As our readers are aware, we frequently receive manuscripts which we do not deem it for the interest of the Review to publish. The matter is most commonly of such a nature that we can give the reason for declining it in few words; and when this is the case we do so under the heading, “To Correspondents,” not as a matter of obligation, but of courtesy to the contributor. There are cases when it would impose too much of a task to do this. The general principle governing such matters, is so well set forth in an article which we find in the Christian Advocate, that we lay it before the reader as follows:—
“The following letter has reached this office, and it is a specimen of many others which from time to time appear:—
“EDITOR OF THE CHRISTIAN ADVOCATE, Dear Sir: I send you the following article for acceptance or rejection. If you reject it, I shall expect you to state your reasons.
“Yours truly, —— ——.
“We rejected the article and sent it back without any statement of reason, and received a reply in substance as follows:—
“I received my article by this evening’s mail. It is a great deal better than much that you publish; in fact, as good, at least, as much that appears editorially. I informed you that I expected you to state your reasons, if you rejected the article. You have not done so, and I now ask upon what principle of justice or courtesy you can refuse so reasonable a request.
“To this second letter we made no reply, and never shall. As to going into an argument with a contributor on the merits of his piece, one might as well go into an argument with a woman as to the beauty and accomplishments of her child. The judge would be against him in every case. A statement lately appeared in the New Jersey Mirror, one of the oldest and best-edited of our exchanges, which clearly sets forth the correct view of the subject, and the last sentence will receive the unqualified indorsement of every editor, religious and secular, in the United States:—
“AN UNWRITTEN LAW.—It is an unwritten law, well understood in journalism, that no editor is under the slightest obligation to give a reason for his acceptance or non-acceptance of a manuscript. He is not called upon to write a private critique on the article to the author of it. His acceptance or rejection is an absolute and unquestionable fact. Among amateur writers this does not seem to be understood. All sub-editors and reporters understand that it is an unjustifiable impertinence to ask the managing editor his reason for not publishing any matter submitted to his judgment. Outside writers and aspiring amateurs rarely seem to comprehend this truth, and their transgressions are largely from ignorance rather than inattention. The nature of editorial work requires absolute power of decision in order to preserve the unities of the journal the editor conducts.
“We do not hold ourselves obliged even to return rejected manuscripts which we have not asked for, but are in the habit of doing so, and shall continue so to do when requested, with a degree of promptitude in proportion to the time at our disposal after doing the necessary work required by the duties of the office. Send in what you would like to have published. In every case it will be read, and if suitable from our point of view—which takes in the contents of all preceding copies of the paper, and those which are to come as far as they are arranged, and all the matter in our hands, and all which we have reason to expect—it will be used. If not, it cannot be used, and we recognize the right of no person to demand, though we may often be willing to give without a demand, a reason for the non-use.
“Let no one misunderstand the meaning or misconceive the spirit of the foregoing remarks. We would be glad to publish everything sent to us, and decline to use in any case with regret; but a demand that reasons shall be given for declining must arise either from presumption or ignorance. If from ignorance it needs enlightenment, but if from presumption it should receive the justice of rebuke or the mercy of silence, according to the circumstances.”