AdventAI

MILLER'S MISTAKE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 41., October 16, 1883

Eld. J. B. Goodrich has been giving lectures on the views of S. D. Adventists, in Worcester, Mass. In one lecture he took occasion to explain the mistake made by Wm. Miller and others in 1844. Light on the subject of the heavenly sanctuary has made it exceedingly plain that the mistake was not in the time but in the event to occur at that point. The Worcester Evening Gazette of Sept. 18, gave a synopsis of this discourse, which the World's Crisis of Oct. 3 copies, and to which its Corresponding Editor offers a reply.

The writer of the reply seems to be laboring under the impression that it is one of the easiest things in the world to demolish Seventh day Adventism, and that he is doing it. Two or three specimens of his assertions and his manner of procedure, will be all-sufficient for our readers. He represents us as claiming that the seventy weeks extend to, and end at, the crucifixion of Christ; whereas any one who knows anything of our views knows that we place the termination of the seventy weeks three and a half years this side the crucifixion of Christ, inasmuch as Christ by his crucifixion caused the sacrifice and oblation to cease in the midst or middle of the last or seventieth week.

Again, he represents us as placing the crucifixion of Christ in A. D. 34. But none of our preachers have ever made such an assertion, nor have any of our books ever so published it. For the past thirty-five, and more, years, our uniform and invariable teaching has been that Christ was crucified in the spring of A. D. 31. A person who has so slightly or so carelessly examined our position is poorly qualified to act the part of a reviewer.

This assumption, that we place the crucifixion in A. D. 34, affords him a good deal of capital. He says:— “The Seventh-day people now insist that the 2300 days ended in the autumn of 1844, and this places the crucifixion in the spring of A. D. 34, in which year the Passover fell on Tuesday, and Christ was certainly crucified at the time of the Passover in whatever year he died; so as truly as Sabbatarians are correct in ending the 2300 days in 1844, so surely Christ died on Tuesday, and there is no way of escaping the conclusion.”

Ah! indeed! Yes, there is—a very easy way of avoiding that conclusion. If the writer will correct his own unaccountable blunder, his man of straw will instantly vanish, and he will have no occasion to make such an assertion. For in the spring of A. D. 31, the Passover did not fall on Tuesday, and the seventy weeks did not end till the autumn of A. D. 34.

Again he says:— “The effort to make it appear that there was need of a cleansing work in Heaven by quoting Heb. 9:23, is a failure. While the text reads, ‘It was therefore necessary that the patterns of things in the heavens should be purified with these; but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these,’ the word ‘purified’ here means, as in the 18th verse, ‘dedicated.’”

How correct and profound this criticism is, may be seen from two facts: 1. The word rendered “dedicated,” in verse 18, is ἐγκαινίζω (engainizo), and is defined, “To imitate, i. e., to dedicate, to consecrate,”—Robinson. 2. The word rendered “purified,” in verse 23, is καθαρίζω (katharizo), and is defined, “1. To make clean, to cleanse. 2. Tropically, To cleanse in a moral sense, i. e., a) From sin or pollution, by expiation, to purify, Heb. 9:22, 23. b) Genr. and without expiation, to cleanse, to purify, to free from moral uncleanness. 3. In the Levitical sense, to cleanse, to make lawful.”

The words are not the same, are not used interchangeably, and do not mean the same thing; and the work they bring to view was not the same work, nor a work performed for the same object.

Another declaration is about parallel to the foregoing: “When under the law blood was applied to inanimate things, it was for their dedication, and not to remove pollution.”

According to Lev. 16, the mercy-seat, the most holy of the tabernacle, the altar of incense, and the first apartment, had blood applied to them every year, to say nothing of other objects, like the altar before the door, which had blood sprinkled upon it every day. The theory under review would have us believe that these things were continually re-dedicated but never cleansed! The chaos which must reign in any mind which can so teach on this subject we leave the reader to fathom if he can.

He thinks our view fails because the sanctuary has been trodden down just as much since 1844, as previous to that time. Here again he entirely misapprehends the subject. The question, How long shall it be trodden under foot? was not directly answered. The answer puts us upon the period of its cleansing which began at the end of the days in 1844; and when this cleansing is finished, the treading under foot both of the sanctuary and its minister, the Lord Jesus Christ, will be brought to a very decisive and effectual close.

This editor of the Crisis teaches, in short, that this earth is the antitype of the first apartment of the sanctuary; that Heaven is the antitype of the most holy place; that the sky is the curtain, or vail, between them; that Christ, the antitype of the high priest, entered Heaven, the most holy place, and began his ministry there, over 1800 years ago; and that the “antitypical minor priests,” by which he means the ministers of the gospel, officiate here on the earth, in the first apartment.

In this view there is an impossibility and absurdity yoked together like an ox and an ass, which was under the law forbidden. If Christ began his ministry in the most holy place 1800 years ago, there has been, according to this view, no ministration (or work of the gospel) here on the earth, or first apartment; for when the high priest was in the most holy, there could be no man (no ministration) in the first apartment or holy place. Lev. 16:17. This is the impossibility. The absurdity is that this view makes the lower orders of Jewish priests types of the ministers of the gospel in this dispensation, or, which is the same thing, the ministers of the gospel are the antitypes of those ancient Jewish priests. Wonder if Mr. S. is not the antitype of Nadab or Abihu. He is just about wild and reckless enough to occupy that position.

Speaking of Mr. Miller, he says: “He also began to reckon from the 7th of Ezra.” He might as well have said, “from the 3d of Job.” He probably meant “from the 7th of Artaxerxes Longimanus, which is mentioned in the 7th of Ezra;” and then in reference to the date of the 7th year of Artaxerxes, he says, “which incorrect chronology sets down as 457 B. C.” But this date has the authority of the best and most reliable authorities on the subject of chronology the world has ever seen. Yet Mr. S. sets these all aside with as much nonchalance as if they were the merest tyros.

Prophecy assures us that we are now in the “patience of the saints.” Yet we confess that nothing so severely tries our patience as the effrontery of such assertions. When we look at such teaching, if it is put forth with becoming modesty and offered as something sincerely believed and honestly taught, it excites only one emotion—that of pity that any one should be so unfortunate in his powers of comprehension; but when it is accompanied with impertinent assurance, the most audacious and groundless assumption, and what to a disinterested beholder looks verily like inordinate self-conceit, another emotion is excited; and then just where the pity should end and the contempt begin, it is not easy to determine.