visions, we may, without any risk of altering the sense, substitute one for the other. In 1 Cor. 2:1, Paul says he came to the Corinthians, declaring the testimony of God. Did he go declaring visions? In 2 Tim. 1:8, Paul exhorts Timothy not to be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord. Does he mean by that that he should not be ashamed of visions? Rev. 1:9 says that John was in the isle of Patmos for the word of God and for the testimony of Jesus Christ. Was John banished to Patmos on account of having visions? In Rev. 6:9, John saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word of God and the testimony which they held. Were those who suffered persecutions in the Dark Ages put to death on account of the visions which they held?
ANS. It is true, as a general rule, that a substitution of synonymous words is admissible. It is also a fact that no two words are in every respect exactly synonymous. Therefore what are called synonyms may not exactly correspond to each other in every connection, although they may in the majority of connections. Words may agree in their primary sense, and yet have a secondary meaning peculiar to each.
But let us examine the test texts with which our friend has furnished us. The first is 1 Cor. 2:1. In that he represents Paul as saying that he came to the Corinthians “declaring the testimony of God.” He then inquires, “Did he go declaring visions?” To this we reply that it is altogether begging the question to put such a text as 1 Cor. 2:1 into our mouth, and then try our logic by the text thus forced upon us. We never said that the “testimony of God” was the same as the spirit of prophecy. We stated that the testimony of Jesus was the spirit of prophecy. The latter term is not found in the text which our critic quotes, and therefore it has no bearing upon the discussion, and we dismiss it as irrelevant thereto, without further comment.
Before replying to 2 Tim. 1:8, it might be well to remind the reader that the real point at issue is not whether there is a single instance in the Scriptures where words which are the equivalent of “the testimony of Jesus” are applied in a secondary or remote sense to something besides the spirit of prophecy. The real point is this: Does that term, as used in Rev. 19:10, apply, in a specific sense, to the spirit of prophecy? We argue that it does; the objector, that it does not. Even though he could furnish a score of instances where it meant something else in other portions of the Scriptures, that would not help him one particle, unless he could also prove that it could not properly be construed to mean that in Rev. 19:10. Words have different significations under varying circumstances. As suggested above, they have also primary and secondary meanings. Those meanings must be determined from the connections in which they stand, as well as from other considerations. Take for example, the words, “testimony of the Lord,” as used in the following passage: “The testimony of the Lord is sure, making wise the simple.” Ps. 19:7; see also 1 Cor. 2:1. These words evidently relate to the Scriptures, as a whole. But let us try again. In Ex. 25:16, the Lord speaks to Moses as follows: “Thou shalt put into the ark the testimony which I shall give thee.” In Rev. 11:19, we have these words: “The temple of God was opened in Heaven, and there was seen in his temple the ark of his testament.” In the first text cited, we saw that the term “testimony of the Lord” applied to the Scriptures as a whole. But putting the last two texts together, we see that the phrase “testimony of the Lord” sometimes refers to that small portion of the Scriptures which is contained in the ten commandments. Thus, it is shown, as intimated above, that the same word or phrase, may, on different occasions, be applied to two things which differ very widely. It would not be strange, therefore, if the gentleman were able to find a few passages in which “testimony of Jesus” might have a wider signification than in Rev. 19:10. Without, however, discussing that point further, and without taking exception to the difference in the phrases “testimony of our Lord” and the “testimony of Jesus,” it may be best to turn directly to the words cited, “Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord.” 2 Tim. 1:8. As the majority of all the books containing the gospel are given by inspiration, and as Christ, in common with his Father, was the author of the inspiration by which they were given, it would not be at all strange if, following the custom, which we have shown was a very common one, the apostle, by metonymy, took that through which the gospel was given, i. e., the testimony of our Lord, to make it for the time being, to stand for the whole gospel. That, we say, would not have been singular. But now attention is called to something which is not a little remarkable. In the verse but one before the verse cited by the objector, we have this language: “Therefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God which is in thee by the putting on of my hands.” Thus it is made to appear from the very connection quoted, that spiritual gifts were prominently before the mind of the apostle when he was addressing to Timothy the language of 2 Tim. 1:8. Hence, also, it appears that, in substance, he did exhort Timothy not to be ashamed of spiritual gifts, or, as the objector is pleased to term it, “visions,” since the latter result from the gifts.
Turning to the third question, “Was John banished to Patmos on account of having visions?” we say, Not for the testimony of Jesus Christ alone, but for that and the word of God together. Such is the positive declaration of the scripture quoted, Rev. 1:9. Now, will any one deny that John had visions before he went to Patmos? We think not. But again: Will any one deny the possibility that these visions might have been a part of the provoking cause which led to his banishment? Again we reply, We think not. But if such is the case, then the text not only fails to furnish any proof that the testimony of Jesus does not mean the spirit or gift of prophecy, but it also disproves our friend’s theory that the Bible (i. e., the word of God) is, and that the spirit of prophecy is not, the testimony of Jesus. Otherwise, why should John say that he was banished for the word of God and the testimony of Jesus Christ? This coupling of the two words together by the conjunction, implies that they stand for two distinct things. If, however, they stand for two distinct things, then our friend is wrong in supposing that the testimony of Jesus is a part of the written word of God and nothing else.p. 483 To the fourth question, “Were those who suffered persecutions in the Dark Ages put to death on account of the visions which they held?” (Rev. 6:9) it is replied, The citation does not bear upon the case in hand. What we are discussing is the testimony of Jesus and nothing else. But Rev. 6:9 does not mention the testimony of Jesus. It speaks simply of the testimony which the martyrs held. That testimony might or might not have included their testimony through the gift of prophecy.* It is well known, nevertheless, that many of them did possess the spirit of prophecy. But, as remarked above, the text is too indefinite to be of any value in the argument.
OBJECTION IX. Many, in their haste to make the spirit of prophecy a definition of the testimony of Jesus, seem to overlook the little connective “for” in Rev. 19:10. There it is equivalent to because, and introduces the reason why John was to worship God, and not to worship the angel.
ANS. It may be that our friend has, at some time, found some person who was ready to ignore the little connective “for.” It is certain that that individual was not the author of the article to which the objector takes exception. One of the most telling arguments in favor of the identity of the gift of prophecy with the testimony of Jesus, was based upon the fact that the conjunction “for,” found in Rev. 19:10, means “because,” and introduces a reason for the counsel given.
That argument runs as follows: The angel said to John, “Do not worship me. Worship God. God only is worthy of worship. I am thy fellow-servant, and the fellow-servant of thy brethren the prophets (Rev. 22:9), which, like you, have the testimony of Jesus, or, which is the same thing, the spirit of prophecy. If, therefore, I am simply employed in bearing the spirit of prophecy to thy brethren, I am, like you, but a servant of God. In other words, I am one of God’s angels. God’s servants are not worthy of worship. That belongs to God alone; see, therefore, that you do not offer homage to me.” But why was John not to offer homage to the angel? we ask again. For, or because, he was simply the angel who conveyed the spirit of prophecy to John, and not God, who was the Author of that spirit, and to whom alone the worship was due.
This explanation is clear and forcible. It points to the conjunction “for” as a word which introduces a satisfactory reason why John should not worship his heavenly visitor.
OBJECTION X. The meaning doubtless intended in Rev. 19:10 by the words, “the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy,” is this: The testimony of Jesus is the soul, the life, the essence, the inspiration, the embodiment of prophecy. It is an emphatic way of affirming that the testimony of Jesus is prophetic in its character.
ANS. It is a source of satisfaction that, in the foregoing, the objector has given us his understanding of Rev. 19:10. It is one thing to criticize, and another to construct theories. We will see how the objector’s theory will stand the test of careful examination.
In one portion of his communication, he tells us that the testimony of Jesus is the Scriptures at large. Again he tells us, in another place, that it is the gospel. Now, he informs us that in the latter portion of Rev. 19:10 the words “the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy” is simply “an emphatic way of affirming that the testimony of Jesus is prophetic in its character.” But if he is right in the last statement, he cannot be correct in the other two. If the testimony of Jesus is necessarily prophetic in its character, it cannot embody the whole of the Old, or the whole of the New Testament, since only small portions of these are prophetical in fact. Again, he argues very correctly above that the conjunction “for” introduces a reason why John should not worship the angel, and that every correct theory of explanation must recognize that fact. But will some one tell us what there is in the statement that the testimony of Jesus is prophetical (or made up of prophetical scriptures), which is calculated to teach men that they must worship God, and not an angel?
Once more: According to our friend’s view, “the testimony of Jesus is the soul, the life, the essence, the inspiration, the embodiment of prophecy.” If he is correct, the text may be properly read as follows: “See that you do it not. I am your fellow-servant, and the fellow-servant of your brethren, who have the testimony of Jesus. Worship God; for the testimony of Jesus is the soul, the life, the essence, the inspiration, the embodiment of prophecy.” Now we ask in what sense the prophets had the soul, the life, the essence, the inspiration, the embodiment of prophecy? The answer is obvious. They could have had it in only just one way, and that is through the possession of that spirit of prophecy which imparted to them the gift of prophecy. But that is the very thing for which we have been arguing, and the very thing against which the gentleman has been arguing. To take any other view of the subject, would be to assume that which would be both nonsensical and false. The prophets did not, nor could they have the life, the soul, etc., of the prophecies through any qualification of their own. They were mere men like ourselves. They did not, in many instances, even understand the prophecies which they gave. It is probably true that John could not have explained one-twentieth part of what he saw on the isle of Patmos. Both he and Daniel were unwise enough to endeavor to worship the angel who was communicating the prophecy to them. Under such circumstances, it would appear almost like blasphemy to say that they possessed (had) in and of themselves, the soul, inspiration, etc., of their prophecies. We have always supposed that the embodiment and inspiration of prophecy came from a higher source than mere men. The word inspiration itself means to breathe into. Men who have inspiration receive it from God in the form of the prophetic gift. In confirmation of this fact, please observe the following: “The prophets have inquired and searched diligently, who prophesied of the grace that should come unto you; searching what, or what manner of time, the Spirit of Christ that was in them did signify, when it testified beforehand the sufferings of Christ and the glory that should follow. Unto whom it was revealed that not unto themselves, but unto us, they did minister the things which are now reported unto you,” etc. 1 Pet. 1:10–12. Here it will be noted that the prophets were not the soul, the inspiration, etc., of the prophecies which they uttered, but that Christ, by his Spirit, bore testimony through them, and that he was the inspiration of those prophecies. This, again, is in harmony with the view of the subject which we advocate. The Spirit of Christ and the testimony of Christ sustained to each other the relation of cause and effect.
Thus it has been made to appear that the objections of our critic are not only unfounded, but that the theory of interpretation which he offers is unsound.
Before concluding this article, by way of confirming the position taken by us in this matter, attention is invited to Rev. 22:9, where are found the following words: “See thou do it not; I am a fellow-servant with thee and with thy brethren the prophets, and with them who keep the words of this book: worship God.” (Revised Version.) In the foregoing, words are given which were spoken to John upon his second attempt to worship the angel. The language employed varies just enough from that used in Rev. 19:10 to throw additional light upon the subject under discussion. It will be remembered that in examining the latter passage, it was argued that the testimony of Jesus was equivalent to the spirit of prophecy, and, therefore, that those who were said to “have the testimony of Jesus” were individuals who were in possession of the gift of prophecy. By placing the two passages side by side, we shall find that those who in Rev. 19:10 are said to have the testimony of Jesus, in Rev. 22:9 are called “thy [John’s] brethren the prophets,” in contradistinction from those who “keep the sayings of this book.” By observing these facts, three points are established. 1. It is one thing to be a prophet, and another thing to “keep the sayings” written by the prophets. There can be no doubt that John and the prophets kept the same things that his brethren kept, and yet the distinction between them was maintained. They after all belonged to two different orders of individuals, i. e., prophets, and keepers of the sayings of the prophets. 2. That we were right in arguing that in Rev. 19:10 the testimony of Jesus had reference to the spirit of prophecy, understood as meaning the Spirit of God, when bestowed for the purpose of producing spiritual gifts; since those who in Rev. 19:10 are said to have the testimony of Jesus, in Rev. 22:9 are called prophets, or individuals clothed with spiritual gifts or prophetic powers. 3. That having the declaration in Rev. 19:10 that the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy, is not, as claimed by our opponent, simply an emphatic way of declaring that the testimony of Jesus is prophetic in its character; it teaches something more than that. It teaches that it is something that makes prophets of the men who have it.
Should it be replied that our last position makes it necessary that all the men who have the testimony of Jesus should be prophets, it might be answered, that that term is evidently employed in two senses, a general and a specific sense. A man, in order to have the testimony of Jesus in the specific or technical sense, must be a prophet. When spoken of in a general sense, however, and applied to the remnant church, it may simply signify that they accept as genuine certain miraculous manifestations of the Spirit of God as existing among them. We have already cited the case of the church of Corinth. Beyond all dispute the Corinthian church is said to have had the testimony of Christ, yet no one will insist that every member of that church was endowed with miraculous gifts. As suggested above, they, as a church, had the gifts in a general way; while those who individually exercised them had, or possessed, them in that specific sense spoken of in Rev. 19:10, i. e., in a sense which demonstrated them to be prophets, or to be possessed individually of miraculous powers.
Here we must leave the subject. As we do so, it is with the feeling that our critic has done as well as perhaps any one could do, and yet has failed either to establish a sound theory of his own, or even to shake the one which he has so vigorously assaulted.