AdventAI

“Suppression” and “The Shut Door.”

By Joseph Harvey Waggoner

From Review and Herald, Supplement, Vol. 60, No. 33, August 14, 1883

BY ELD. J. H. WAGGONER.

I HAVE read the article written by Eld. A. C. Long on the subject of the “Early Writings of Mrs. White,” and feel inclined to give it some notice. He speaks in a confident manner, which, with some, may be considered evidence of the correctness of his position. But I do not look upon it in that light. Having been acquainted with these subjects many years, I am not prepared to assent to statements on the mere ground of plausibility. In most respects, Eld. Long’s professed argument lacks even plausibility.

At the very outset he makes an issue which has no foundation in fact, and draws his conclusions from certain assumptions, which, both assumptions and conclusions, are very far from the truth in the case. Thus in regard to an article in the REVIEW written by Bro. Butler, he says:—

“From the above quotations we gather the following points: 1. That these Early Writings of Mrs. White were published under her own eye, and with her approval; 2. That they contain all of her early visions; 3. That those who have claimed that certain portions of her visions were suppressed, are liars, since they are now all republished.”

Except the first statement that the book, Experience and Views, was published with the approval of Sister White, the paragraph above quoted is an entire deception. It was never claimed by anybody that these publications “contain all her early visions.” They who publish such an assertion know that there is not a word of truth in it. This very book lately republished speaks of a number of “early visions” which no printed publication ever contained. And her account of her early labors in “Spiritual Gifts” speaks of a large number of visions, some of which were given for her own instruction and encouragement; some for individuals or churches, which were written in part or in whole; and later, some were written and printed in slips or sheets for the benefit of those for whom they were given, or, if for general use at that time, the friends were so few that but few copies were required. These were not incorporated in “Experience and Views,” which has always, and very properly, been considered her earliest publication. A number of them were barely referred to, or particular points may have been dwelt upon in relating her experience and labors, but they were not comprised in what were termed her “Early Writings.”

It is not true that any part of her early visions or early writings have been “suppressed.” Some of her early visions were printed in whole or in part, as before said, in slips or sheets; but the number printed was small. Those interested were few, and not many copies were needed. But no effort was ever made to withhold them from any readers, or to withdraw them from their possessors. They were scattered as far as readers could be found, or their numbers would go, and no effort was made to restrict their circulation. Where, then, was the suppression? The fact that a publication, or any part of it, is not republished, is no evidence of intention to suppress it, as long as no effort is made to recover or to check the circulation and use of the copies issued. All this talk about “all her early visions,” and “suppression,” is evidently to give plausibility to his professed reasoning, and his conclusion as to the object of neglecting to republish them or parts of them. But neither his reasoning nor his conclusion is in accordance with the truth in the matter.

His (or more properly their) statement of the belief of the early Seventh-day Adventists, is not truthful. It was made to show that they had an object in not republishing certain things, and that that object was to hide from the public the fact that the visions at first taught certain doctrines which are not now held by those who believe the visions. Now if we shall prove that that is not so, and that their statements to that effect are also absolutely false, then there will remain no ground whatever for their accusations.

Eld. Long quotes from an address of a committee appointed to set forth the reasons why we should have Conferences and churches organized, as follows:—

“Our views of the work before us were mostly vague and indefinite, some still retaining the idea adopted by the body of Adventists in 1844, with Wm. Miller at their head, that our work for the world was finished, and that the message was confined to those of the original advent faith. So firmly was this believed, that one of our number was nearly refused the message, the individual presenting it having doubts of the possibility of his salvation because he was not in the ’44 move.”

Of this the editor of their paper says:—

“The people with whom she was connected, who afterward organized as Seventh-day Adventists, believed at that time that probation for sinners was past since 1844; and as Mrs. White always received ideas into her mind before she gave them out in vision, she believed this error too, and hence her language of the salvation of sinners being past, corresponded with her faith and that of her brethren. That this was the belief of the leaders of that people at that time, we have the statement in the REVIEW AND HERALD, Vol. 18, No. 3, June 11, 1861.”

The above is a gross perversion of the words of that address. We are not astonished that the editor made such remarks; for it is not the first time of his trying to make that appear to be true which he had no reason to believe was true, and even that which he knew was not true. Lest some reader should think this charge too severe, I will state a case.

Several years ago a letter appeared in the Advocate, signed by a person living in San Francisco, which contained something which was not true. We called the attention of the writer to the case, and he informed us that he never wrote the letter as published. Upon further investigation the editor of the paper had to confess that he made changes in the letter; and thus he made it read, not as it was written, not according to the truth in the case, but as he wished it were, or as he wished it to appear. This we exposed in the spring of 1877. Being forced to make such a confession would have been sufficiently humiliating to make him careful how he perverted anybody’s language thereafter, if the truth only were his object. But to take up and retail an evil report against their neighbor is the very life of that paper.

Now I assert with positiveness that such was not the belief of “the leaders,” nor of any leading or ministerial brother of the Seventh-day Adventists. If any should draw such an inference from the quotation, he would have the inference dispelled if he read the entire address. Speaking of the necessity of organization to correct wrongs and disorders in the churches, and the difficulties which we had experienced in this respect, the address said:—

“And when order was to some extent introduced, and wrongs corrected or separated from in compliance with gospel rules, some imagined that the introduction of order created the evils brought to light, instead of exposing and correcting wrongs already existing.”

There was no more reference to “the leaders” in the word “some” in the other paragraph than there was in this, and none at all in either. That language did not refer to any S. D. A. preacher, but to some who professed to be of us, and whom “the leaders” were at the very time trying to correct in regard to these things. At the time referred to in the address, the truth of the message was well formulated in the minds of the messengers. But because of limited ideas, not of the truth, but of the great work to be accomplished, many opposed organization, while others saw that it was the only means whereby we could keep our churches free from such fanaticism as was there referred to. As the work opened before us, and believers multiplied, the necessity of organization was felt more and more, and the language above quoted was used to impress this necessity upon the minds of all. To show that I have a right to be positive in my statement, I will now say that I wrote that address myself, and knew the person to whom

reference was made as having expressed his doubts, and also that I was the one of whose salvation the doubt was expressed, because I had no part in the advent work of 1844. But not one of the leaders or ministers ever expressed any doubt on the subject; on the contrary, they hailed my conversion to the message with joy, and received me cordially. And further, I afterward learned that Bro. White was laboring with this man in order to correct his errors at the very time of my introduction to him. But without organization, we had no means of holding such persons in check. This man, with all his vagaries, represented the S. D. A. cause to us in Wisconsin for a time; but he was never recognized by “the leaders” as a preacher, nor indorsed as a teacher among them.

It is easy to show that the construction put upon the faith of the Seventh-day Adventists on the subject of “the shut door” is entirely wrong. That the great body of Adventists with Mr. Miller did, for a short time after the disappointment of 1844, believe that “the world” had received its last warning, is true beyond all doubt. They could hardly think otherwise with their faith on “the judgment message.” But this idea was soon renounced, especially by two classes: one, composed of those who renounced the advent faith entirely, avowing their belief that the whole movement was fanatical and erroneous; the other, composed of a small company who saw that another message was to follow the judgment message of Rev. 14:6, 7, given in verses 9–12 of the same chapter, and represented also in Rev. 10:11, in which chapter (10) after the passing of the “time,” the church was to “prophesy again before many peoples, nations, tongues, and kings.” And it must be remembered that this vision in which it is claimed that she said the time for the salvation of sinners was (then) past, was given more than five years after that time, and when they had been laboring for years for all whom they could reach with the message.

But do not their writings of that time show that they believed in “the shut door?” We answer, In connection with an open door, Yes; in the sense in which their revilers use the phrase, No. The heading of that vision in which the (to them) objectionable expression is found is, “The Open and Shut Door.” Mark it; they believed in an open door as well as a shut door. One paragraph in that vision is as follows:—

“I saw that Jesus had shut the door of the holy place, and no man can open it; and that he had opened the door into the most holy, and no man can shut it; Rev. 3:7, 8; and that since Jesus has opened the door into the most holy place, which contains the ark, the commandments have been shining out to God’s people, and they are being tested on the Sabbath question.”

We find that in their writings of an early date they were careful to specify that they believed in “the open door;” and their labor for their fellow-men showed that they did believe a door was open where sinners might find the Saviour.

Of this I will now offer most conclusive proof, and show that their faith is either misunderstood or misrepresented by those who say they denied the salvation of sinners. No one was more outspoken in expressing his faith than Bro. Bates; no one more firmly believed in the shut door than he. I have before me the report of a meeting held in Vermont, signed Joseph Bates, dated Fairhaven, Nov. 4, 1850. In the last paragraph the report says:—

“The two Bro. Martins and their companions, with two others in Bennington, professed their clear convictions of the seventh-day Sabbath and shut door.”

This, then, was noted as an article of their faith as late as 1850. But now notice further. In this same report he says: “Brother and Sister Butler came from Waterbury with Bro. Chamberlain and Churchill.” And yet Bro. Churchill was not in the first message; his first advent experience was in the faith of the third angel’s message, the Sabbath, and the shut door!p. 2 It is also true that Bro. Churchill was held off for a time by some who were in doubt about his case, but Sister White had a message of hope for him, which silenced the objections of all who had confidence in the visions. Some were steeped in fanaticism, and rejected the visions, and of course they rejected him, but they were not the Seventh-day Adventists. Of course many embraced the Sabbath who were believers in that view, but the visions were the means of bringing them out to the faith of an open door as well as the shut door.

And again, in the sketch of Sister White’s life and labors, we find an account of a meeting which she attended in Carver, Mass., in 1846. There were two men convicted on the Sabbath question, who were not in the first message; for these also she had a comforting message of hope. These cases prove positively that she did not believe “the door of mercy” was shut against those who were not in the ’44 movement.

And still further. I have before me a statement written by Marion O. Truesdail (formerly Stowell), and signed by herself and five others, from which I copy the following words:—

“During Miss Harmon’s [now Mrs. White] visit to Paris, Me., in the summer of 1845, I stated to her the particulars of a dear friend of mine, whose father had prevented her attending our meetings; consequently, she had not rejected light. She smilingly replied, ‘God never has shown me that there is no salvation for such persons. It is those only who have had the light of truth presented to them, and knowingly rejected it.’ Miss Harmon’s reply coincided with my idea of a shut door, and in justice no other could be derived from it. It might be well for those who have so much fault to find to read the decisive answer given by Jesus against those ‘that were bidden to come,’ that refused. Luke 14:24.”

The writer of the above, and they who signed her statement with her, lived in Paris, Me., in 1844, and for about ten years thereafter, and she was intimately acquainted with Sister White and her early labors; and I am able to say that Bro. and Sister White were far in advance of the body of Seventh-day Adventists in regard to the nature and magnitude of our work, and the necessity of a perfect organization to carry the message to the world. I heard him introduce the idea of an organization at least five years before he could induce his brethren to take any step in that direction. Almost all Adventists, of all classes, were opposed to organization. Many of the S. D. Adventists were in doubt whether the “third angel’s message” would be given to any great extent outside of the United States. Even at the time when we organized, we had not the remotest idea that we should carry on such a systematic missionary work as we are carrying on at present, which is but a prelude to the work which is soon to follow. In this respect—and this relates to “our views of the work”—our views were indefinite. Why was it, then, that Bro. White had ideas of the work and its necessities so far in advance of those of his brethren? It was because he was so closely connected with the Testimonies, which were leading the workers, step by step, to larger views of our work; which had pointed out the necessity of thoroughly organized efforts to give the last message of warning to a perishing world. But the matter was delayed for years, until the body of the brethren also could see the necessity, and thus united action be insured. It is an evident truth that the vision which speaks of “their salvation,” given in 1849, is misapplied and perverted by our opposers.

I will now examine more particularly the supposed object of not republishing certain visions or parts of visions. They say “omitted or suppressed.” But these words do not signify the same thing. I have sufficiently noticed that there has been no suppression. It is easy to find a reason why many of her visions were not published. We believe it is left to the judgment of Sister White herself whether the circumstances and the nature of a vision demand its publication, where no specific direction or impression is given with it. Jeremiah put on record the words which he wrote to Jehoiakim; but the king burned the roll, and the prophet renewed the message to him, and “added besides unto them many like words.” But he did not put them in the book of his prophecy. Perhaps some of the princes who rejected the message turned round and accused him of “suppressing” part of the Lord’s testimony; but probably Jeremiah met the mind of the Lord in the matter. Paul said he had not shunned to declare the whole counsel of God to the brethren at Ephesus; but when he wrote to them, he wrote but a small part of the counsel of God. Was his failure to write it all to them, or to publish all the wonderful things which he received by “visions and revelations,” evidence that he intended to “suppress” a part of that which the Lord revealed to him?

Why certain parts of the vision published in the tract, “A Word to the Little Flock,” were omitted I am not able to say. I can see no object in their being omitted. And he who had sole charge of the publishing work for “the little flock” at that time is not living, so that if any reason existed, it will never be known. It is always right and just to inquire into a person’s motives for an action before we condemn him; if no reason can be given, or no motive proved, showing that there was a wrong intention in the action, that fact will go very far toward exonerating him from having any wrong motive. If anybody could show that there was any wrong intention, any evil motive, in omitting these lines, we would readily unite with those who condemned the action. We regret that it was done; but we see no possible reason for imputing wrong intention to the one who did it. Certainly Eld. Long has not given the true reason, and this I am able to show.

That Eld. Long has supposed an impossible object, and that he knew that his statement was unjust when he made it, I believe every candid person will admit when his professed reasoning is examined. The following is the principal omission, consisting of twenty-two lines:—

“And as we were gazing at the glories of the place, our eyes were attracted upward to something that had the appearance of silver. I asked Jesus to let me see what was within. In a moment we were winging our way upward, and entering in. Here we saw good old father Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Noah, Daniel, and many like them. And I saw a veil with a heavy fringe of silver and gold as a border on the bottom; it was very beautiful. I asked Jesus what was within the veil. He raised it with his right arm, and bade me take heed. I saw there a glorious ark, overlaid with pure gold, and it had a glorious border resembling Jesus’ crown; on it were two bright angels, whose wings were spread over the ark as they sat on each end, with their faces turned toward each other and looking downward. In the ark, beneath where the angels’ wings were spread, was a golden pot of manna, of a yellowish cast; and I saw a rod, which Jesus said was Aaron’s; I saw it bud, blossom, and bear fruit. And I saw two long golden rods, on which hung silver wires, and on the wires most glorious grapes; one cluster was more than a man here could carry. And I saw Jesus step up and take of the manna, almonds, grapes, and pomegranates, and bear them down to the city, and place them on the supper table. I stepped up to see how much was taken away, and there was just as much left; and we shouted Alleluia, Amen. We all descended from this place down to the city.”

Now notice Eld. Long’s conclusion, or the reason he assigns for this omission. He says:—

“We are again left to conjecture why these lines are omitted. It appears evident to my mind that at this early period she believed in the immortality of the human soul, and that the saints went to heaven at death, for she says that she saw Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Noah, Daniel, and many like them, in the heavenly Jerusalem above. As these had no resurrection, they must have ascended there at death. As she does not now believe in that doctrine, this portion of her vision had to be suppressed. That weak and childish expression of glorious grapes growing on silver wires, and these wires attached to golden rods, was doubtless sufficient to have it struck out also.”

This comment has not even the feeble claim of plausibility; more, it has not the merit of common honesty. If we cannot show that it is an inexcusable deception, we are willing to stand impeached.

1. The vision said nothing about grapes growing on silver wires. It describes what she saw within the veil of the sanctuary. She said she saw long golden rods on which hung, not grew, silver wires; and on the wires, glorious grapes. We here say that we have seen clusters of grapes hung on wires and hempen cords, and these again hung on rods of oak, in California. But Eld. Long must not tell that we have said that grapes grow on wires, and cords, and oak sticks in California, though he might with as much justice as he made the above declaration.

2. He says the scene of this vision is laid before the resurrection. This he says in order to make it appear that she believed in the immortality of the soul when the vision was given, and a change of faith made it necessary to “suppress” the vision. We have the testimony of those who were intimately acquainted with her at that time that she did not believe in the immortality of the soul. But such evidence is not necessary. The vision itself most clearly condemns the reason given by Eld. Long, and not only this, but it condemns Eld. Long in giving the reason. In the vision the resurrection precedes the lines omitted, upon which he makes that comment. In the third paragraph preceding the lines under consideration are found these words:—

“Then Jesus’ silver trumpet sounded, as he descended on the cloud, wrapped in flames of fire. He gazed on the graves of the sleeping saints, then raised his eyes and hands to heaven, and cried, Awake! Awake! Awake! ye that sleep in the dust, and arise! Then there was a mighty earthquake. The graves opened, and the dead came up, clothed with immortality. The 144,000 shouted, Alleluia! as they recognized their friends who had been torn from them by death, and in the same moment we were changed, and caught up together with them to meet the Lord in the air.”

Then follows their entrance into the city, and the omitted lines are a part of the description of things seen in the city. Any candid person who will read them in their connection must agree with us that there is no reason apparent for their omission; certainly no ill intention appears in their omission, for they teach nothing inconsistent with the rest of the vision, nor with the Scriptures. There is nothing in them to which an opponent can object, unless they are misrepresented, as Eld. Long misrepresents them.

To make this yet more apparent, we will specify in their order some of the things which the vision contains:—

a. The 144,000 were gathered out of the world, and sealed, and clothed with the glory of God.

b. They saw the sign of the Son of man, the cloud of glory on which the coming Saviour was seated.

c. The voice of Jesus raised the dead, as noticed in the quotation given above.

d. They all entered the cloud and ascended to the New Jerusalem.

e. The 144,000 stood apart from the others on the sea of glass.

f. She saw the ancient worthies,—Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, etc.

g. Jesus took of the fruits of the place and put them on the supper table.

h. They left the city and descended to the earth, and the mountain became a great plain under the feet of Jesus.

i. The city came down from heaven upon the earth.

Now what shall we think of Eld. Long’s statement that “these had no resurrection” at the time she saw them in the vision? He affirms that she thought they were there in December, 1844, when the vision was given! To make that appear consistent, he must affirm that she thought that in December, 1844, the 144,000 were gathered out and sealed; that Jesus had come on the white cloud; that his voice had raised the dead; that the living saints were changed; that they were together caught up in the clouds to meet the Lord; that they had ascended to the city; that they had seen the marriage supper prepared; that Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, etc., with the resurrected saints, were then in the city; and finally, that the New Jerusalem had descended from heaven to the earth! Did Eld. Long think that she believed all this had taken place when she had the vision?—No; he knew when he wrote that she did not believe that any of it had taken place when she had the vision. Why, then, did he declare that she saw Abraham and other ancient saints in heaven before the resurrection, when the vision says it was after the resurrection? I can imagine only one answer that can be given to this question, namely, because it suited his purpose.

Eld. Long is very sarcastic on Eld. Butler because of his incautious expression; but to make the worst that is possible of Eld. Butler’s expression, it still must pass for an honest mistake. No one can with reason say that Eld. Butler did not believe all that he intended to say in his article. But can the same be said for Eld. Long? The vision itself did not leave the resurrection in any doubt as to the fact or the chronology. It gave it ample prominence, and placed it before she saw the saints in the city. Had Eld. Long read the connection, so that he could understand it? In his tract, pp. 5, 6, he says:—

“I read down through seventy-two lines more, and find that the new book is a correct reprint of it so far. But here at the end of the seventy-second line there is another chasm, omission, or suppression of twenty-two lines.”p. 3

Thus it appears that he had carefully read the paragraph relating to the scene of the resurrection, and yet deliberately denied that there had been a resurrection when she saw the saints in heaven. The idea that she believed the ancient saints were in heaven in 1844 cannot possibly be gathered from the vision, but exactly the opposite. That idea could only originate in the mind of a person who was determined to oppose the visions, even though he had to manufacture reasons for his opposition, no matter how contrary to the words of the vision he made them appear, nor how plainly his statements concerning them were disproved by them.

I must further notice as briefly as possible the expression, “The time for their salvation is past.” And (1) I have sufficiently proved that the idea of “the shut door” believed in by Sister White, in connection with “an open door,” is not that claimed by her opposers; that she did not believe that the “door of mercy” was closed in 1844 against those who were not in the advent movement. Her teachings and her labors in 1849, when this vision was given, are a standing disproof of their assertion. (2) As in the case of the passage which I have quite fully examined, the chronology of which Eld. Long so inexcusably misrepresented, so in this, our opposers are greatly at fault in its application. That language was used in March, 1849, in a vision of the nature and future work of spiritualism. That work was then in its infancy, not at all popular, and few could have imagined that it would spread over all the world, and become the most popular theory of the age. In that vision she said:—

“I saw that the mysterious knocking in New York and other places, was the power of Satan, and that such things would be more and more common, clothed in a religious garb, so as to lull the deceived to more security.” “I saw that Satan was working through agents in a number of ways. He was at work through ministers who have rejected the truth, and are given over to strong delusions to believe a lie, that they might be damned. When they were preaching or praying, some would fall prostrate or helpless, not by the power of the Holy Ghost, but by the power of Satan breathed upon these agents, and through them to the people. While preaching, praying, or conversing, some professed Adventists who had rejected present truth used mesmerism to gain adherents, and the people would rejoice in this influence, for they thought it was the Holy Ghost.” “Some of these agents of Satan were affecting the bodies of some of the saints,—those whom they could not deceive and draw away by a Satanic influence. Oh, that all could get a view of it as God revealed it to me, that they might know more of the wiles of Satan, and be on their guard!” “I saw that the mysterious signs, and wonders, and false reformations, would increase and spread. The reformations that were shown me were not reformations from error to truth. My accompanying angel bade me look for the travail of soul for sinners as used to be. I looked, but could not see it; for the time for their salvation is past.”

In connection with this, read what was given in the following year, 1850:—

“I saw that soon it would be considered blasphemy to speak against the rappings, and that it would spread more and more; that Satan’s power would increase, and some of his devoted followers would have power to work miracles, and even to bring down fire from heaven in the sight of men.”

Now every one knows that very little of this is yet fulfilled. It has but just commenced to take its place as a religion. It is not considered blasphemy to speak against its power and miracles. But the way is well prepared for this to be fulfilled speedily. It is even now taking the garb of religion in order to deceive, but religious reformations under spiritualism have never yet been seen. They will be seen in connection with the closing scenes of this dispensation. Mark the connection in the vision,—“mysterious signs, and wonders, and false reformations,” “not reformations from error to truth.” It is to these reformations, carried on under the influence of the power of Satan as manifested in the signs and wonders of spiritualism, that the vision has reference, and not to reformations which took place years ago. I believe that the remarks of Eld. Smith in “Objections Considered” are just and true as far as they go, but they do not reach the full intent of this important vision, which I verily believe to be from Heaven, given for the “edification and comfort” of the little flock, and which we shall soon see literally and completely fulfilled.

Some years ago a writer in Marion, Iowa, objected to our faith on the two-horned beast, on the ground that, if we were right, spiritualism would have much to do in making the image, whereas this would be a religious movement, and spiritualism was altogether irreligious, and opposed to religion. But we believed it would change its position in that respect, and it is now fulfilling the prediction. A change has for some time been going on, and the following shows how far it has progressed.

The city authorities of San Francisco determined to make the mediums and clairvoyants in the city pay license fees, and they have resisted. In a recent trial of a clairvoyant the case turned on another point, so that the real question did not come to an issue; but the Chronicle’s report says:—

“Had not the case gone off on another point, the defense would have offered testimony showing that the spiritualistic fraternity and sisterhood are organized in a religious incorporation, which provides for the ordaining of mediums, who, it would have been claimed, hold in the spiritualistic faith and religion the same position as do priests and clergymen in other religious denominations. It had been intended to show also that the accused was such an ordained medium, and that clairvoyance was the greatest gift bestowed on mediums. It was to have been argued on this showing that until clergymen and priests were compelled to pay licenses, none could or should be collected from spiritualistic priestesses.”

This will yet come to a decision in the courts, and it is easy to see that it must soon turn in favor of spiritualism as a legally incorporated religion, with its regularly ordained mediums. With its millions of believers it must be popular as a religion; and there are a host of ministers, among them some of the most eminent in the land, who now occupy a position which would not only permit, but directly lead them to act as priests of the spiritualist church! Who, except one under the direction of the Spirit of God, would have predicted all this of spiritualism when it commenced in Western New York?

In the light of all this, the remarks of Eld. Long on page 5 of his little tract appear ridiculous. Concerning the opinion that the time for the salvation of sinners closed in 1844, he says:—

“Mrs. White believed this doctrine, and taught it in her visions; but since that time she has renounced that doctrine, and consequently those portions of her visions that taught it are now suppressed and denied.”

But we have proved that she did not believe it nor teach it in her visions; and the paragraph on which they principally depend for proof against her on this point, stands, as it always has stood, in “Experience and Views,” and was recently republished in Battle Creek, Mich., and Oakland, Cal. What are Eld. Long’s statements worth, in the light of these facts?

We fully believe that “the present truth,” the true advent message, is now, and has been for years, testing the world. While we do not believe that they who keep Sunday now receive “the mark of the beast” in fulfillment of Rev. 13, we do believe that the great majority of those who have heard this truth and seen the light, by willfully rejecting it have taken a position to effectually shut themselves out of the kingdom; that they are in the sight of God where they are placed in the parable of the invitation to the supper made for the marriage of the king’s son—they are rejected. Because they refused the message, it was said of them, “Not one of them shall taste of my supper.” But others are still being called. So it was in the parable, so it is now. The view she had of “the travels of the Advent people to the holy city,” in the narrow path above the world, is fulfilled only in small part. Many below that path have refused the message which the Lord in mercy sent to them, and are rejected. Before the message closes, most of the world will occupy that position; and all the world, except those on the narrow path, will be rejected before Christ comes, for every case will be decided before the advent. The vision embraces the whole journey, even to the coming of the Saviour.

The fault of our opposers on all these visions is in claiming a complete fulfillment of them years ago, while no reasonable construction will admit of their being applied to the past, except in a small part. In the longest omission we have clearly shown that Eld. Long did, in a most inexcusable manner, misrepresent the vision by laying the scene of its fulfillment before the resurrection, when the vision says it was after the resurrection. Eld. Long could be more successful in charging that John believed in the immortality of the soul, because he saw the saints in glory in A. D. 96!

In regard to “the number of the beast,” the objection is sufficiently answered in the book by Bro. Smith. I will not take upon myself to affirm that it is fully understood. As Bro. Smith intimates, there would be no incongruity in giving a number to both the beast and his image; on the contrary, there would seem to be a fitness in it. And he prudently says: “Doubtless more light will be given on this point as we approach the time of its fulfillment.” I say “prudently,” for the Lord has specially pointed to this subject as one requiring much wisdom. Dr. Clarke treated it as a point to be most easily and certainly established; more so than any other in the book. But the Lord said: “Here is wisdom. Let him that hath understanding count the number of the beast.” It may be that it is now understood, and that the numerical value of the letters of the pope’s title give the correct solution. Dr. Clarke finds the same number in the alphabetical value of the letters in “the Latin kingdom,” in Greek. This he considered “a demonstration.” It may be a mere coincidence. We feel the utmost confidence in the correctness of the vision, and we believe that time will vindicate it.

And we believe that all her exhortations and statements in regard to the shortness of time are worthy of all acceptation. Peter exhorts the servants of the Lord to “hasten the coming of the day of God.” To the careless reader his language may appear strange; it evidently appeared obscure to the English translators, and therefore they made it actually obscure by a needless and erroneous addition. God has a specified work for this message to do. If the Advent people, numbering between 50,000 and 100,000 in 1844, had been true to their trust, and to the profession of their faith, and received the third angel’s message just as it stands in the prophecy, immediately following the judgment-hour message which they had given, the world would have been warned in a very short time, and the “nations, and people, and tongues” of the earth would have been moved as with a mighty whirlwind. The work of the message would have been done in a short time. “Time should have closed years ago, and would, if the body of Adventists in 1844 had stood true to their trust.” A full understanding and appreciation of this text in 2 Peter 3 must cause every heart to feel sad over the backslidings of God’s people, to whom he committed the light. We are not surprised that God has spoken to them in visions, and warned them faithfully. And when people set themselves against the Heaven-given message of Rev. 14:9–12, and the Testimonies of the Holy Spirit, we are not surprised that they find, greatly to their own satisfaction, a few apparent contradictions in the Testimonies. Infidels are using the Bible just so, and with equal success. And I believe the result will be the same to the two classes.