HOW THEY ARE HELD AMONG S. D. ADVENTISTS.
BY ELD. G. I. BUTLER.
“QUENCH not the Spirit. Despise not prophesyings. Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” 1 Thess. 5:19–21. This scripture is specially applicable to the last days, as the connection unmistakably shows. The apostle had been speaking of the “Lord descending with a shout,” the “dead in Christ” rising first, the living being caught up together with them to “meet the Lord in the air.” He tells us that when these things are about to transpire, an unbelieving world will be saying, “Peace and safety,” and will be overtaken “as a thief.” “But ye, brethren, are not in darkness, that that day should overtake you as a thief,” etc. Then certain practical instructions are given, which are specially important at this time, and then the words of this text occur. How applicable the words, “Quench not the Spirit,” to this age when the “form of godliness prevails,” and the “power thereof” is lacking; when the mass of professors of religion know nothing by experimental knowledge of the influence of the Spirit on their hearts; and denominations of Christians, so-called, can be found who teach that there is no Spirit in the world to affect the hearts of men, save in the “word alone”?
“Prophesyings.” Mr. Webster defines it to be “the exercise of the gift of prophecy.” “If there be a prophet among you, I the Lord will make myself known unto him in a vision, and will speak unto him in a dream.” Num. 12:6. When the Spirit of God takes complete possession of a person’s mind in his waking hours, and reveals that which he could not know by means of the ordinary mental processes of thought and experience, it is a vision; when this is done in the sleeping hours, as in the case of Nebuchadnezzar and others, it is a dream. Visions were common in those days when God’s Spirit was with his people, and through them light has been given to the world. Much of the Bible was given through vision. Abraham had visions. Gen. 15:1. The word of the Lord came through vision. 2 Sam. 7:4, 11; Ps. 89:19. The light the prophets received, which enabled them to give us a knowledge of divine things, came the same way. Isa. 1:1; Eze. 1:1; Dan. 1:17; Nahum 1:1.
The Lord used the same method of giving light in the new dispensation. Luke 1:22; Acts 10:3, 10, 17; 2 Cor. 12:1, 7; Rev. 9:17. Indeed, this has been the ordinary, if not the exclusive manner by which God has imparted special light to mankind, and in ancient times it was thought to be a great calamity to be deprived of this precious blessing. Prov. 29:18; 1 Sam. 3:1; Micah 3:6.
But now we have reached a different age, when prophesyings are despised. There is nothing now that will bring a stare of astonishment, a sneer, and a curl of the lip, and cause one to be more the object of contempt, than to know that he believes that the Lord is again honoring his people with visions. It is just such an age as makes especially forcible and important the apostle’s caution, “Despise not prophesyings.” “The exercise of the gift of prophecy” can be nothing else than having visions from the Lord; for “if there be a prophet among you, I the Lord will make myself known unto him in a vision,” saith the Lord.
The last or “remnant” church are to have this gift. Rev. 12:17. “The testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” Rev. 19:10. The spirit of prophecy is that manifestation of the gifts of the Spirit which enables one to prophesy, or if you please, have visions; for if there is a prophet among God’s people, he will reveal himself through visions. Be it known to every reader of this Supplement, yea, to all who care to know it, that S. D. Adventists, as a body, firmly believe that there has been connected with this people, through their whole history, one who has visions from the Lord. If this be a disgrace, let our enemies make the most of it. We feel that it is a high honor. We would not deny it if we could, and we could not if we would. It has been recognized by the General Conference of our people, the highest authority among us, in resolutions many and strong, and the same has been done over and over in all our State Conferences which have been organized any length of time. We have been despised by many for this, and have had opprobrium and derision heaped upon us because of it. Misrepresentation and lies have been poured upon us for this reason; but we understand it all very well. We are living in an age when the people “despise prophesyings;” but we propose to heed the apostolic caution to despise them not, but to accept those which give satisfactory evidence of genuineness, as a distinguished honor from God.
We shall not here enter into an argument on the perpetuity of spiritual gifts. Our people are so familiar with it that it is wholly unnecessary to do so. The argument is so plain that even our enemies do not often undertake to deny its correctness. The gifts of the Spirit are promised to the church of God till the end of the dispensation; and one of these gifts is prophesying (1 Cor. 12:10, 28), or, if you please, having visions. And this gift, we have seen, is to be in the last church, among those who keep the commandments of God. We hope all will read again the article from Eld. Littlejohn, recently published in the REVIEW, which settles that point beyond successful contradiction. Either this gift is among us, or we are not the “remnant” church spoken of in the last verse of Rev. 12. If that church has not yet appeared, then we have not reached the last generation of men, and the coming of the Lord is not very near. The question, therefore, becomes to us one of vital interest, and it is no wonder our enemies are making such furious efforts to break down faith in this gift. They are sharp enough to see how much depends upon this position. This also accounts for the well-known fact that when persons have wholly lost faith in the manifestation of this gift among us, they have very soon lost their faith in other special subjects, such as the messages, the sanctuary, the work of the two-horned beast, and other views held by us. Our position on the Testimonies is like the keystone to the arch. Take that out, and there is no logical stopping-place till all the special truths of the message are gone. Our enemies, and the master they serve, realize this; but some of us do, having seen these things developed over and over again during the history of this work.
We firmly believe the visions of Mrs. White are a genuine manifestation of spiritual gifts. They bear every test the Bible gives to distinguish between true and spurious manifestations. They speak according to the “law and the testimony.” Isa. 8:20. Mahomet, Swedenborg, Ann Lee, Jo. Smith, and a host of spiritualists, do not thus speak. They proclaim that “Jesus Christ has come in the flesh” (1 John 4:1–3), and exalt him as man’s Saviour, who died for our sins, and who now pleads his blood in our behalf; and declare him to be our only hope of salvation, and hence they “are of God.” A host of spiritualist mediums do not, and hence we know they are not of God.
The fruits borne by these visions, are good, and hence the tree which bears them is good. Matt. 7:15–20. They teach truth and purity, and lead to the love of God, and the study of his word. Mahometanism, Mormonism, spiritualism, and a host besides which claim to be genuine manifestations, do not. We will not stop here to enter into the details of their history, but we know we speak the truth. The fruits of these visions are certainly manifest, after our experience with them of nearly forty years; and we unhesitatingly declare their fruits to be good. Every one who obeys them is made better by so doing. Not one immoral sentiment is taught by them. Our enemies, with all their bitterness, have never been able to show that they contain a single one. B. F. Snook, after he left us, and did his utmost against them, going from church to church in Iowa to break down confidence in them, when pressed by the question, “If a man will live out the ‘Testimonies,’ will he not be saved?” was compelled to answer that “he would.” An admission from such an enemy, under such circumstances, carries with it strong weight in favor of their excellence.
We know very well that some claim that their fruits are not good, because they say divisions are caused by them, and those who are reproved by them sometimes give up the truth. We admit that these results sometimes follow. But the same argument would condemn even Christ himself. His reproofs caused some to be mad against him, and he said himself, “Think not that I am come to send peace on earth; I came not to send peace, but a sword. For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother, and the daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; and a man’s foes shall be they of his own household.” Matt. 10:34, 35. The truth of God ever causes a division between those who love it, and those who do not. The human heart never loves reproof; but the word teaches the necessity of it all the same. The trouble with the Testimonies is mainly because they are too straight for the carnal heart, and reprove selfishness, covetousness, and various sins, and show men to be wrong when they thought they were right. The human heart never likes this; and rather than yield their opinion, some will turn around to find fault with the reprover. This is no evidence that the Testimonies are wrong, and that their fruits are not good; but it is very strong proof of their heavenly origin.
The blessings to this cause from its connection with the visions, have been many and great. When this movement commenced in weakness and obscurity about thirty-five years ago, the Adventist body, about 50,000 strong, were making a stir in the world, and looked down upon this movement, and the visions connected with it, with contempt and derision. But how changed the circumstances! They have split up into sects, divisions, schisms, and factions; and none of them have enough coherence to keep up an effective organization. They are not really exerting one-tenth of the influence in the world at the present time that they were then. They have fallen to pieces almost like a rope of sand. This despised movement, with those much-hated visions in the forefront, has constantly gained strength, and has never before exerted the influence in the world that it is exerting at the present time. It is doing fifty-fold more to circulate the light of the precious truths connected with the Advent message than all the other Adventist bodies in our land put together.
It commenced in poverty and weakness, and was most unpopular with the world and the first-day Adventist believers themselves. It gathered of all classes and sects, and of different nationalities, and welded them together into one body, with a thorough organization. It is moving onward, increasing its extent and influence, and reaching out its arms to every civilized nation, till they almost encircle the globe. The light of the third angel’s message is spreading as never before. Never were its prospects of ultimate success as bright as to-day.
To what do we owe this union and strength? We answer: To the influence of these despised visions more than to anything else but the word of God. They have always been held in high esteem by the most zealous and humble among our people. They have exerted a leading influence among us from the start. They have first called attention to every important move we have made in advance. Our publishing work, the health and temperance movement, the College, and the cause of advanced education, the missionary enterprise, and many other important points, have owed their efficiency largely to this influence. We have found in ap. 12 long, varied, and in some instances, sad experience, the value of their counsel. When we have heeded them, we have prospered; when we have slighted them, we have suffered a great loss. Many instances of this kind could be given from our past history. As a people, we have no reason to boast of our faithfulness to them. On the contrary, we have shown much of unbelief and indifference to their teachings. But when we have regarded them most highly, we have enjoyed the greatest prosperity. It is clear to every one who has closely noticed the workings of this cause that in those Conferences where these Testimonies are most highly regarded, there the greatest degree of prosperity is seen; and in those where they are least respected, there the work drags heavily.
The same is true of individuals. We have never known a person to meet with much success in preaching this truth, who had little or no faith in the visions. And those ministers who are most successful in accomplishing real good, and truly build up the cause, are always those who have strong faith in them. And there is still another evidence in the individual experience of persons. We have had instances of ministers who for a period met with great success in their labors, and then finally lost a large part of that success, and seemed to accomplish very little. In every such case, success attended their labors when they had faith in the visions, and their lack of it came when they did not have such faith. These facts have become well known among us. All these things clearly prove them to be an essential part of the work itself.
The same lesson has been often taught by offshoots from our people, who made the visions a pretext for withdrawal from us. Bro. Waggoner has mentioned the old Messenger movement. Its leaders thought they could do great things if they could get rid of the visions; but they made a miserable failure. It was the same in Iowa. On my way to that important meeting at Pilot Grove, Ia., in 1865, after Snook and Brinkerhoff had withdrawn from the body, and had taken nearly one-third of the Sabbath-keepers of the State with them, I met Eld. Snook in Marion. He was full of fight, and was going to accomplish great things. He had his arguments all prepared against the visions. I said to him, “If you give up the visions, you will soon give up the messages, and other truths.” “Oh, no,” said he; “if we can get rid of the visions, we shall soon have the loud cry of the message. The visions are what stand in the way, and hinder the progress of the work.” What was the result? In a short time, Elds. S. and B. had given up the messages, the sanctuary, the Sabbath, and all, and become Universalists. A little remnant there have been living out a lingering existence for seventeen years, and in their “Extra” just issued, the editor of the Advocate says, “It is more strange that we have been able to maintain our position, than that we have not built up a larger interest.” Why, how is this? We thought if they could only get rid of those terrible visions, the truth would go wonderfully! Yet after trying it seventeen years, the editor is astonished that they have stood through the struggle at all; while we have been growing all the time, with this terrible “incubus,” as they call the visions, and without them, they have hardly been able to maintain an existence, according to their own confession. They have the Sabbath truth, and the light on the state of the dead, and the Lord’s coming, and other truths which the people accept most readily; but they make no progress.
Our S. D. Baptist brethren also greatly commiserate us because of the visions; yet they have a large amount of wealth, an educated and talented ministry, and stand as a very respectable people before the world, and are not disgraced by visions. How is it that they are practically making no advancement or increase with such great advantages? We leave them to answer. Well, we are thankful that with all our unworthiness, the Lord mercifully gives us light from heaven. We prosper when we follow it, for then God blesses us.
But it is said that we have lost many of our “leading ministers, such as B. F. Snook, W. H. Brinkerhoff, Moses Hull, M. E. Cornell,” and they might have added, H. C. Blanchard, E. W. Shortridge, and others, because of the visions. Well, most of these did leave us, and with some, if not all, the visions were the pretext. We have no knowledge whatever but that Bro. Cornell is still in full faith a S. D. Adventist, but the rest have gone, our enemies say, because of the visions. Well, suppose that to be so, for the argument’s sake; how much did they gain by doing so? These men were at one time laboring in the cause, and bringing souls to the truth, and seemed to be men who feared God and loved his truth. They became opposed to the visions, our opponents say, and for this reason left us. Moses Hull went into the blackness and darkness of atheism, and sank so low in filth that even the spiritualists will hardly own him. Elds. Snook and Brinkerhoff went over into Universalism, gave up the Sabbath of the Lord, and renounced the truth. H. C. Blanchard gave up preaching, and hardly kept the Sabbath the last we heard of him. Shortridge went into spiritualism and immortality, and others have also gone far from God and truth who have pursued the same course. Does giving up the visions seem to improve men spiritually, make them more devoted, give them more love for Christ and their fellow-men, lead them to be more conscientious and sacrificing,—more like Christ? These examples fail to show it. The truth is, there never was a case among us of a man who became more devoted by giving up the visions, but thousands have increased in devotion by accepting them, and will thank God for the light and spiritual strength they have received thereby.
We might increase these reflections to almost any length. Nothing is surer than this, that this message and the visions belong together, and stand or fall together. This has been the case from the commencement, and will be to the end. Thirty-five years of experience ought to teach us something. From the commencement, the visions have exerted a leading influence in the work in every important movement. It is folly to call this message the special work of God, and that leading influence which has molded it, the work of a deceiver or of the devil. God does not enter into such partnerships. I can easily see how a person who has no faith in the movement we are engaged in can cast aside the visions, but can see no reason or good sense in one’s doing so who believes the message to be of God.
The majority of our people believe these visions to be a genuine manifestation of spiritual gifts, and as such to be entitled to respect. We do not hold them to be superior to the Bible, or in one sense equal to it. The Scriptures are our rule to test everything by, the visions as well as all other things. That rule, therefore, is of the highest authority; the standard is higher than the thing tested by it. If the Bible should show the visions were not in harmony with it, the Bible would stand, and the visions would be given up. This shows plainly that we hold the Bible the highest, our enemies to the contrary, notwithstanding. We believe them, because the Bible teaches that such manifestations will be seen in the last church, because every rule given in the Bible to test spiritual manifestations by proves them to be genuine, and because in all our experience we have found them to be of great value to us in every important point in our history. When we have Scripture and uniform experience in their favor, we have a strong case.
But when we have demonstrated them to be of God, then we claim that they should be respected, and their instruction should be regarded. We can see no consistency in persons’ claiming to believe them of divine origin, and then paying no respect to their teaching. These instructions come to us in several different ways,—sometimes in books and pamphlets designed for general circulation, sometimes in special Testimonies designed for some particular church, sometimes privately to individuals. There are obvious reasons why this should be so. General instruction is needed, which all require. Sometimes there are local circumstances which it would not be proper to publish to the world, also personal reproofs for personal sins. All reasonable persons can see that there would be no propriety in making such things public.
Our enemies, in their desperate efforts to prove that we suppress the visions, try to make it appear that we do so because these special Testimonies to churches or individuals are not published everywhere. They show their lack of candor and their malice by so doing. They might just as well say that there was suppression, because every private letter was not published in the daily papers. Any reasonable person will admit that if the Lord gives special light to any one, that person is as likely to know how it should be communicated as those who do not have it, or those who hate it.
Our enemies try very hard to make it appear that we make the visions a test of fellowship. They must know themselves that this charge is false. Our leading men have never done this, and the visions themselves teach that it should not be done. It would be most absurd and impossible to do so, even if we would do it. With people in all parts of the world embracing our views who never saw Sister White or heard of her, how could we make them a test of fellowship? By their own admissions, our opponents have shown that we do not do so. They claim that there are many among us who do not believe the visions. This is true; yet these are in our churches, and are not disfellowshipped. They have claimed in this “Extra” that Elds. Smith, Canright, and Gage did not believe the visions; yet all of them are members of our churches, two of them hold credentials as ministers, and one of them holds very important offices. Why will men talk so foolishly and unreasonably as to even show they are not consistent in their own statements? Hatred blinds the mind, and destroys their good sense. No; we do not make the visions a test, and never have. But we do claim the right to believe them, to talk about them freely, and to read them in private and in public, and shall no doubt continue to exercise that right, regardless of the spite of those who hate us.
But we close this lengthy article. For our part, we thank God for light and truth in these last days, which comes from the throne above. We love and prize it, and hope it may ever continue to shine, till this dark world of sin is passed, and we enter the haven of rest.