AdventAI

THE EFFECT OF REPROOF UPON ST. PETER.

By John Nevins Andrews

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 36., September 4, 1883

When the apostle Paul wrote to the Galatians, it was necessary, in consequence of the calumnies of his adversaries, that he should mention the fault which the apostle Peter had committed at Antioch, and also to declare that he had publicly reproved him for this fault. Gal. 2:11-14. His fault was that of dissembling, from lack of moral courage. When Peter arrived at Antioch, he ate with the Gentiles. But soon after, when certain persons arrived from Jerusalem, where such an act was held to be sinful, he refused to eat with the Gentiles, hoping that it might appear that he had never thus eaten at Antioch.

For this fault Paul gave him reproof in the presence of all the parties at Antioch who were interested in the case. How did Peter take this humiliating and painful reproof? Did he become angry, and attempt to retaliate by saying hard things to Paul? We know how we are inclined to speak and act when we are reproved. We immediately recite the faults of the one who has reproved us, and we attempt to show that he had no cause to say that we had done wrong. If St. Peter had acted thus he would have said: “Paul, you are quite out of place in speaking in this manner to me. I am the chief of the twelve apostles, while you are not even numbered with the twelve. I have been with Christ from the beginning, but during several of the first years of my toil in the apostleship, you were a cruel persecutor and a blasphemer.” If St. Peter had spoken in this manner, his second fault would have been vastly greater than the first, for the reproof was just and necessary.

It is a remarkable fact that the first epistle of Peter was addressed to the Galatians, the very persons to whom Paul wrote of the fault of Peter and of the reproof which he gave him for that fault. 1 Pet. 1:1. It is also worthy of notice that his second epistle was written to the same persons as the first (2 Pet. 3:1), and that when he wrote his second epistle to the Galatians, he had already seen and read the epistle of Paul to the Galatians in which Paul mentions and condemns the fault of Peter. 2 Peter 3:15, 16. Now we shall see whether it was sin or grace that reigned in the heart of Peter. It certainly was not pleasant to read of his fault in this epistle, so many years after he had committed it. Does Peter show resentment toward Paul? Far from it. He even calls him “our beloved brother Paul,” and he places the epistles of Paul in the rank of the inspired Scriptures, though one of those epistles would perpetuate the knowledge of this fault of Peter to the latest generation. Would we have borne reproof like this, or would we havep. 569 become angry, and spoken words of bitterness in retaliation? J. N. A.