A CONVERSATION ON PORK, TEA, AND COFFEE.
By N. J. Bowers
A. Does not Paul speak of some who in “the latter times” shall depart from the faith, and give heed to “doctrines of devils,” and who shall command to “abstain from meats?” I Tim. 4:1–5. How can you show that these words do not apply to your church? B. 1. We do not command anybody to abstain from eating meat. We try to persuade the people by instructing them that some kinds of animal food, especially pork, are not healthy, and advise them not to use it. This is as far as we go. Many physicians do the same. 2. The words are not, commanding to abstain from swine’s flesh, but from certain kinds of food not named. 3. This forbidding of meats is associated with the “doctrines of devils.” The Lord told his people to abstain from swine’s flesh (Deut. 14:8). Are the Lord’s doctrine and the doctrines of devils all one? Are light and darkness the same? 4. Those who command to abstain from meats, forbid to marry. This we do not do. 5. Those who put forth the doctrines mentioned are hypocritical liars, and conscience-hardened reprobates. Our worst enemies will hardly say this of us. 6. The meats prohibited are such that “God hath created to be received with thanksgiving of them which believe and know the truth.” We read that in the beginning God created the heaven and earth, man and his food. What was his food? Let me read Gen. 1:29: “And God said, Behold I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat.” This is the meat, or food, the Lord created for man. We think a fruit and vegetable diet is best, and recommend it. I suppose our people, as a rule, eat less meat than any body of Christians in the world. The diet of our father Adam was fruits and grains, and we know it is the best because the Lord gave him this and no other. Science, also, proves it best. Meat-eating seems to be one of the consequences of the fall. 7. The food specified was “created to be received with thanksgiving.” Did any holy man or woman in the Bible ever give thanks over a hog? We know the Lord blessed a few small fishes and some loaves of bread, but these were neither slices of bacon nor greasy sausage. Did the Lord create the hog to be received with thanksgiving by anybody? He told his people it was an abomination and unclean, and they must not eat it. Let the shoe of this prophecy be worn where it fits. It does not apply to our foot. A. I am pretty well convinced you are about right on the pork question, at least. There is one more thing the apostle says, and that is, “Every creature of God is good and nothing to be refused.” How about this? B. You did not quote it all. I will finish, “If it be received with thanksgiving.” A proviso, you see. Its goodness and its not being refused depend on conditions which are that it “be received with thanksgiving: for it is sanctified by the word of God and prayer.” (Ver. 5.) Here is the key. It is good if we can receive it with thanksgiving. This depends on whether the word of God has sanctified or appointed it for the use of “them which believe and know the truth.” The word of the living God must first set it apart for us, then we can receive it with prayer and thanksgiving. So the apostle’s “every creature” is limited to that which God has appointed for our use. He has not sanctified the hog for us; on the contrary, he calls it “abominable,” and the last time he speaks of it he says he will consume those who shall be found eating its flesh when he comes with fire and chariots like a whirlwind “to rebuke with flames of fire.” Isa. 66:15–17. But then, if nothing—in the broad sense—is to be refused, we are bound to eat everything, and the Bible says in another place “whatsoever is set before you, eat, asking no question for conscience sake.” Jesus said, “Take heed how ye hear.” Let us also take heed how we read. Let us apply the words of the Bible where they belong. A. Well, now about tea and coffee. These beverages are not hurtful, especially when taken in moderation. I do not think a cup of tea or coffee will hurt any one. B. I may grant that a single cup of tea or coffee will injure no one, as you say. So a single glass of grog might not. But the drinking of it daily will. It is the many cups drunk for years that do the mischief. If you will drink but one and then stop forever, I do not think you will suffer much damage. A. Tea and coffee are not like alcohol, intoxicating in their effects. They gently stimulate, only. B. If they stimulate they intoxicate. If they gently stimulate, they gently intoxicate. Tea and coffee do intoxicate. Dr. Smith of England, when making some experiments with strong coffee, fell to the floor insensible. He was intoxicated. His assistant was served in the same way. They had been drinking the coffee very strong to notice its effects. Dr. Cole, also of England, speaks of several persons who were found unconscious from drinking tea. He mentions a man of literary habits who was discovered in this condition two or three times a week. I am told there are real tea drunkards in England, and I suppose they are to be found elsewhere. A person can get drunk on any kind of stimulant, and he is drunk more or less, according to the amount taken. Dr. Arlidge, another English physician, tells us that many of the women among the working people in his country use tea to such an extent that they greatly suffer from its narcotic poisonous effects. Tea and coffee, though they but gently stimulate, do it at the expense of the vital powers. Now, what is a stimulant? Let Dr. Billing in his “Principles of Medicine” tell us: “Tonics give strength; stimulants call it forth. Stimulants excite action, but action is not strength. On the contrary, overaction increases exhaustion.” Dr. Smith, mentioned before, says that exercise taken while under the stimulation of tea is succeeded by reaction with a sense of exhaustion.” So, if tea and coffee gently stimulate, they gently abstract the strength and exhaust the natural powers of the system. Truly, they must be wily and to-be-dreaded foes to go about their work in so gentle and pleasing a manner. Again, tea is greatly adulterated. Gen. Stahl, U. S. Consul at Hiogo, Japan, in his official report to our government, says artificial coloring is given to teas by the use of indigo and gypsum. The Hiogo News, of July 20, 1881, speaking of tea adulteration says: “But there is doctoring and doctoring. Analysis of eleven samples of Japan teas made last year in San Francisco, showed that four contained Russian blue (ferro-cyanide of iron), five, plumbago (black lead), and the remaining two, simply indigo and gypsum.” Who wants to drink plaster of paris, indigo, black lead, and something worse than copperas?