Early Writings” and “Suppression

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 14, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Supplement, Vol. 60, No. 33

Read the full edition

“Early Writings” and “Suppression.”

BY ELD. G. I. BUTLER.
Last fall a volume entitled the “Early Writings of Mrs. E. G. White” was issued from the press, and a large number of copies have been sold. It was a book much desired by our people; for it contained nearly all of her earliest published writings, many of which had been out of print for more than twenty years. In noticing this book in the Review of Dec. 26, 1882, the writer, among other statements, made the following concerning “Experience and Views,” and “Supplement to Experience and Views,” which formed an important part of this volume:—
“These were the very first of the published writings of Sister White. Since they went out of print, many thousands have become interested in her writings. Many of these have greatly desired to have in their possession all she has written for publication. Efforts in all directions have been made to hunt up the little volume in question, and worn copies here and there have been obtained, and held with great care. So strong was the interest to have these early writings reproduced, that several years ago the General Conference recommended by vote that they be republished. The volume under consideration is the result of this interest. It meets a want long felt.”
I give this somewhat lengthy extract because a few of our people have become somewhat confused over a slight inaccuracy in it, as a little company at Marion, Ia., who have been for seventeen years past our bitterest enemies, have issued a little tract written by A. C. Long, and have scattered it widely throughout the country among our people, in which, by a process of reasoning peculiar to that class, they have tried to make it appear that somebody has been very wicked, and that Sister White’s visions have been “suppressed.”
There is but one inaccuracy in that article, and that is found in this clause: “These were the very first of the published writings of Sister White.” This statement is not strictly true, though we supposed it was at the time we wrote it. We had never seen any earlier published writings of hers, and others of long experience thought the same as we did. But since writing to Bro. Andrews, and talking with others longer in the truth, we have found that we were mistaken. We have never claimed to be infallible, and often find, like other mortals, that we make mistakes, and hope ever to be willing to acknowledge them when we know them to be such. But we want the reader distinctly to notice that we did not claim that Early Writings contained “all her early visions,” as Mr. Long tries to make us say. This we have never said. We did suppose, however, at the time, that “Experience and Views,” and the “Supplement” to the same, contained her earliest “published writings,” but were mistaken. There is quite a difference between this and what Mr. Long undertakes to make me say, that the book in question contains “all her early writings.” I stated in that article that many of our people “desired to have in their possession all she had written,” and that this republication of “Experience and Views” and “Supplement” was undertaken because of this desire, but did not say this comprehended all she had written in the early part of this work, or that they were “all now republished,” as he says. He picks out a sentence here and there from my article, and groups them together, and tries to make it appear that I said this, and then tries to prove that I am a liar in doing so. He tries to put me in a position I never took, and then proceeds to demolish it. This is a favorite style of argument with this class; but it amounts to nothing, only to show the character of the men who use it.
We will now briefly explain the manner of publishing some of the earlier visions of Mrs. White, as we have been able to ascertain the facts from Bro. Andrews and some others early in the faith. Her first vision, given in 1844, was first published in the Day Star (a first-day Adventist paper) in 1846, and then in the tract “Word to the Little Flock,” by Eld. White, in 1847. Another vision, given in Topsham, Me., in 1847, was written by her to Eld. Joseph Bates, who had it published in this same tract, as we have stated in the article headed, “A Venerable Document.” We are told by brethren who have long been in the truth, that from time to time “Views” were published in sheets for the benefit of those who desired to obtain them. Whether or not these are all obtainable now, we cannot tell. At the time, they were read with much interest by the early believers, who considered them a great source of comfort. In this tract, page 21, Bro. Bates makes this remark: “It is now about two years since I first saw the author, and heard her relate the substance of her visions as she has since published them in Portland (April 6, 1846).” This shows there were some of them published very early. These were read by the believers, and no doubt kept as something valuable by a few of the most careful. But nearly forty years have passed, and great changes have occurred, and no one can say that “all these early writings” can be found.
In 1851 the little work, “Experience and Views,” was published, and in 1853, the Supplement to it. In this first work, her first vision, as published in “Word to the Little Flock,” is nearly all repeated. The same is true of the one given at Topsham, Me., in 1847. There are a few passages, not specially important, left out. The same is also true, I think, of one or two other visions published by themselves, and largely republished in “Experience and Views” or “Supplement.” There is no claim whatever in either of these little works that all her views were contained in them which had been previously published in “Word to the Little Flock” or elsewhere.
In a very few years after these works were published they went out of print; that is, the edition was all sold out. Back before 1860, when I had become interested in these questions, I could not obtain a copy till I accidentally found one in a chamber among some old books. I have kept it and prized it highly ever since. Many others wished to obtain them, but could not find them.
The number of Sabbath-keepers was rapidly increasing; and other and larger works were written by Sister White; such as the “Great Controversy,” “Facts of Faith,” her life and experience, called “Vol. 2, Spiritual Gifts,” the small volumes of the “Testimonies to the Church,” now 31 in number, and also volumes of the “Spirit of Prophecy.” These first mentioned contained some of her earlier visions condensed, the most important passages being retained, and others not republished. We make these brief statements of facts for the benefit of those who have embraced the truth at a comparatively recent date; our older brethren know them to be true as well as the writer.
The first we ever heard of this howl of “suppression” was back in 1866, when Snook and Brinkerhoff got out a little pamphlet against the visions, full of gall and bitterness. This was followed in 1870 by another slippery document from the pen of H. E. Carver. Our people and the visions have survived both of these attacks, and still prosper. And now comes Mr. Long’s poor imitation of both of these men; and after examining the three together, we cannot see that he has a single new idea which they did not have. But having obtained two very zealous recruits in the persons of “Prof. McLearn,” and Mr. Green, “the eminent lawyer,” as they call him, we hear a great noise about “suppression” once more. The sound is very familiar to those of us who have lived in Iowa. When Mr. Long’s tract appeared last spring, we did not see anything in it worth noticing; but on attending the Western camp-meetings, we find that great efforts have been made to circulate it in almost every church, and a few brethren, comparatively young in the faith, have been troubled on some of these points. We make these statements for their benefit.
And right here we will state a few facts to show the candor (?) of these Marion, Ia., people concerning this “suppression” cry. In Snook and Brinkerhoff’s work, published in 1866, and in Carver’s, published in 1870, which were circulated as leading works by this party, a great deal of effort was made to show that our people were deceptive, and that we were unwilling to have the people know what the visions taught, and therefore suppressed “Experience and Views,” because of what it said on the “shut-door” question. In the first of these works, after quoting from “Experience and Views,” on page 6 this language occurs: “Why is all this suppressed? and why does it not appear in any work now for sale at their office?” And on the same page another statement of similar import is made. In Carver’s book, on page 60, similar statements are made. It is well known that this has been one of their main points with which to throw doubt on the visions, that we did not republish “Experience and Views;” “we had become ashamed of it;” “we dare not publish it,” etc., etc.
But after a while, when the demand of our people for it became strong enough, a large edition was published, and Mr. Long himself admits that it was published entire as printed in 1851 and 1853. Our people were strongly urged to buy it, and many thousands of copies have been sold. This is the way we showed we were ashamed of it. It has been read with deep interest, and we have never heard of a single person who lost any faith in the visions because of reading it.
But now comes out this last tract of Long’s on “suppression,” published at first in the Advocate, the organ of this Marion party. Is there one word of admission or confession that they were incorrect in their charges concerning the “suppression” of “Experience and Views?”—Not a word. They are not candid enough to admit it. And yet the republication and circulation of that work by us proves beyond all controversy that their charges of our suppression of it, because we feared to let the people know what it said about the “shut door,” were utterly false.
Again, we have just republished all the visions of Sister White contained in the “Word to the Little Flock,” as stated in the article entitled “A Venerable Document.” It can now be obtained at the Review Office, singly or by the quantity. It appears just as originally published, with a very few grammatical corrections. All that want this little tract can now get it. Mr. Long has laboriously tried to show some great wickedness on our part, because a few passages in it were not placed in “Experience and Views,” when published in 1851. We have, he says, “suppressed fifty-nine lines” of Mrs. White’s writings. But here are these visions about which they have raised such a howl for nearly twenty years past, published entire as in “Word to the Little Flock,” and all who want to obtain them are invited to send for them freely, and see what terrible things they contain. And now, after all of these charges, which events have shown to be false, will they make any admission that they were wrong, and that their charges were unjust? We have no expectation of it. They have never in the past been known to be candid enough to do such a thing.
Another circumstance will perhaps bring out this point in a clear light. About ten years ago, soon after the iniquity of the notorious Nathan Fuller had become known to us, and he had been published through our paper, and had been kicked out of our denomination, he turned up in Marion, Ia., and was received there as a great acquisition, and made much of, as most any one is who has once been a Seventh-day Adventist, if he will talk against the visions. When I learned of this, knowing what sort of a person he was, I wrote an article for the Review, telling some of the awful facts concerning him. H. E. Carver, the editor of the Advocate, their church organ, devoted several columns to my special benefit, in which he denounced me in the most terrible terms, and said I was “worse than a murderer” or a thief, and accused me of “bearing false witness,” etc., etc. But after some time they found the said Fuller to be a bad man, and then they could not carry him. Quite a number of their more respectable members were very much dissatisfied, and the present editor of the Advocate left their office, and went to work in another office, and they found they were getting into serious trouble among themselves over his case; so their church appointed a committee to ask of me facts with which to try Fuller. Of course I gave them the desired facts, and they soon got rid of him. But from that day to this I have never known of a single sentence in the Advocate making any apology for their false and cruel charges against me; and years after, when I saw Mr. Carver in Marion, and asked him if he did not believe my statements concerning Fuller were all true, he admitted that he did, and that he owed me an apology. I told him then and there that justice required a confession through their paper just as broad as those charges had been made; but I have never known of a sentence of the kind being published. How can we expect any Christian candor from those who pursue such a course?
Perhaps there never was a more unjust charge made than this, that we have “suppressed” the visions, because there were some portions of them of which we were ashamed. Mr. Long thinks he has found “fifty-nine lines” which we have “suppressed.” From a rough estimate, we judge there are at least 150,000 lines extant of her different published works. Surely, according to his own statement, it is but a very small proportion of her writings we were ashamed of,—fifty-nine lines out of 150,000. But now nearly all of these fifty-nine lines are published, and accessible, and all who want them are invited to obtain them. And if there are any of the works he speaks of, as the one entitled “The Sealing,” which we have not published, it is solely because we do not possess a copy to print from. If he will send it to us, we will publish that if it is genuine. What becomes, then, at last, of this wonderful cry of “suppression,” about which these people have been making so much fuss for nearly twenty years? It has dwindled down to a point too small to be seen with the naked eye. It was always utterly false, and now the facts have demonstrated it too clearly to be misunderstood. We say again, as we said in the article published last December, “These lying insinuations have answered their purpose in deceiving some unwary souls. They now appear in their real character by the publication of the very passages they claim we ‘suppressed.’ There is nothing in any of these passages which he quotes that we should have any desire to conceal, or that is difficult to explain. In many of her published writings which are obtainable at any time, there are passages far more difficult; yet they are published by the thousand copies.”
These men complain, on the one hand, that we make the visions too prominent, exalt them too highly, think too much of them, and test every one by them (which is false); and then, on the other hand, claim that we “suppress” them, are ashamed of them, and will not keep them where they can be obtained, etc., etc. Surely they are very hard to please. Their main stock in trade is to find fault, and to accuse the brethren, showing themselves to be in close sympathy with him who is called the “Accuser of the brethren.”
We are free to admit that during the history of this cause there have been instances, more or less numerous, where omissions have been made in republishing some of Mrs. White’s visions, but never from such motives as have been attributed to us; for there were none of these omitted passages which contained a single sentiment we were ashamed of, or that taught a doctrine which was contrary to our belief as a people, or a sentiment that was immoral. But in those visions which had been published it was thought some passages were personal, or related to matters which at the time of their publication were important, but had now become unimportant because of an entire change of circumstances, or for some similar reason. Hence it was not thought these were of sufficient importance to demand their republication, and some omissions were made.
If any one will take the trouble to examine Vol. 4 of “Spiritual Gifts,” he will find a synopsis of the “Testimonies to the Church,” arranged in this way, with a large number of personal testimonies left out, and various passages omitted. These were published under the eye of Bro. White himself; but it would be perfectly foolish to charge him with a design to “suppress” any portion of the Testimonies, because of these omissions, when there were thousands of copies of them in the hands of our people, and many still for sale at the Office. Yet one would have just as much right to make such a claim as our opponents have to put forth the one they have been making so persistently for many years past. There were many reasons which Bro. White could and did assign why it was not necessary that all these personal testimonies should be republished after many of the persons involved were dead, or had repented of their sins. These reasons had weight; yet we all know Bro. White stood up as staunchly for the Testimonies as any of us. But others thought (and the writer was one who felt very strenuous on this point) that it would be far better to have them all accessible just as originally published; and all the volumes of the “Testimonies to the Church” are now being republished. What a cry of suppression we should have had, if some of these volumes could not be obtained! We want them all, because we believe they contain precious light from the Lord, and every one of them contains most profitable instruction. We trust there will never be occasion to say more concerning this foolish and wicked charge of “suppression.”