(Continued.)
PROPER METHOD OF CONDUCTING CHURCH TRIALS.—CONTINUED.
Our Saviour gives directions in regard to the settlement of difficulties between brethren as follows:—
1. “If thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone; if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.”
2. “If he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.”
3. “If he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church.”
4. “If he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.”
From the foregoing we learn that there are two things which should be done by any person who feels that he has been injured by a brother, before bringing the matter to the bar of the church.
First, he should go to the offending brother and tell him his fault when no other person is present.
Secondly, if he will not hear him, he should go to him again, taking one or two witnesses, so as to provide himself with the necessary proof in regard to the result of the interview.
Until both of these steps are taken, the offended brother has no right to burden the church with his personal troubles. The same authority which gave him the right to appeal to them under certain circumstances, imposed upon him the duty of endeavoring first, through an interview, to bring about a settlement of his difficulties with the individual who had injured him. In nine cases out of ten, church trials can be avoided altogether, when the steps prescribed by the Saviour are properly carried out.
Even where the offense committed by an individual is not a private but a public one (i. e., one which concerns the whole church and the cause of God generally), the person who is in the fault should be visited, and remonstrated with before charges are formally preferred against him. Such a course gives him an opportunity to explain away misapprehensions if such exist. If not, and if he is guilty, it opens the way for an appeal to him to humbly confess his fault before entering upon the trial.
Whenever it becomes apparent that a church trial is unavoidable, it should be entered upon with an earnest desire to do exact justice to all the parties concerned therein. However guilty an individual may be, he is entitled to a fair hearing, and an impartial verdict. To secure this end, the testimony of credible witnesses should be received, even though the witnesses themselves are not professors of religion.
The time for the trial should be definitely fixed upon, and the date at which, as well as the place where, it will take place, should be distinctly announced in the public congregation. A sufficient number of days should intervene between the public announcement of the trial and the time at which it is to occur, to enable all concerned to make the necessary preparations therefor.
The charges which are to be considered should be made out in writing, and handed to the one who is to be put on trial, on or before the time at which the public notice of the trial is given. They should be signed by the individual making the same.
The elder of the church usually presides at all church trials. In case there is no elder present, then it would be proper for the leader of the church to occupy the chair. In case neither the elder nor the leader be present, a temporary chairman should be elected, and the meeting adjourned to some specified future time. When, at length, the time for the trial is reached, and everything is in readiness to proceed, the meeting should be opened with singing and prayer. This done, the charges which have been brought against the party who is to be tried, should be distinctlyp. 522 read before the whole congregation. The officer in charge should then inquire of the person on trial, whether he admitted that he was guilty of the offense charged against him. Should he reply in the affirmative, then the church should determine just what he ought to do under the circumstances. If his reply is in the negative, then the person bringing the charge should be allowed to introduce the witnesses upon whom he relies to make out his case. When they have been heard, then the party charged with the wrong should be allowed to introduce the witnesses upon whom he relies for his defense. It is competent for the church to decide what witnesses and what evidence should or should not be received. They should seek, however, to obtain all the testimony necessary to a full understanding of the case. Technicalities ought to be waived, and the whole truth sought after. The trial from beginning to end should be characterized by a spirit of fairness and moderation. The presiding officer should at once rebuke everything like excited debate and personal abuse.
After the witnesses have been directly examined by the party who introduced them, the opposite party should have the right to cross-question them. When the evidence has been fully presented on both sides, all the parties to the case should be requested to retire from the room until the decision has been reached, as their presence might act as a restraint upon some of the members, causing them to vote differently from what they would under other circumstances. The case should at last be decided by a rising vote. A member can be expelled upon nothing short of a two-thirds’ vote of all the members present. The same rule applies when a member is placed under censure.
In church trials, there is no appeal from the decision of the church to which the parties concerned in the same belong. It is better that an individual should even suffer injustice occasionally than that the church should be kept in a state of ferment for years by the repeated examinations of the same case by different bodies of men. However, when a grievous wrong has been done to any person by the decision of any church, and he is able to make such appear to be the fact, he might lay the matter before the State Conference Committee. Should they become convinced that a new trial was unquestionably necessary, in order to do justice to the aggrieved party, they might be induced to use their official influence to secure a reopening of the case in the church where it was first tried.
When a person has been expelled from a church for a good cause, he can be received back again as a member of the same church whenever confidence in his integrity is so far restored that he can secure the unanimous vote of all the members present at the time when his application is considered. Such applications, however, should not be acted upon until the church have been fully notified of the time when action is to be taken in such cases.
When a person is simply placed under censure, his name remains on the church list, but he is denied the privileges of the church until such time as the censure shall be removed by a two-thirds’ vote of the church. Persons to whom the privileges of the church are denied, have no right to partake of the ordinances, or to vote in church meetings. Neither would it be proper for them to speak or pray in the ordinary services of the church unless they wish to say something by way of confessing their fault. The following will give something of an idea of the forms usually employed in expelling members or placing them under censure:—
“Whereas, A. B. has been proved guilty of ——; therefore—
“Resolved, That we hereby withdraw from him the hand of Christian fellowship.”
“Whereas, C. D. has been proved guilty of ——; therefore—
“Resolved, That we do hereby place him under the censure of this church until such time as he shall make satisfactory confession of his wrong.”
Persons cannot withdraw from the church at pleasure, neither can their names be dropped from the roll of church membership by the action of the church itself, when once those names have been properly placed thereon. There are but three methods by which individuals can become disconnected from a church. The first is by death, the second by letter, and the third by expulsion.
Whenever there is a strong probability that a proposed church trial will present points which it will be difficult to decide, or when the case is such as to render it certain that it will be necessary that the case should be managed with great care in order to prevent unhappy divisions in the church itself, it would be well for the latter to apply to the Conference Committee to send them some minister who is competent to give them the counsel which they need. W. H. L.
(To be continued.)