PROPHETS AND THEIR PREROGATIVES.
By W. H. Littlejohn
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN. It is well known to those acquainted with Seventh-day Adventists, that they claim to have in their midst a manifestation of spiritual gifts. They believe that for the last thirty-nine years the Lord has at sundry times spoken to them through the person of Mrs. E. G. White. This peculiar tenet of their faith is exceedingly unpopular at the present time, and is made the grand center of attack by their opponents. This is not surprising when we remember two things: First, that there is in our day an almost universal unbelief in the perpetuity of the prophetic gift; and, secondly, that were our opponents to concede that the miraculous manifestations found among us are genuine, they would also be compelled to admit the correctness of the views which we hold in regard to the Sabbath and other points which have been approved by the manifestation in question. The lines of argument which are resorted to for the purpose of overthrowing the claim of Mrs. White are various. Some of them relate to the general doctrine of the perpetuity of spiritual gifts; others to considerations of a personal nature. It is the purpose of the writer of this article to consider only two criticisms which are of the latter character. The first of these is based upon the fact that Mrs. White is in the habit of quoting from visions, which she claims were given to her some time in the past, such portions and such only as may suit her present purpose. It is objected, for example, that in a little work entitled “Experience and Views,” put forth by her in 1851, she declares that the Lord showed to her certain things in a vision which she had years before, and that in doing so, she left out of the work in question all mention of certain other things which she saw in the same connection. These omissions, it is claimed, cover about fifty lines of the original vision as published elsewhere. The gravity of this charge depends upon two things: First, whether in her later work, she claimed to give all which she had seen in the vision to which reference was made; and, secondly, whether it is the province of a prophet to reproduce at any given time such portions of a vision as may best serve his purpose at the time being, while leaving out certain other portions which, to his mind, are not important to the object which he has in view. As regards the first of these positions, it is enough to say that Mrs. White nowhere states in “Experience and Views” (the work in which it is claimed that the omission occurs) that she is giving the whole of the original vision to which she is referring. Had she done so, then the charge of dishonesty might have been urged with great force. Inasmuch, however, as she did not do so, that charge could not be maintained, and the whole discussion must turn on the question found in the second proposition given above; i. e., the right of a prophet to narrate such portions of a given prophecy as he may think expedient at the time, leaving out such other portions as in his judgment it may seem advisable to omit. It is frankly conceded that in “Experience and Views” Mrs. White did not mention certain things which she saw at the same time at which she had a view of the things narrated in that work. It is denied, however, that those portions that are omitted contained anything which was untrue in fact, or which was of such a nature that she was ashamed to have it republished. There is not one sentiment in the omitted passages which is not in harmony with the faith of Seventh-day Adventists at the present time. We must therefore look for the occasion of the omission in some other direction. We understand that Mrs. White claims that the reason why, in this as in other cases, she has omitted certain parts of certain visions, is found in the circumstance that in her judgment they possess simply a local, or temporary interest, or because brevity required that she should only reproduce those portions of her previous visions which would be likely to conduce to the highest interests of those for whom she may have written at any given time. To our mind, such a defense on the part of Mrs. White is perfectly satisfactory. In matters of this kind, the prophetess herself must be the sole judge. To take the position that she has no right to select out certain things which have been shown to her, without making mention of certain other things which she saw at the same time, would be preposterous in the extreme, as well as unscriptural,—preposterous, because in a single vision, matters are presented before her mind of a widely varying nature. Some of them relate to individuals, some to the church at large, and some, perhaps, to national affairs. Now suppose, for example, that she wished to communicate to the church at large that which had been shown her respecting their spiritual condition; would any man insist that while doing so it would be necessary for her to narrate all which she had seen at the same time concerning individuals and nations? Once more: Suppose she should wish to state to a single individual that which had been revealed to her concerning his moral status. Will it be required that before entering upon that task she should pause to communicate to him all which had been revealed to her concerning a score of other men? If such were the case, we hardly know which should be pitied the more, the prophetess who is compelled to write and re-write whole books in order to reach the end of communicating to an individual that which might have been stated in a few words, or the individual himself, who would be compelled to read whole volumes in order to obtain the information which was really included in a few lines. Common sense would teach one that the Lord would never require at the hands of any one so unreasonable a thing. It would also dictate that a prophet must have the prerogative of determining how much or how little of what he had previously seen should be employed on any given occasion. In harmony with the decisions of human judgment on this point, is the practice of inspired men as recorded in the word of God. By way of illustrating this point, attention might be called to the vision which Paul saw near Damascus. It will not be disputed that Luke was guided by the Holy Spirit in writing out the account which he gave of that event. It will be admitted, also, that if Paul, in the two addresses delivered by him to the mob at Jerusalem and before Agrippa at Cesarea, withheld anything from the account which he gave of the vision at Damascus, it was right for him to do so. For the purpose of determining whether he did give the vision in full on both of those occasions, and also in order that one may decide whether Luke recorded the vision in question in precisely the same words in which Paul narrated it, we append the account of the matter as given by Luke in the Acts. It is as follows: “And as he journeyed, he came near Damascus; and suddenly there shined round him a light from heaven; and he fell to the earth, and heard a voice saying unto him, Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me? And he said, Who art thou, Lord? and the Lord said, I am Jesus whom thou persecutest; it is hard for thee to kick against the pricks. And he trembling and astonished said, Lord, what wilt thou have me to do? And the Lord said unto him, Arise, and go into the city, and it shall be told thee what thou must do.” It will be observed that the phraseology of the above differs considerably from that employed by Paul when speaking of the same occurrence in the 22d and 26th chapters of Acts. It will be noticed, also, that the record of Luke is much more brief than the narrative of Paul. Luke’s account is embraced in fifteen lines of the Bible, while that of Paul, as given in the 22d of Acts, covers eighteen lines; and the one by the same apostle in the 26th chapter has twenty-six lines. Thus it appears that the shorter account, as given by Luke, is not so long by eleven lines, as the longer one given by Paul, and that the account given by Paul, in Acts 22, is eight lines shorter than the account of the same event as given by him in Acts 26. But these are not the most important discrepancies to which attention is called. If the reader will turn to the 22d and 26th594 chapters of the book of Acts, and peruse the addresses which Paul made to the Jews at Jerusalem, and to Agrippa at Cesarea, respectively, he will find that Paul on these two occasions, varied his account of the vision at Damascus very materially, leaving out, in one, important facts and statements which are given in the other, and vice versa. Take, for example, the account in the 22d chapter, verses 6–10. There we have the following words, which Paul employed in narrating the vision at Jerusalem, but which he left out entirely when speaking of the same occurrence to Agrippa at Cesarea: “And the Lord said unto me, Arise, and go into Damascus, and there it shall be told thee of all things which are appointed for thee to do.” Again: In Acts 26:13–18, we have the following words, which Paul employed in rehearsing the vision which he saw at Damascus, which words have nothing to answer to them in his narration of the same vision to the Jews at Jerusalem: “It is hard for thee to kick against the pricks. And I said, Who art thou, Lord? And he said, I am Jesus whom thou persecutest. But rise, and stand upon thy feet; for I have appeared unto thee for this purpose, to make thee a minister and a witness both of these things which thou hast seen, and of those things in the which I will appear unto thee; delivering thee from the people, and from the Gentiles, unto whom now I send thee, to open their eyes, and to turn them from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and inheritance among them which are sanctified by faith that is in me.” It will be discovered at once, that the foregoing extracts are neither inconsiderable in size, when the length of the vision is taken into account, nor unimportant, as it regards the character of their contents. They both embody words of Christ, containing important directions or explanations. The vision was not complete without them. By omitting them, therefore, Paul committed a very grave offense, provided they are correct who insist that prophets have no right to select from their visions such portions as they may deem it expedient to narrate at any given time, leaving out such other portions as they may think advisable. What shall we say, therefore, respecting the theory of the persons in question. If it be a sound one, it impeaches the great apostle to the Gentiles. Shall we throw Paul overboard, and adhere to the opinions of those who virtually challenge his right to do what he did? Or shall we conclude that Paul’s course, sanctioned as it was, by the Holy Spirit, was proper, and that these modern critics stand condemned by the record of the New Testament? It will not take long for the humble believer in the inspiration of the Bible to decide that it would be safer for him to recognize the right of Paul to do as he did, than it would for him to adopt a conclusion which would rob him of all his confidence in Paul as one who, agreeably to the vision at Damascus, was chosen to do the very work which he did both at Jerusalem and at Cesarea; that is, to declare Christ before the kings and rulers of the earth. Having come to this conclusion, he will find no difficulty in harmonizing it with the dictates of sound philosophy; since a moment’s thought will convince him that it would not be expedient for a public teacher like the great apostle to the Gentiles to present to every congregation a statement in full of everything which had at any time been revealed to him by the Spirit of the Lord. But let us return, now, to the point which we were considering when the practice of Paul was taken up, by way of establishing a principle which should govern us in determining the prerogative of Mrs. E. G. White when acting as a prophetess. We think it is safe to decide that the intelligent reader has already concluded that those occupy untenable ground who objected to her course because she is in the habit of quoting certain portions of visions given to her in the past, as the circumstances of the case may seem to demand, leaving out certain other portions as her judgment may dictate. He will see, at once, that if the objection offered would invalidate the claims of Mrs. White, they would also overturn those of Paul, and, indeed, every other prophet whose writings are found in the sacred Scriptures. Before closing this article, it might be well to consider, in brief, one other stricture which is frequently pronounced upon the course pursued by Mrs. White, in the matter of allowing a few of her early writings to go out of print. It is claimed that such a course proves a disposition to suppress such writings on account of the character of their contents. The syllogism which they employ would run somewhat as follows: 1. Whatever God inspires any prophet to write or speak, it is the duty of the said prophet to keep the same in print for the benefit of the church for all time to come. 2. Mrs. White has failed to do this. 3. Therefore Mrs. White has committed a grievous wrong, which should destroy confidence in her prophetic gift. It is not a little astonishing that this logic, if it may be called such, should have so much weight as it appears to have with many. The fact is that it really has no force whatever. If it could be shown, which it cannot, that the contents of those writings were objectionable in themselves, then the case would be different; since it might be fairly inferred that the objectionable features were the real occasion of the disappearance of the writings in question. The mere omission to reprint, however, is very far from proving bad intention on the part of Mrs. White. It is demonstrable that her published views will fill more volumes than those of any writer whose productions are found in the Scriptures. They now cover several thousand 12mo. pages, and constitute nearly ninety-nine hundredths of all she has ever written for the public eye. So far as we are aware, there are at the present writing only a very few pages of her early productions which are not found in her published works. These are composed of several printed leaflets and cards, and perhaps two or three small tracts. The writings in question are very rare; but they are still possessed by a few of the pioneers of our work. The most of them were put forth to serve a special purpose in the matter of gathering out from the fragments of the “’44 movement” a company who should engage in giving the third angel’s message. Having accomplished the design for which they were put in print, they were very naturally allowed to go out of print when the editions in which they were issued were exhausted. Such a course was the more justifiable on account of the constantly pressing necessity of publishing new views, which not only contain all the important doctrines embraced in the publications in question, but, also, new light of great significance to those who were steadily emerging from the darkness and disappointment which marked the close of the “’44 movement” into the light and hope of those who suddenly discovered that God was opening before them a new and glorious mission in connection with the restoration of his downtrodden Sabbath. Having made a statement of the facts in the case as we understand them, it is now time to test the syllogism given above by the word of God. Can it be demonstrated from the Scriptures that it is the will of the Lord that everything that is given through inspiration should be handed down from generation to generation? If it is not, then the premises of the foregoing syllogisms are demonstrated to be unsound, and, consequently, the conclusion drawn therefrom to be unreliable. It is not a little mortifying to be compelled to admit that there are those who are so ignorant of the plainest facts concerning the word of God as not to know that, in all human probability, the inspired writings which the Bible contains are a very small portion of what the Lord has seen fit to give, in time past, by direct revelations. Take for example, the period between the creation and the flood, which covers about sixteen hundred years. We know that Enoch and Noah were prophets of the Lord. That many others likewise received revelations, there can be no doubt. That which was revealed to Enoch during the three hundred years when he walked with God, must have been very considerable in amount; and yet we have only the two verses in Jude which set forth anything which he ever saw in vision. That which is given us, also, respecting what was shown to Noah, renders it quite certain that he must have received much more through revelation than the record brings to view. Descending to the period between the flood and the first advent, it would be an easy matter to demonstrate that it would have taken hundreds of volumes to contain all that was shown to the children of Israel through prophets. It is enough for the well-informed reader, to call his attention to the numerous prophets who are but little more than mentioned by name in the Old Testament. He will perceive at once that possession of the gift furnishes a fair presumption that they must have seen much more than the brief reference to them indicates. Passing to the New Testament, we find the names of such prophets as Agabus, Simeon, Anna, the four daughters of Philip, etc., etc. So far as the daughters of Philip are concerned, not a solitary word of their production has ever come down to us. As it regards Agabus, Simeon, and Anna, but a few sentences from among their utterances have been preserved in the New Testament record. Besides the foregoing prophets which are mentioned by name, there was a host of men and women in the early church who possessed spiritual gifts and exercised them publicly, not one sentence of whose predictions has ever been recorded. Their names even, have passed into utter oblivion. 1 Cor. 1:1–8; 12:13, 14. Should it be objected that the cases of the prophets mentioned above are not parallel to that of Mrs. White, because their predictions were never written out, it would be sufficient to reply: First, that written predictions are no more sacred than oral ones; secondly, that it is highly probable that many of the foregoing prophets put their predictions in writing; thirdly, that we know of a certainty that not only brief prophecies have been written out and then lost sight of altogether, but, also, that whole books which were written by inspired men have never found their way into the sacred canons of the Old and New Testaments. In proof of this, attention is called to the following: “Now the rest of the acts of Solomon, first and last, are they not written in the book of Nathan the prophet, and in the prophecy of Ahijah the Shilonite, and in the vision of Iddo the seer against Jeroboam the son of Nebat?” 2 Chron. 9:29. On this verse Adam Clarke gives the subjoined comment: “These books are all lost.” Other books besides the foregoing might be referred to, were it necessary; these, however, are sufficient in number to prove that it has not been an uncommon thing for God to direct by his providence that even whole prophetic books should be allowed to pass into oblivion after they had accomplished the purpose for which they were brought into being. What, then, we inquire, shall be done with these facts? Shall we conclude, as the critics of Mrs. White (would be compelled to do should they reason in regard to them as they do in reference to the publications of Mrs. White), that either God or the prophets who wrote the books under consideration were ashamed of them and caused them to be “suppressed”? Such a question suggests its own answer. It is perfectly reasonable to conclude that God may with perfect propriety ordain that any given prophecy should be written out or put in print for the accomplishment of a definite purpose, and then be allowed to pass forever from public observation. But if God can do this without censure, it is not impossible that one of his prophets should be led by his Spirit to pursue a similar course of action without blame. The great mistake of the opponents of Mrs. White is attributable to the circumstance that they are ignorant of God’s dealings in such matters in time past. Their criticisms of Mrs. White have been based upon the hypothesis that a prophecy once put in print was of such a nature that it must always, from the very necessity of the case, be kept in print. This error being exploded, they will, if candid, find no difficulty in recognizing the right of Mrs. White to do as she has done: that is, to use her own judgment, in common with other prophets, both in regard to how much of a given vision should be quoted on any occasion, and whether it would be advisable to reprint every vision that had ever been put in type.