THE GOD OF THE BIBLE AND THE “GOD OF NATURE.”
By A. W. Barton
We have now to determine whether we have a communication possessing the tests we demand. If we look, we shall find several compilations of moral requirements, religious teachings, exactions, etc., as the Shaster, the Vedas, the Koran, and the Bible. These are the codes of moral and religious jurisprudence among pagan, civilized, and enlightened nations, respectively. The skeptic would ask us to devote but little time to the first three named or others of their character, because he knows that they no more meet his demands of what a God of love and justice would require than they do ours; and they are evidently not the authorized will of a sovereign Creator whose purpose is good, and who requires good. We must, perforce, look among those peoples whose intelligence, government, institutions, and aims,—in fine, whose sum of good,—are superior to all other existing peoples, for that divine code which we seek; for if one has been given, the highest embodiment of good among nations must reflect its teachings and character. Then, among nations of such characteristics, we find the Bible accepted as the divine will to man. The best examples of political and religious jurisprudence are based upon it. Its title gives it what it should have the right to claim,—The Book, if such it is. It is professedly a revelation of the Supreme Being to man, and treats of his will and requirements, and man's nature and destiny. Its Author asserts at the beginning that it was he who created the heavens and the earth, and all things therein. He requires righteousness (Gen. 4:7-10), and condemns evil. Deut. 25:16. He has also given a law concerning both. Ex. 20. He declares himself the author of that law (Ex. 20:1), and sets forth the nature of good and evil. Ex. 11:18, 19; 14:32. He grants life to the good (Prov. 12:28), but condemns the wicked. Ex. 23:7; Job. 36:6. Thus we have found that all the evidences which a divine revelation to man should contain to prove that it was indeed divinely given, are found in the Bible. We treat of general evidence, only; hence, we shall assume that the Bible is the revealed will of God to his rational subjects, and shall not offer further proof,—historical, archæological, or otherwise,—than we have sought and found to accord with our demand and the nature of things. The objection first considered is usually the first given against the God of the Scriptures. The skeptic always has the Bible here, as his handiest weapon; but in the second objection, he has compelled us, and with some trouble, to look for it in that place where he says it ought to be, and where he might have found it himself had he tried. Having found and brought it to him, he makes us reason a little for him, and deduce a conclusion from given premises. “Will a God of mercy and justice, like the God of Nature,” he says, “purposely destroy a part of men, and save another part? I don't believe it.” In the first place, the character of good and evil must be determined. It is possible that justice and mercy are dependent upon these diverse qualities. How can either be said to exist, and be exercised, unless such existence, and exercise be necessary? There can be no demand without necessity, and if all attain to God's requirements of good, the terms mercy and justice become obsolete in meaning. It is obvious, then, that the difference between good and evil makes necessary the exercise of these attributes of God, and also the manner of their manifestation. The principle of good, exercised, must result in further good. It is impossible that it could do otherwise; for since God's purposes are for general good, and he requires good of all men, or obedience to his law, it follows that it cannot be subject to loss; for from its nature it preserves itself, and lives for the further exercise of itself. A man, then, by embodying in himself good, and exercising the requirements of God, secures to himself life through the nature of righteousness. Man thus fulfills the object of his creation,—to obey and live; for obedience secures the favor of God, and in the favor of God is life. Ps. 30:5. So life becomes the inalienable inheritance of the righteous, and it is impossible, in the purpose of God, that it can be taken from them. We come now to consider if the nature of evil can result in life. If it does, then God would seem to work at cross purposes with himself; for if good, or favor, gives life, evil, or condemnation, should give death. Evil is defined as “having qualities which tend to injury,” “producing mischief.” It thus opposes and destroys the good, and this is evidently why it calls forth the condemnation of God. Its tendency is to subvert the sole purpose of his government, and is in both purpose and agency the highest treason. It violates the law of good, and consequently opposes the Law-giver and injures the interests of the body politic. It everywhere and in everything produces effects opposite to those produced by good, and so works mischief and disorder. Evil, which is in its nature destructive of everything that was designed for good, involves in ruin the agency of its manifestations; and man, created to promote good, becomes, as an agent of evil, subject to its destructive tendency. We see that its purpose is to destroy, in order that good shall not be performed; and its instrumentality in man is only perpetuated by the reproduction of new agencies, created by God to serve his own purposes of good. It only exists by negation. It is conceived in hate, and brings forth in death. God owes it nothing. The skeptic knows that the God of the Bible requires obedience to a law that is just and good. It is in harmony with his idea of a God. The principles of right and justice set forth in that law cannot be exchanged for others, for it is impossible that others can exist. Will our friend now claim that the violator of this law, or he who becomes the agent of evil in opposition to the principles of good enjoined by the law of God, can in justice receive life, the result of righteousness? There is no room for justice, love, or mercy in the case. God is not indebted to the evil-doer or sinner because he has created him. On the contrary, the sinner is indebted to God, in that he has been created, and has the inestimable privilege of securing eternal life by fulfilling the purpose of his creation. If he does not do this, he becomes the instrument of his own destruction. God does not destroy him; but through the nature of evil he comes to death, and in death receives justice, which constitutes punishment. God will not raise him to life again for the purpose of giving him another trial. There is no reason for demanding it, and besides, he would be as likely to sin again, with the same nature. If God should restore him sinless, it would not in fact be the restoration of the one who died by his sin, but a new and special creation of God, which would not answer the demand in question. Therefore, eternal life or eternal death is the inevitable result of living for God or living against him. Justice requires both conditions; for with only one, there could not be the exercise of justice. Justice gives to a man what belongs to him, or what he has earned; and it can give nothing more. Mercy is defined as “a disposition to overlook injuries, an inclination to forego justice, to remit penalty.” It must be admitted that man is more or less a partaker of evil by nature. It is obvious, if not admitted. As evil, or sin, must occur in life, so mercy, or forgiveness, can only be granted during the lifetime of the recipient, or while he is able, or has a disposition to do the will of God. The terms are imperative, and limited by the nature of things. God cannot alter them, and be consistent with his general purpose; for if he forgives the incorrigibly wicked, the necessity of good is no longer of superior importance, and the great purpose for which it was ordained is weakened. Sin would serve as effectually for man's righteousness as the doing of the will of God; and finally we should be led to the conclusion that God has no will at all respecting man, but eternal life or death for all. Having found that obedience to God results in the bestowal of mercy or the forgoing of penalty, it follows that a continuance in sin results in application of penalty, or the effect of sin itself, and, as we have seen, in the infliction of justice. Mercy cannot exist without a condition; hence, those who do the will of God and live for his pleasure, receive both mercy and justice; but the disobedient, justice only, which is the naturally acquired penalty of evil. This conclusion is in harmony with the words of the Bible. Num. 14:18; Prov. 28:12. We have now found that the administration of mercy and justice as declared in the Bible, and at which the skeptic takes exception, is the inevitable result of the nature of things; that it is by the principle of good only that life is possible; that it is only to those who turn from the evil and serve the good that mercy can be granted; and by this act alone is the attribute of mercy called into existence and exercise. God will not create from the realms of evil and death sinless creatures for his purposes; but he will call them from the ranks of living men whom he has already created to serve him; and he chooses those who, like himself, love the good and hate the evil. God has now no use for those who have perished in the evil of their ways. There can be no more remembrance of them. Having reasoned with our unbelieving friend upon the basis of our common requirement of God, and his own discernment of man's nature and capacities, and found that our conclusions harmonize with the Bible declarations regarding God's requirements, and man's nature and destiny,—let us ask him how he will prepare a case for himself in order to secure a hearing in the court of Heaven on the plea of mercy and justice. We leave this question wholly to his consideration; for, having treated him thus far as an intelligent entity only, we will see that now, in pleading for results or conditions, the opposites of those that belong to the nature of evil, he becomes an abettor of evil and arrays himself against the purposes of God. His influence partakes of the nature of that evil which he deprecates. As the greater includes the less, so must all minor objections which are opposed to the God of the Bible be disposed of according to the relative effect of good and evil, and the determination of God to make a way for the good. Has he not a right to dispose of his own, when it is in the way of his purposes?644 Most assuredly; and when he destroys the wicked for that object, we have learned by this time that it is the best use he can make of them; and when he does this, he is meting out justice. A few questions in conclusion. How is the “God of Nature,” or any other imaginary deity, proved to be more merciful or more just and impartial than the God of the Bible? There are evidently none of these attributes manifested in the earthquake, the cyclone, the flood, or the conflagration. All are unsparing, cruel, resulting in nothing but suffering and death, and the anguish of stricken hearts. Will you boast of the mercy of such a God as this, or curse him for his acts? Yet you blame the God of the Scriptures for having, in the interest of good, exercised his prerogative, and destroyed in certain places those peoples that opposed his righteous designs. Certainly, if justification be considered, the act of God in the latter case is the more pardonable, and the numbers so destroyed, insignificant, when compared with the loss of human life by natural forces. Besides, mercy would have been granted to these guilty people, had they been disposed to accept its terms; but they were incorrigibly wicked and obstinate. Does the “God of Nature” offer inviting terms of mercy? Never, in the sense that the skeptic regards him. But the God of the Bible does, and ere the visitations of war, pestilence, famine, or any destructive agency, all have had ample time to turn to his commands. To this end was man created. The requirement is given and earnest entreaty accompanies it. Our God says, “Why will ye die?” So, when the day of disaster comes, the ungodly are without excuse as regards time, opportunity, invitation, or the reasonableness of the divine requirement. Further, how does he who worships the “God of Nature” convince himself that any worship is required? How is this worship authoritatively announced? Of what character is it, and where is it directed,—toward nature as a whole, or some peculiar manifestation of nature? As the “God of Nature” does not define any religious duty, manner of worship, or what he is or where he is, men would here differ, and be their own arbiters, as their individual impulses or tastes inspired them; and the result would be “gods many,” eventually developing into a pagan polytheism, “with self-taught rites and under various names, female and male,—Pomona, Pales, Pan, Flora, and Vertumnus; peopling earth with tutelary goddesses and gods.” Having found that the “God of Nature” is, in every sense which the devotee required of him at the beginning, no God at all, in that he is without sentience, makes known no law for man's government, defines no duty, teaches no morality, shows no mercy or justice,—no anything but the blind forces which combine matter into organized forms and produce all the phenomena known as nature,—it follows that a Being who does possess and exhibit these requirements must be the true ideal God for whom we are seeking. As none but the God of the Bible has revealed in him all the required characteristics, hence, he is God, and the Bible is the revelation of his purposes, his law, and his nature. From this source alone do we find the God who manifests and declares his sovereignty,—“I have made the earth, and created man upon it.” Isa. 45:12. “For thus saith the Lord that created the heavens: God himself that formed the earth and made it; he hath established it, he created it not in vain, he formed it to be inhabited. I am the Lord; and there is none else, I have not spoken in secret, in a dark place of the earth.... I the Lord speak righteousness, I declare things that are right.” Isa. 45:18, 19. This God dispenses mercy and eternal life to all that do his just will. Read Eze. 18:21-23. He guides man to every duty. Man is alone without him. The God of the Bible removes every need of any other “God of nature” but his own. See Deut. 10:12, and onward. It is he that turneth the wise men backward, and maketh their knowledge foolishness.” Let us escape the imprecation, “Woe unto him that striveth with his Maker.” Isa. 45:9.