AdventAI

IS IT A SIMILAR CASE?

By D. T. Bourdeau

From Review and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 42., October 23, 1883

BY ELD. D. T. BOURDEAU.

When we object to going to history or to the Fathers to prove that men should keep Sunday, an institution neither found in nor established by the Bible, we are sometimes met with a plea like this: “You cannot prove the divine origin of the Bible, or show the fulfillment of prophecy without appealing to history.” But is this a similar case? We think not. As to the divine origin of the Bible, it is first demonstrated by intrinsic proof,—proof found in the Bible itself. In the case of the fulfillment of prophecy, we have first in prophecy itself history given in advance. Do we bring in secular history? In so doing we present a human edition agreeing with the divine, which has the priority every time. No moral duty originates with secular history, or even with prophecy. In these two instances on which the objector would base his plea, we have a starting point in the Bible. But not so in the case of Sunday-keeping.

What we do object to is to giving secular history the priority in settling the matter of religious faith and practice. What we, as Protestants, do enter our solemn protest against, is assigning to secular history and to the Fathers the office that the Almighty has assigned only to his infallible word; following the example of the Pharisees of old and of the Romish church since Christ, in exalting tradition above the Word of God, and making void the commandments of God by tradition. Mark 7, etc. We protest against going to history and to the Fathers to establish a doctrine or a duty not found in the Bible. The moment we do this we leave the platform of Protestantism,—the Bible, and the Bible alone as our rule of faith and practice,—and step on the platform of the Roman Catholic church,—first tradition, then afterward the Bible,—and should, to be consistent, adopt all the dogmas of that church which are based on tradition.

If we are to follow the faith and practices of professors of Christianity in the past, as set forth in history, surely we will have to pursue a zig-zag course. For what have not professors of Christianity believed and practiced?

Therefore we say: First settle the Sabbath question by the Bible. If we go to history, to the Fathers, or to tradition, let it be as a matter of after-consideration. Let us never be guilty of giving to things of a human origin the office and weight which, by right and the nature of things, belong alone to things of God’s own creation.