To the Editor of the Review and Herald: When I wrote the article for the Supplement, I thought I should pay no further attention to the Advocate or its correspondents. But an article in the number of Sept. 24, by Gilbert Cranmer, ought to be noticed, for the reason that it misrepresents a meeting held in Battle Creek, in which his case as a minister was considered; and the time was so long ago that the circumstances cannot be remembered by a large number, and therefore there is great liability of many being deceived by his statements.
He affirms that objection was made on two points to his preaching among us. 1. Because of his differing with us on our views of Christ’s work in the Sanctuary. 2. Because of his rejecting the visions. Now, I have a very distinct recollection of that meeting, as have some others who are still living. I have had occasion to meet his misrepresentations on that subject, both in Michigan and in New England, as have others. I assert that the decision in his examination turned upon neither of the points which he has brought up in his article. The point, and the only point, upon which he was rejected as a preacher among us, was that he used tobacco, which he knew the ministers among us were not permitted to use, and that he had practiced deception, by professing to the brethren that he had quit the use of tobacco, when he had not. Brethren were present who testified directly on these points, and the evidence was so clear and decisive that he made no defense; no effort to shield himself from the force of the proof offered.
These facts were very strongly fixed on my mind at the time, and still more by my having to meet his mis-statements in different places while the circumstances were yet fresh in the minds of all who attended that meeting. Having been exposed in his deception there, we hoped that he would reform; but his recent article in the Advocate shows that he is engaged in the same work still.
Oakland, Cal., Oct. 2. J. H. WAGGONER.